Post#3 » by dahntayJfanclub » Thu Jul 17, 2025 2:19 am
I think there are 3 major scenarios to consider:
1) Nembhard turns the flashes of brilliance (and general grit) into sustained borderline-stardom as a focal point. If he takes that step, I think they'd manage 47-48 wins. So many of the other players know exactly how to play now. And Nembhard has the skills. A sustained 17/8/4 line would do a lot to stabilize things. If he trades some of his effort on defense for effort on offense, that would help a team that needs to keep its flow without Haliburton.
2) Siakam loses his edge. He came here to play with Haliburton and Turner. He's already 31. Maybe his level of effort drops, he gets the minor injury bug, and/or he tries to engineer a move. He seems like such a professional, but stranger things have happened. That would sap the team's energy, and I could see a 33 win season, or even a full-on tank with everyone suddenly noticing their minor injuries.
3) More of the same, minus Haliburton. I think the bigs will find a way to manage 75% of Myles' value. I'd still pick the over, at 41 wins. Siakam, Nesmith, Nembhard, Mathurin, McConnell, and Toppin can still make a lot of winning plays. And that finals run should have cemented the understanding of what it takes.
The Pacers have enough good players. I've seen enough of Mathurin's game and attitude to know he probably won't be a high level starter (would love if he proved me wrong). So his development will matter in terms of long term assets, but I doubt it'll make a big difference in our win total. If he stagnates, we'll have other players to step up. If he thrives, they'll lose opportunities. I just don't see how he's worth as much to the Pacers as he would be to a team more suited to his skill set.
I'm cautiously optimistic that the first scenario is the most likely. So I'll go with 47 wins.
The wildcard is Nesmith. He's shown a clever midrange game at times, which would unlock a deadly element to his game. But his handle is so poor that he can't get those looks unless the opponent is unprepared. If he can tighten that up, the sky is the limit. But I don't think it's likely.