ReddManBogieMan wrote:I think that he can be comparable to Eli and Romo much more than a Brett Favre. I think he looked very similar to the way Eli played in the playoffs, and he played pretty close to Romo in that Week 12 game against the Cowgirls. He was pretty darn good in the preseason if I recall, something like 80% passing. With the weapons we got he should be able to put up 25-30 TD's next year.
Theres so many things wrong with that its hard to pick where to begin.
First im going to go with, This is about how he compares to young QBs. I dont see how Favre has anything to do with that. Secondly, Aaron Rodgers hasnt even started one game and youre putting him up with those two? Third, putting Eli up next to Romo is ridiculous. Yes you can say Romo hasnt won in the playoffs and that Eli has. But giving Eli credit for game managing (ie. dont try to win it, just dont **** up) and saying thats the same as a guy that wins you games is stupid. If you want to discuss Elis great play where he escaped all those lineman as an example of winning the game for a team, you should also remember the plays right before where he was an inch or two away from having a stupid pass picked off.
I can understand being hopeful and excited, but maybe you should wait until Rodgers at least starts in the NFL for a season at least before you put him with a guy who threw for over 4200 yards and 36 td passes last year.
)