Big J wrote:CrimsonCrew wrote:Not great news, but it's only a week or so and if it leads to a better result, it's well worth it.
I think regardless of what happens with Purdy, we go into this season with Lance. The offense around him should be as good if not better than it was at this time last year, assuming Big Trent doesn't hang them up. We'll have to replace McGlinchey and maybe Brendel, but those guys aren't exactly world-beaters.
And more importantly, if Lance is possibly the future, we need to see what he can do. He just didn't get a chance to show much last year. He needs sustained playing time. I find it incredibly ironic that Shanahan, who had Garoppolo as his QB for years, is apparently reluctant to let the leash off of Trey because of his performance in practices. Garoppolo is a notoriously bad practice player. But get him in a game, and he does pretty well (still not great). What if Lance is that guy, too? Even if it's ugly at times, he gets the job done. His play at North Dakota had elements of that. But we won't know unless Shanahan gets him out there and opens up the playbook.
I really hope we see Lance getting a LONG look in the preseason. The dude needs live game action.
Problem is that this team is ready to win a Super Bowl right now. We don't have time to let Lance make mistakes. Bringing in a proven vet makes the most sense.
You need elite QB play to win it all and we keep falling into the trap of settling for average QB play because we're so close to winning a Super Bowl with the roster we have now.
If we had elite QB play we would've had 2 maybe 3 Super Bowl titles in the last 4 years instead of 1 Super Bowl loss and 2 NFC championship losses.
I don't know if Lance is the guy but he clearly has all the tools the elite guys have and the team needs to fully commit to him to see if he can put it together and be that guy and if not keep looking.
We need a veteran option as a backup but there isn't a guy out there that we could realistically add that can go toe to toe with the other elite QBs that we'd see in a deep playoff run or Super Bowl.
I like Purdy but I fear he's just going to be a career overachiever that's popular with fans due to being that scrappy underdog type but will smash his head against his ceiling once he faces guys that can do everything he can but better.
Purdy reminds me of a Doug Flutie type that is beloved by the team, fans, and everybody but won jack squat ultimately.