CrimsonCrew wrote:Scoots1994 wrote:CrimsonCrew wrote:The Compton addition was a mistake from the beginning. We would have been better off sticking with Person - and that's really saying something.
You know Person retired right?
Person retired after he was cut. I bet he would have stuck out another year on the Niners.
Don't get me wrong. I'm not saying Person would have been any kind of solution. Just that he was better than Compton.
I liked the McKivitz pick because he's super smart and is 100% dog, I figured he'd be a multi-year development player who could eventually earn some PT. But I'm surprised he's done as well as he has in camp. To start he was apparently getting his butt kicked all over the place, but has significantly impressed as camp has gone on. He may make the roster and be the first OL off the bench for the first couple games. He CAN play anywhere on the line, but I think he's most likely a right guard in the NFL.
It just re-iterates that the Lynchahan value OTs and Cs but the guard positions they are fine with journeymen taking up the snaps.
Need to find a replacement for Richburg ... he costs too much and misses too many games.
Williams, Tomlinson, Richburg, Brunskill, McGlinchey is a good line.
Skule, Compton, Garland, McKivitz is pretty meh. Cheap and functional may be the best NFL teams can do these days and that group is cheap and functional.
Garland may be the most critical because of Richburg's injury history. Skule will be important as I assume the starting OTs will miss at least 3 games.