People can feel that Manning and Brady are still better than Rodgers is. I don't think so, but it's not crazy to feel that way.
To put those other three guys though above Aaron is flat out silly given the incredible importance of QB's in today's football and he's an elite QB.
Joe Thomas at 46 is beyond laughable, he has Dallas Clark above Thomas.

Suh i'd probably put next right after the elite quarterbacks. Witten is to high.