humanrefutation wrote:sdn40 wrote:humanrefutation wrote:
I'm not commenting on that - I doubt Gute would force anyone's hand like that at a position that is already thin.
I'm just pointing out that saying "Pettine is in charge of starters, not MM" is pretty silly when Pettine reports directly to MM. If McCarthy wants Pettine to play Josh Jones, he'll play Josh Jones.
Technically yes. But MM didn't hire Pettine to boss him around. The lineup is Pettines. And no, I don't think there is a scenario where MM would tell Pettine who to start. And that wasn't the main argument anyway
You don't know what McCarthy would do or wouldn't do. I have zero doubt that Mac gives Pettine rein to run his defense, but I also have zero doubt that he consults with Pettine and provides his input into the gameplan and approach. That is what head coaches do.
To make such a definitive statement otherwise is all speculation on your part. For you to call another poster "ignorant" on that basis is pretty silly.
The post was ignorant - I never called another poster ignorant. Gute doesn't cut guys to force others to play. Plain and simple. That was the comment I was referring to. If you want to call it speculation - so be it.