ImageImageImageImageImage

2010 report card

Moderators: Kilroy, Danny Darko, TyCobb

User avatar
TonyMontana
RealGM
Posts: 11,726
And1: 398
Joined: Apr 27, 2006
Location: Loungin in the Cali sun.
     

2010 report card 

Post#1 » by TonyMontana » Fri Jun 18, 2010 6:10 pm

So lets grade this teams for 2010 and where do you see improvements needed.

Kobe Bryant A Enough said

Ron Artest B+ He came through for us time and time again. Kept his cool. He is a keeper.

Shannon Brown B Been an X factor at times but Im hoping he can start next year. he is a Keeper.

Andrew Bynum C and I dont blame him for being MIA since he was injured, but I think maybe we need to trade him.

Jordan Farmar C He came through in the Finals and a few playoff games. I dont think he will resign.

Derek Fisher A- Time and time again he came through. A true warrior but I think its time for him to come off the bench.

Pau Gasol A Enough Said

Lamar Odom B+ We all know he comes and goes when he wants but I still think he did a great job for us except a few games in the finals where he was MIA

Josh Powell C+ he came through and played his role. Keeper

Sasha Vujacic D- I really dont have anything to say about this guy and I hope we trade him and let him go. Other than the two freethrows I think he sucks and he will never be the machine anymore.

Luke Walton D He needs to go and I cant wait till he is gone.

Dj Mbenga C+ Love the guy and I cant ask for more. He did okay when he got on the court.

Adam Morrison :lol:

Phil Jackson A I hope he resings but he might not. Replacement Im hoping for is either Shaw or B Scott.
Image
Asianiac_24
General Manager
Posts: 8,504
And1: 3,999
Joined: Jul 28, 2008
Contact:
   

Re: 2010 report card 

Post#2 » by Asianiac_24 » Fri Jun 18, 2010 6:44 pm

Kobe Bryant - A , played as I expected
Pau Gasol - A+ , really can't ask for more. Gasol was amazing throughout the playoffs and really exceeded my expectations
Artest - B , Great defense but his inconsistency and hesitance behind the 3 sometimes really held us back
Odom - B , inconsistent again, but had some great moments in the playoffs
Bynum - B , really fought hard and I am happy to see him compete despite of his injuries
Fisher - A , despite complaints about his defense, he has held his own against Deron/Nash and Allen in the Finals, along with some timely clutch shots
Farmar - C , even though he had some good moments, he was overall a liability on defense and made some dumb mistakes
Brown - C , he is chucking too much in the playoffs, played selfishly at times
Walton - F , he is just eating up our cap space with his dead weight contract IMO
Powell/Mbenga - C , really didn't see much of them
Sasha - D , I would give him a F if not for those 2 FTs. The machine is done
Morrison - F , didn't even cheer the team well

Phil - A , what more could you ask from a coach
User avatar
chefy
Head Coach
Posts: 7,014
And1: 658
Joined: Aug 14, 2006

Re: 2010 report card 

Post#3 » by chefy » Fri Jun 18, 2010 7:05 pm

kobe, gasol A+

artest, fish A- did what they supposed to do...artest played D, struggled with 3 pint shooting but hey nobody's perfet and he made up with it big time!...same with fish hes here for the playoffs and to be our leader and he delivered those (we still need a pointguard though :D).

odom B consistency

bynum -B injuries

farmar/brown C these dudes are expected to stepped up this year...they supposed to takeover fish's spot but no..their 3 point shooting got worse. their gifted athletes but they can't even outplay an old, slow guy, that has a ton of mileage in his body.

walton F still has no jumpshot, still can't hit threes, no D. I don't even know how this dude gets injured.

sasha A+ for getting maria sharopova

mbenga B works hard. he does his role: black shots, hustles.

morrison F

powell D his best attributes is hitting the midrange and I dont remember him hitting one since last year
User avatar
3-Pt_Shooter
Senior
Posts: 745
And1: 0
Joined: Aug 01, 2007
Location: Bay Area
     

Re: 2010 report card 

Post#4 » by 3-Pt_Shooter » Fri Jun 18, 2010 7:23 pm

TonyMontana wrote:So lets grade this teams for 2010 and where do you see improvements needed.

Kobe Bryant A Enough said

Ron Artest B+ He came through for us time and time again. Kept his cool. He is a keeper.

Shannon Brown B Been an X factor at times but Im hoping he can start next year. he is a Keeper.

