ratra_1211 wrote:hi there! it's okay to play around GB, just dont post something mentioning Kobe on your top 10 all-time list.. youll get burned by crazy stats

i think it's ok to have kobe in the top 10, it's including kobe in the top 5-6 that's the problem.
it's generally accepted (on realgm's player comparison board) that kobe stats-wise is arguably equal if not better than bird (who most people stick in at #6), with the added advantage of great defense (earlier in his career)
the other players that are in that 6-10 range at the moment (bird, kobe, shaq, duncan, hakeem), all have slight knocks against them (i.e. great but slightly incomplete resumes to get them into the top 5)
but when it's all said and done, lebron will be top 5, maybe even top 3, probably knocking either magic/russell/wilt out depending on which criteria you value most highly (rings/stats/defense)
now isn't that an argument waiting to happen on a lakers board?