RealGM

Here's a cool game that should invoke some interest in this board.

Rules: Copy and Paste this list in each reply, then add a point to a player you want to keep while subtracting a point from a player you'd like to get rid of. You can only reply twice a day, roughly once every twelve hours.

I'll manage it when needed, but if everyone gets it...it should manage itself.

It's easy for the NBA with only twelve players and a few coaches, so I've adapted it here. Using just the offensive skill positions. We'll do the defense if this goes well. I assume it'll take a few months with our slow traffic.

I've also made my first reply...

A.J. Feeley - 9 (-1)
Kevin Kolb - 10
Donovan McNabb -10
Correll Buckhalter - 10
Brian Westbrook - 11 (+1)
Lorenzo Booker - 10
Hank Baskett - 10
Reggie Brown - 10
Kevin Curtis - 10
Greg Lewis - 10
L.J. Smith - 10
Matt Schobel - 10
Andy Reid - 10
Marty Mornhinweg - 10

Am I going to be doing this myself?

A.J. Feeley - 9
Kevin Kolb - 10
Donovan McNabb -11 (+1)
Correll Buckhalter - 10
Brian Westbrook - 11
Lorenzo Booker - 10
Hank Baskett - 10
Reggie Brown - 10
Kevin Curtis - 10
Greg Lewis - 10
L.J. Smith - 10
Matt Schobel - 9 (-1)
Andy Reid - 10
Marty Mornhinweg - 10

A.J. Feeley - 10
Kevin Kolb - 10
Donovan McNabb -10
Correll Buckhalter - 10
Brian Westbrook - 12 (+1)
Lorenzo Booker - 10
Hank Baskett - 10
Reggie Brown - 10
Kevin Curtis - 10
Greg Lewis - 9 (-1)
L.J. Smith - 10
Matt Schobel - 10
Andy Reid - 10
Marty Mornhinweg - 10

I don't know if I did that write? I copied the list, pasted it, added 1the player I'd like to keep and subtracted on to the player I don't want.

Yes, for the most part. You just forgot to make Westbrook's total 12...I edited it for you.

A.J. Feeley - 10
Kevin Kolb - 10
Donovan McNabb -10
Correll Buckhalter - 10
Brian Westbrook - 12
Lorenzo Booker - 10
Hank Baskett - 9 (-1)
Reggie Brown - 10
Kevin Curtis - 11 (+1)
Greg Lewis - 9
L.J. Smith - 10
Matt Schobel - 10
Andy Reid - 10
Marty Mornhinweg - 10

m23uza1hem36...please adjust the tally of the player you add/subtract from...I edited your post from Thursday again...so they are all up-to-date...and make sure you copy the last post...

A.J. Feeley - 8 (-1)
Kevin Kolb - 10
Donovan McNabb - 12 (+1)
Correll Buckhalter - 10
Brian Westbrook - 12
Lorenzo Booker - 10
Hank Baskett - 0 (-1)
Reggie Brown - 10
Kevin Curtis - 11 (+1)
Greg Lewis - 9
L.J. Smith - 10
Matt Schobel - 10
Andy Reid - 10
Marty Mornhinweg - 10

^^
Ehh...sorry, I've never done this so let me get this right,

I copy MY previous post and continue from there?

For example:

Day 1: McNabb- 10 (+1)
Westbrook- 10 (-1)
blah1- 10
blah2-10
Day 2: McNabb- 11
Westbrook - 9
Blah1- 10 (+1)
Blah2- 10 (-1)

Is that right?

You definitely got the concept, and no worries. But when you add a point (+1) to a player...adjust the tally right then...

Here's an example...

Previous Post:
McNabb: 10
Westbrook: 10

Reply:
McNabb: 9 (-1)
Westbrook: 11 (+1)

Here's my reply...just to remind, you can do it twice in a day, usually in the morning and night.