Andrew Bynum C and I dont blame him for being MIA since he was injured, but I think maybe we need to trade him.

Jordan Farmar C He came through in the Finals and a few playoff games. I dont think he will resign.

Derek Fisher A- Time and time again he came through. A true warrior but I think its time for him to come off the bench.

Pau Gasol A Enough Said

Lamar Odom B+ We all know he comes and goes when he wants but I still think he did a great job for us except a few games in the finals where he was MIA

Josh Powell C+ he came through and played his role. Keeper

Sasha Vujacic D- I really dont have anything to say about this guy and I hope we trade him and let him go. Other than the two freethrows I think he sucks and he will never be the machine anymore.

Luke Walton D He needs to go and I cant wait till he is gone.

Dj Mbenga C+ Love the guy and I cant ask for more. He did okay when he got on the court.

Adam Morrison :lol:

Phil Jackson A I hope he resings but he might not. Replacement Im hoping for is either Shaw or B Scott.


Kobe A+... Proved that he's a great teammate after all.

Pau A... Grew in his toughness since the 08' Finals and was excellent complimentary player to Kobe.

Ron A-... Did his best to "fit in" with this championship team. And no ejections or blow ups all year!

Andrew C+... His productivity was down. But I give a lot of credit for playing with a painful injury (that just kept getting worse) all playoffs long.

Derek A-... His leadership and grittiness were huge for us this year. Bring him back next year, even if he just comes off the bench.

Lamar B... He answered the bell more often than not. But the Candyman needs to be more consistent. Still thinks he has a place as the leader of our second unit.

Shannon C+... Big play potential. Rim rattling dunks. But needs to understand that he is not Kobe. He played well for us overall though.

Jordan B-... Thought was one of our key guys off the bench this year and would like to see him back.

Luke C... Dealt with more injuries. But Luke has always been there for us when we needed him to come in to be a facilitator and play smart defense.

Sasha C-... I agree that we should trade him while we can. Thanks for the 2 free throws though.

Josh C... Great team guy who played his role.

DJ C... Another great team player. Would like to keep him around if possible.

Adam D... What can I say? I don't want to step on a guy when he's down. But at least he's a two-time NBA champion.

Phil A... Yet another masterful coaching performance by the zen master. Hope to see him and over-sized chair on the sidelines next year.
Image
DubaLakers
Banned User
Posts: 3,830
And1: 1
Joined: Jul 02, 2007
Location: OC, CA

Re: 2010 report card 

Post#5 » by DubaLakers » Fri Jun 18, 2010 7:38 pm

TonyMontana wrote:So lets grade this teams for 2010 and where do you see improvements needed.

Kobe Bryant A Enough said

Ron Artest B+ He came through for us time and time again. Kept his cool. He is a keeper.

Shannon Brown B Been an X factor at times but Im hoping he can start next year. he is a Keeper.

Andrew Bynum C and I dont blame him for being MIA since he was injured, but I think maybe we need to trade him.

Jordan Farmar C He came through in the Finals and a few playoff games. I dont think he will resign.

Derek Fisher A- Time and time again he came through. A true warrior but I think its time for him to come off the bench.

Pau Gasol A Enough Said

Lamar Odom B+ We all know he comes and goes when he wants but I still think he did a great job for us except a few games in the finals where he was MIA

Josh Powell C+ he came through and played his role. Keeper

Sasha Vujacic D- I really dont have anything to say about this guy and I hope we trade him and let him go. Other than the two freethrows I think he sucks and he will never be the machine anymore.

Luke Walton D He needs to go and I cant wait till he is gone.

Dj Mbenga C+ Love the guy and I cant ask for more. He did okay when he got on the court.

Adam Morrison :lol:

Phil Jackson A I hope he resings but he might not. Replacement Im hoping for is either Shaw or B Scott.


Did Morrison even shower or shave during the playoffs, he looks like he won a contest when he's sitting on the bench.

Brown is gone TM, he wants to test the market, he's too limited, great athlete, but not much of a shooter or a scorer. Dribbles dominant right handed thru traffic, like Big Game used to.

Powell is gone too Powell was a D in my book, Benga is a nice backup defender, but he didn't get any minutes so he must have a worse grade than Powell. Powell played dumb when he came in jacking shots like it wasn't that important to run the offense when he came in, like it was warmup or something.

Farmar gets a C-, he is fn out the door, Siberian Professional is his destination, few pg's in the league make worse decisions. His three shot was pretty at times, and he's quick and fast, but not much else.

