Page 6 of 6

Re: OT: Patriots

Posted: Tue Dec 19, 2017 3:09 pm
by CeltsfaninDC
Homerclease wrote:
Captain_Caveman wrote:
Homerclease wrote:Not true, he wasn’t down by contact.


Doesn't matter if he was touched or not as far as calling it a completed pass. He was diving during the catch and had to maintain control all the way through the ground (unless ball never touches the ground).

I’m taking the play and basically breaking it in half. Part one - completed catch/establishing in bounds. Part two - football move and dive for the end zone. He grabs the ball and secures it, drops to one knee and reaches for the goal line. Should’ve been 6 points

You can break it up however you want, but thats not how it works. You assume he made the catch and THEN hit the ground but the rule is clear about this. Sorry, but you are 100% wrong here and arguing more just shows your ignorance of clearly stated rules that you've been shown here a number of times

Re: OT: Patriots

Posted: Tue Dec 19, 2017 4:00 pm
by Homerclease
CeltsfaninDC wrote:
Homerclease wrote:
Captain_Caveman wrote:
Doesn't matter if he was touched or not as far as calling it a completed pass. He was diving during the catch and had to maintain control all the way through the ground (unless ball never touches the ground).

I’m taking the play and basically breaking it in half. Part one - completed catch/establishing in bounds. Part two - football move and dive for the end zone. He grabs the ball and secures it, drops to one knee and reaches for the goal line. Should’ve been 6 points

You can break it up however you want, but thats not how it works. You assume he made the catch and THEN hit the ground but the rule is clear about this. Sorry, but you are 100% wrong here and arguing more just shows your ignorance of clearly stated rules that you've been shown here a number of times

Except the rule isn’t the case here. He had already made the catch. You can call it ignorance if you want to, doesn’t make you right or me wrong

Re: OT: Patriots

Posted: Tue Dec 19, 2017 7:09 pm
by CeltsfaninDC
Homerclease wrote:
CeltsfaninDC wrote:
Homerclease wrote:I’m taking the play and basically breaking it in half. Part one - completed catch/establishing in bounds. Part two - football move and dive for the end zone. He grabs the ball and secures it, drops to one knee and reaches for the goal line. Should’ve been 6 points

You can break it up however you want, but thats not how it works. You assume he made the catch and THEN hit the ground but the rule is clear about this. Sorry, but you are 100% wrong here and arguing more just shows your ignorance of clearly stated rules that you've been shown here a number of times

Except the rule isn’t the case here. He had already made the catch. You can call it ignorance if you want to, doesn’t make you right or me wrong

SIGH...... yes it is ignorance because you are choosing to ignore the specific rule that regulates this specific incident which makes you 100% wrong. You've tried to break it up, you've tried to use different criteria and you've failed....... even Tomlin agreed it was the right call.

Re: OT: Patriots

Posted: Sun Dec 24, 2017 7:32 pm
by threrf23
Well, I thought that was a catch (Bills game)...

Re: OT: Patriots

Posted: Mon Dec 25, 2017 2:03 am
by Bostondave
What a slog that was for 3qtrs. Then we broke it open. We need Gronk to stay healthy to stand an outside chance. Our D is hurting right now. Thank goodness Bills have no real pass rush.

Glad to see Gillesley back on the field.

Re: OT: Patriots

Posted: Mon Jan 8, 2018 2:32 am
by Bostondave
OK PNation, looks like Titans are up first. Then on to Pitt in the Conf championship, then it's SB against Phil.

Re: OT: Patriots

Posted: Sat Jan 13, 2018 4:59 am
by ash_k
Bostondave wrote:OK PNation, looks like Titans are up first. Then on to Pitt in the Conf championship, then it's SB against Phil.


What are you talking about? Phil will be eliminated tomorrow :wink:

Re: OT: Patriots

Posted: Sun Jan 14, 2018 12:35 am
by Bostondave
Good game here. Phil v Atl

Re: OT: Patriots

Posted: Sun Jan 14, 2018 12:38 am
by Bostondave
Wow. This is it for Atl. one play.

Re: OT: Patriots

Posted: Sun Jan 14, 2018 12:40 am
by Bostondave
Wow. Busted play. Phi wins.

Re: OT: Patriots

Posted: Sun Jan 14, 2018 1:28 am
by KGboss
Anyone breathing around here?

Re: OT: Patriots

Posted: Sun Jan 14, 2018 3:51 am
by Bostondave
This clearly is not the place to be.

Re: OT: Patriots

Posted: Sun Jan 14, 2018 4:18 am
by ash_k
Do the General board for Football..it is 'better'...this one has gone quiet

Re: OT: Patriots

Posted: Sun Jan 14, 2018 4:19 am
by ash_k