A.J. Feeley - 8
Kevin Kolb - 10
Donovan McNabb - 12
Correll Buckhalter - 9 (-1)
Brian Westbrook - 13 (+1)
Lorenzo Booker - 10
Hank Baskett - 0 (-1)
Reggie Brown - 10
Kevin Curtis - 11 (+1)
Greg Lewis - 9
L.J. Smith - 10
Matt Schobel - 10
Andy Reid - 10
Marty Mornhinweg - 10

A.J. Feeley - 7 (-1)
Kevin Kolb - 10
Donovan McNabb - 13 (+1)
Correll Buckhalter - 9
Brian Westbrook - 13
Lorenzo Booker - 10
Hank Baskett - 9
Reggie Brown - 10
Kevin Curtis - 11
Greg Lewis - 9
L.J. Smith - 10
Matt Schobel - 10
Andy Reid - 10
Marty Mornhinweg - 10

A.J. Feeley - 10
Kevin Kolb - 10
Donovan McNabb -10
Correll Buckhalter - 8 (-1)
Brian Westbrook - 14 (+1)
Lorenzo Booker - 10
Hank Baskett - 9
Reggie Brown - 10
Kevin Curtis - 11
Greg Lewis - 9
L.J. Smith - 10
Matt Schobel - 10
Andy Reid - 10
Marty Mornhinweg - 10

A.J. Feeley - 7
Kevin Kolb - 9 (-1)
Donovan McNabb - 13
Correll Buckhalter - 8
Brian Westbrook - 14
Lorenzo Booker - 10
Hank Baskett - 9
Reggie Brown - 10
Kevin Curtis - 12 (+1)
Greg Lewis - 9
L.J. Smith - 10
Matt Schobel - 10
Andy Reid - 10
Marty Mornhinweg - 10

A.J. Feeley - 10
Kevin Kolb - 10
Donovan McNabb -10
Correll Buckhalter - 8
Brian Westbrook - 14
Lorenzo Booker - 10
Hank Baskett - 9
Reggie Brown - 10
Kevin Curtis - 12 (+1)
Greg Lewis - 8 (-1)
L.J. Smith - 10
Matt Schobel - 10
Andy Reid - 10
Marty Mornhinweg - 10

A.J. Feeley - 7
Kevin Kolb - 9
Donovan McNabb - 13
Correll Buckhalter - 8
Brian Westbrook - 15 (+1)
Lorenzo Booker - 10
Hank Baskett - 9
Reggie Brown - 10
Kevin Curtis - 12
Greg Lewis - 8
L.J. Smith - 10
Matt Schobel - 9 (-1)
Andy Reid - 10
Marty Mornhinweg - 10

PacerPerspective, I did update my most recent one with the Plus/Minus tallies, pay close attention to how Curtis was 11, I added plus 1 to him and his total is 12, Lewis was 9, I subtracted 1, he's 8 on that post. I couldn't reply to your message so I had to reply to it here.

A.J. Feeley - 7
Kevin Kolb - 9
Donovan McNabb - 13
Correll Buckhalter - 8
Brian Westbrook - 16 (+1)
Lorenzo Booker - 10
Hank Baskett - 9
Reggie Brown - 10
Kevin Curtis - 12
Greg Lewis - 8
L.J. Smith - 10
Matt Schobel - 8 (-1)
Andy Reid - 10
Marty Mornhinweg - 10

A.J. Feeley - 10
Kevin Kolb - 10
Donovan McNabb -10
Correll Buckhalter - 8
Brian Westbrook - 15 (+1)
Lorenzo Booker - 10
Hank Baskett - 8 (-1)
Reggie Brown - 10
Kevin Curtis - 12
Greg Lewis - 8
L.J. Smith - 10
Matt Schobel - 10
Andy Reid - 10
Marty Mornhinweg - 10

m23uza1hem36,

Please heed my advice on this game...compare my post above to yours. Feeley should have 7, and so on...

Try and edit it...if you can't, I'll do it tomorrow.

I suck at this
I'll try one one on a different board and see if I get it right, no need to annoy you.

Updated...

A.J. Feeley - 6 (-1)
Kevin Kolb - 9
Donovan McNabb - 14 (+1)
Correll Buckhalter - 8
Brian Westbrook - 17
Lorenzo Booker - 10
Hank Baskett - 8
Reggie Brown - 10
Kevin Curtis - 12
Greg Lewis - 8
L.J. Smith - 10
Matt Schobel - 8 (-1)
Andy Reid - 10
Marty Mornhinweg - 10