I got no problem with Luke, he plays as hard as he can, but he's limited with what he can do, he's been injured all year with back issues, and he has little trade value, we're stuck with him, plus he's not scared, and he has a ton of exp.

I've come around on Sahsa I want to keep him for another year, because he's under contract of course, but he's not afraid, he hit some nice threes in the playoffs, even went to the basket a few times, nails FT's, and has a ton of playoff exp.
User avatar
Jase
RealGM
Posts: 13,051
And1: 158
Joined: Aug 01, 2008
Location: Grand Rapids, MI.

Re: 2010 report card 

Post#6 » by Jase » Fri Jun 18, 2010 7:50 pm

I would have given Pau an A until the Finals. He let KG mess with him and mess with his game. I don't care about the regular season when in comparison to the final round. A-.

I want to give Artest an A-, but his shot selection was still questionable. If he could tap into a conscious, offensively, he'd get more than a B+.

A- for Kobe. His shooting percentage and some of his shots showed a bit of regression, sadly. How awesome would he be if he was a 50% shooter from the field?
"A winner listens. A loser just waits until it's their turn to talk."
User avatar
Mamba Venom
RealGM
Posts: 17,979
And1: 582
Joined: Sep 07, 2005
Location: California
Contact:

Re: 2010 report card 

Post#7 » by Mamba Venom » Fri Jun 18, 2010 8:22 pm

Lamar was just a little better than average from what we expected. He wasnt the same Lamar from 2009 so I have to go w/ a C+

You have to understand its harder to be pissed off when you are in love

Ron Artest was an A++++++ in game 7, but a B- in the play-offs because of his loss of swagger ie hesitation.

Kobe was a A+ in the play-offs but a C- in game 7 despite his inner Dennis Rodman

Gasol was a European A+ which is called 1+ in Spain
Lakers are 22-3 in OT last 6 seasons:Kobe best OT closer!
Tee212
Lead Assistant
Posts: 4,782
And1: 423
Joined: Jan 10, 2009

Re: 2010 report card 

Post#8 » by Tee212 » Fri Jun 18, 2010 8:36 pm

You guys are pretty much spot on with every player. Again im sorry fisher for all my negativity.
magic1fan
Starter
Posts: 2,374
And1: 0
Joined: Oct 02, 2006
Location: The showitme era...

Re: 2010 report card 

Post#9 » by magic1fan » Fri Jun 18, 2010 9:42 pm

we are the world champs...everyone get's an A :D :D :D
Only on realgm is 27,000 points, 5 rings, 1 rs mvp and 2 finals mvp considered overrated!
DubaLakers
Banned User
Posts: 3,830
And1: 1
Joined: Jul 02, 2007
Location: OC, CA

Re: 2010 report card 

Post#10 » by DubaLakers » Fri Jun 18, 2010 10:01 pm

Tee212 wrote:You guys are pretty much spot on with every player. Again im sorry fisher for all my negativity.


Ha Tee, I love your honesty. Fish might have played his finest this playoffs, not so much offensively but defensively, and doing all the little things that matter so much in the long run. Think about it Westbrook is too fast for everybody, but then he had DWill(the best pg this season), Nashty, and then Rondo are you kidding me?! What a guantlet that is.

For sure Fisher's flop was perfected this year as the best in the NBA, because he can use his incredible hulk strength to make it look like it's a clear foul ;). He needs to teach Pau how to do it better, because Pau's is embarrasing at times, like he's taking the Nestea plunge.
User avatar
dockingsched
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 56,660
And1: 23,966
Joined: Aug 02, 2005
     

Re: 2010 report card 

Post#11 » by dockingsched » Sat Jun 19, 2010 3:02 pm

A+ pau gasol. you simply can't ask for more on and off the court.

A kobe bryant. fought through injuries, sat down when it was better for the team.

B+ ron artest. I thought he had a great regular season, doing exactly what he was brought in to do. too bad his injuries made him a terrible shooter in the playoffs.

B+ andrew bynum. he helped keep the lakers in a dominant position early on with his 20/10 tear. later on he struggled to adjust to a less scoring intense role. eventually he suffered his annual knee injuries, but this time he simply sucked it up. i expect big things from him next yr, health permitting.

B lamar odom. once again stepped up when bynum went down, struggled in the finals.


B derek fisher. was a pain to watch at times in the season, but like we should expect, stepped up in the playoffs. his leadership is also always understated.

