Off-Season Miscellaneous
Posted: Mon Aug 5, 2019 10:14 pm
Sports is our Business
https://forums.realgm.com/boards/
https://forums.realgm.com/boards/viewtopic.php?f=18&t=1880655
QRich3 wrote:I never really cared about this all-time rankings, but I'd have Lebron comfortably ahead of Kobe if I had to rank them. For most of his career Kobe was a one dimensional scorer, and not an incredibly efficient one. Which still makes for a pretty great player, not gonna lie, but not great enough to be mentioned in the same breath than all time greats that affected the game in every area, as Lebron does/did. Kobe was a good wing defender early in his career, but that went away pretty quickly, and while his assist numbers are not bad, he was never a great playmaker. His +/- numbers never suggested he impacted the scoreboard as much as his contemporary stars, and he fell off quickly after his 2010 last ring, which makes his prime shorter than Lebron.
His legend status has more to do with aesthetics and a few memorable moments than it does with his on court impact. Lebron contributed considerably more to his teams' wins than Kobe did.
nickhx2 wrote:QRich3 wrote:I never really cared about this all-time rankings, but I'd have Lebron comfortably ahead of Kobe if I had to rank them. For most of his career Kobe was a one dimensional scorer, and not an incredibly efficient one. Which still makes for a pretty great player, not gonna lie, but not great enough to be mentioned in the same breath than all time greats that affected the game in every area, as Lebron does/did. Kobe was a good wing defender early in his career, but that went away pretty quickly, and while his assist numbers are not bad, he was never a great playmaker. His +/- numbers never suggested he impacted the scoreboard as much as his contemporary stars, and he fell off quickly after his 2010 last ring, which makes his prime shorter than Lebron.
His legend status has more to do with aesthetics and a few memorable moments than it does with his on court impact. Lebron contributed considerably more to his teams' wins than Kobe did.
pretty much all this
lebron's just been the higher impact player on both ends of the floor. kobe's status has quite a bit to do with big shots and "KOBE!!!!!!"
Young Sterling wrote:Ok here's the thing. You know how there's a saying about stats not taking everything into consideration? It's totally true in cases like Avery Bradley last year, but I don't think it does a good job of measuring some other guys, Kobe included. The inefficiency in his shots throughout the season is one thing, but he becomes a different animal when Championships are on the line. Ultimately, you want a player not because of the stats he pads up, but because you want a guy who can win you a title. Take Kawhi for instance. With all the load management he's doing, he may not win an MVP award. James Harden pads better regular season stats then him. It's just, the more veteran players know regular season doesn't mean as much as the Playoffs. Even if Kawhi never wins a regular season MVP, he's more likely than not gonna get the Finals MVP along with that Larry O' B so long as he can sniff playoffs. He understands what's important.
QRich3 wrote:Young Sterling wrote:Ok here's the thing. You know how there's a saying about stats not taking everything into consideration? It's totally true in cases like Avery Bradley last year, but I don't think it does a good job of measuring some other guys, Kobe included. The inefficiency in his shots throughout the season is one thing, but he becomes a different animal when Championships are on the line. Ultimately, you want a player not because of the stats he pads up, but because you want a guy who can win you a title. Take Kawhi for instance. With all the load management he's doing, he may not win an MVP award. James Harden pads better regular season stats then him. It's just, the more veteran players know regular season doesn't mean as much as the Playoffs. Even if Kawhi never wins a regular season MVP, he's more likely than not gonna get the Finals MVP along with that Larry O' B so long as he can sniff playoffs. He understands what's important.
I'd agree with that, problem is, that's more legend than truth. Kobe's scoring efficiency actually drops in the postseason, as it does with most players. His +/- numbers drop in the postseason, as most players do since the competition is harder. A guy like Kawhi, he actually does improve his efficiency numbers in the postseason, which were already considerably better than a guy like Kobe (60 TS% to 55 TS% in RS), to a crazy 62 TS% in the postseason.
Again, Kobe's reputation is more legend than truth. If what you say actually applied to him, I'd agree, but it doesn't, he just shoots more, and happened to hit a bunch of big shots in memorable moments. He's a scorer, a damn good one that can carry all the volume you ask of him -and that's an important skill- but far from good enough to be considered among all time greats.