RealGM

Who would you rather have Cutler or Rodgers? Cutler is very upset about the Broncos trying to trade him and then lying to him about it. Would you trade Rodgers for him if Cutler tries to force his way out of Denver?

I'd rather have Rodgers.

I'm a Brett Favre apologist who remains unconvinced by Aaron Rodgers. But, I'd still take him over Cutler any day of the week.

I'm I the only one who thinks Cutler is a total jerk, just from looking at his face? I don't know him personally, but he just seems to have a bad personality based upon the way he carries himself around his teammates, and around the media. Plus, he looks like a sleepwalking hobo.

Cutler may or may not be more talented, but Rodgers seems like the cooler cat, and the eventual better leader.

Cutler is a head case, Rodgers isn't. In his 3 years Cutler never had as good a year as Rodgers had in his first year starting.

Rodgers, without question.

Silly question. Rodgers by a landslide.

Arod

Rodgers.

Cutler has supreme talent but he comes as a very emo person. He looks more like a frat boy than a nfl qb. A-Rodg by a mile.

Actually Cutler, A-Rodg, and Big Ben are all tight.....I love Cutler's ability but he is a douche and he has way to much of a gun slinger mentality, those types rarely win championships.

an_also wrote:Cutler has supreme talent but he comes as a very emo person. He looks more like a frat boy than a nfl qb. A-Rodg by a mile.

Saying Rodgers by a mile is an exaggeration. Cutler throws more picks than i care for, but the Broncos defense was miserable last year and wasn't very good the year prior either. The only chance Denver had to win games last year was for the offense to score a ton of points because their defense couldn't stop anyone.

I'd rather have Rodgers also, but Cutler is a damn good young QB who should only get better, he just needs to grow up some.

El Duderino wrote:

an_also wrote:Cutler has supreme talent but he comes as a very emo person. He looks more like a frat boy than a nfl qb. A-Rodg by a mile.

Saying Rodgers by a mile is an exaggeration. Cutler throws more picks than i care for, but the Broncos defense was miserable last year and wasn't very good the year prior either. The only chance Denver had to win games last year was for the offense to score a ton of points because their defense couldn't stop anyone.

I'd rather have Rodgers also, but Cutler is a damn good young QB who should only get better, he just needs to grow up some.

Yup. I think it's very close.

I was exaggerating friends. I'm just not a fan of Cutlers mental state. I dont know if he's tough enough sometimes with the stuff he says. Big fan of his talent though.