C+ jordan farmar. i didn't have too much of a problem with jordan this season. he had his bright spots, and i thought he learned to be more aggressive towards the basket. defensively, effort was hardly there.

C shannon brown. he's a ball stopper, plain and simple. his exciting plays make up for his constant shot clock draining.

D+ sasha vujacic. has never lacked confidence, but he can't shoot anymore and he thinks he's a shut down defender. he's just pesky, and if he played like it, he wouldn't always put the other team in the penalty.

F luke walton. one of my favorites, but he's physically done.

F josh powell. this guy straight sucks. has no clue at all on defense, and is just a big shooting guard on offense.

F adam morrison. doesn't even look good in a suit.

B DJ Mbenga. love his effort, even though it leads to a 20 fouls per 48 minutes rate.
"We must try not to sink beneath our anguish, Harry, but battle on." - Dumbledore
User avatar
TruSkool
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,706
And1: 253
Joined: Jun 01, 2007
 

Re: 2010 report card 

Post#12 » by TruSkool » Sat Jun 19, 2010 3:07 pm

the only player who gets an A is pau gasol.....kobe, artest, and fisher get B's, the rest are in the C category
LAKESHOW
RealGM
Posts: 18,064
And1: 4,471
Joined: Mar 14, 2002
Location: HOME OF THE 17 TIME WORLD CHAMPIONS!

Re: 2010 report card 

Post#13 » by LAKESHOW » Sat Jun 19, 2010 4:33 pm

im a simple easy grader.

everyone gets an A except for the bench.

that needs to be improved.
Home of the 17 Time World Champions
User avatar
snaquille oatmeal
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 16,819
And1: 4,826
Joined: Nov 15, 2005
Location: San Diego
   

Re: 2010 report card 

Post#14 » by snaquille oatmeal » Sat Jun 19, 2010 5:12 pm

A pau gasol. solid, but needs to keep hitting the weights.

A kobe bryant. fought through injuries, keeps growing as a player.

B+ ron artest. I thought he had a great regular season, doing exactly what he was brought in to do. I'll take Ron over Trevor anytime.

B+ andrew bynum. he helped keep the lakers in a dominant position early on with his 20/10 tear. later on he struggled to adjust to a less scoring intense role. eventually he suffered his annual knee injuries, but this time he simply sucked it up. i expect big things from him next yr, health permitting.

B lamar odom. once again stepped up when bynum went down, struggled in the finals. should have taunted KG just to get in his head.


B derek fisher. was a pain to watch at times in the season, but like we should expect, stepped up in the playoffs. his leadership is also always understated. we still need a point a guard to start.

D jordan farmar. :wave:

D shannon brown. he's a ball stopper, plain and simple. his exciting plays make up for his constant shot clock draining.

D sasha vujacic. keep for one more season (contract season coming up :wink: ), I want more Dragic-Sasha romantic comedy drama.

F luke walton. :wave:

F josh powell. :wave:

F adam morrison. :wave:

B DJ Mbenga. Congo Cash stays
Forum permissions
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot trade for basketball reasons in this forum
You cannot but I can...five rings!
User avatar
TylersLakers
RealGM
Posts: 10,961
And1: 2,867
Joined: Jan 20, 2006
Location: Winnipeg Canada
     

Re: 2010 report card 

Post#15 » by TylersLakers » Sat Jun 19, 2010 7:13 pm

Kobe Bryant- A: Was our leader and played like his normal self for most of the season. After the All Star Break, he didn't play well because of injuries so that's why I don't give him an A+.. He carried us for most of the playoffs so you definitely have to recognize him for that.

Andrew Bynum- A-: I've got Andrew at a pretty high grade and I don't see how he doesn't deserve it. He played great most of the season until he got hurt down the stretch for the last 10-15 games, which proved to be pretty meaningless anyways. He was a big factor to this team and it was evident when he wasn't in the game. He's finally embraced the role of being our anchor on the defensive end and him and Pau Gasol really clicked this season, which is something we were all waiting for. You also can't forget what he did at the start of the season while Gasol couldn't play because of injury. 20 points, 10 rebounds, 2 blocks. Can you ask for anything more? Add in the fact the guy was playing in the playoffs on one leg and he had the balls and mental toughness to block it out and play well.

Pau Gasol- B+: Pau missed games early because of a hamstring issue, and there were some nights this season where he wasn't himself as he was trying to come back from the injury. He was even benched down the stretch of a couple games on the road where Andrew's toughness brought a different element. As the season grew though, he got back to being himself and played like it. He was excellent in the playoffs and the majority of the Finals, he dominated. A summer of rest is going to do him well and he'll come back and return to the "A" grade next season.

Ron Artest- B+: Came in a little too heavy from too much working out, if that's possible. It affected him early, but his defense was pretty damn good most of the season and it was a robbery he didn't make the All Defensive team. Offensively, he never really found himself or his niche in the triangle. He just needs to remember he was an 18 PPG scorer the majority of his career and I'm hoping he does a little more of it next season. In the playoffs, you couldn't have asked for a better defensive performance. He shut down Kevin Durant and limited Paul Pierce. That's the reason why we got him, when you look back on it. And if someone said to you at the start of the season, "If he shuts down Kevin Durant, is inconsistent offensively throughout the season, holds Paul Pierce to a low FG percentage in the Finals and we win the Chip," do you take it? I know I would have.

Lamar Odom- C+: Never had quite the impact this season off the bench and I thought he could have been a lot more aggressive since he had more time with that unit this season. I know we've been saying this his entire Laker career, but when he has a favorable match-up.. Damn, be aggressive. That said, he came through in the Phoenix series and is one of the leaders on this team. I still wouldn't trade him because you need three very good big men to win in this league and he provides that third option after Gasol and Bynum.

Derek Fisher- C+: Even though he was absolutely great the majority of the playoffs, you can't overlook the regular season he had. He can't stay in front of PG's in the regular season because it's such a work on his body and especially at his age. That said, he had his moments in the regular season knocking down shots like we expect and in the playoffs he was a new player for the most part, also which we expected. Big shot after big shot, and his defense was pretty damn good when he put forth a full effort and had a chance to prepare for each guy. Besides Westbrook, he was great against every other guard we went against. The extra stuff that he brings is a reason by itself why we have to bring him back. The vocal leadership, Kobe's trust, etc

Shannon Brown- C-: At this point, his role is to bring energy and those plays that can ignite a team. He did that and he's also another option on this team of a guy who can create his own shot. That said, if he returns next season, he needs to realize who he is. Knock down catch and shoot shots, be a slasher, and play hard nosed defense. He needs to be a Trevor Ariza type player from the guard position. He's got the talent to do it, that's not even a question.

Sasha Vujacic- D+: I really pull for Sasha but you just keep on waiting for him to be the player he was before he put the pen to the paper, and it just doesn't happen most of the time. And just when he was starting to get into a rhythm, he got hurt. He needs shots and a good amount of minutes off the bench and I think he's going to get that next season. It's also a contract year again for him, which helps us, for sure. He played pretty well in the Finals though and I'm hoping he works on his game this season and puts it to work next season.

Jordan Farmar- D-: This is one of those grades on one of those subjects in school where you were just about to fail the test and then got the last question right to break even and you can go home and tell mom and dad, "Yeah! I passed!" He doesn't play D, he's pretty selfish offensively, and he doesn't play his role. However, he does have a lot of talent and if he can get with the right team and possibly be a starter, I think he'll do a pretty solid job pushing tempo for a team that is lottery bound. With that said, he played pretty good in Game 6 and brought one of the moments of our season when he beat Rondo to that loose ball.

Josh Powell- C: Never got the minutes that he did last season, so it's hard to judge. But he's important just to the morale of the team and in the locker room. He's one of the best teammates and he's always ready to come in and play when needed.. the opportunity just never came. You also never hear him complain, which is another thing that I like about him. I hope we bring him back for around 1 million a season. He's going to test the market though and do what's best for his family, which he should do.

Luke Walton- F: It really sucks how much injuries have robbed this guy of being a pretty solid role player on a team. He used to be a solid outside shooter and great facilitator, but his ankle injuries and back injuries have robbed him of that even. At this point, pretty much all he can do is be a passer. Inbounding situations, or spot minutes against the right teams. He'll most likely be back because of his contract (although I pray some GM has a mental breakdown and his wife begs him to trade for Luke) and if so, he needs to get healthy and shoot a thousand jump shots a day.

DJ Mbenga- D: DJ is who he is. He provides a toughness element in practice, and when he plays actual meaningful minutes, he's going to block shots and give maximum effort. I think we'll probably bring him back at a minimum contract to fill out the roster.

Adam Morrison- INCOMPLETE:: Good bye, Adam. I hope you enjoy telling your great grandchildren how you won two championships for the Lakers.
Image

Return to Los Angeles Lakers