Andrea Bargnani for Joakim Noah

[Dolemite]

The sad thing is, I think that the Bulls would not do this trade with the way Bargnani is playing.

Noahs problem is that he want to win too much. He would be an ideal Smitch player, and would hopefully instill a rebounding and defensive work ethic on this team.

Think about it, the Raps problem is not offence, its rebounding and defence....Bargnani will NEVER be the type of player who will offer significant contributions on the boards or on defence, although I think he can be adequate.

They want Andrea to perform a role he is not suited for at all. Chicago might be willing to play him purely as an offensive force where he could thrive.

[Ackshun]

-= original quote snipped =-



Whereas Noah, being 2 months into his NBA career, has clearly reached his potential.

hmm..never said that.

However, Noah is a Chicago Bull. Ceteris paribus.

[Harry Palmer]

-= original quote snipped =-



hmm..never said that.

However, Noah is a Chicago Bull. Ceteris paribus.

Oh yeah? Generalia specialibus non derogant!!!!!

HA!


I LOSE!


WAIT! I MEANT WIN! RE-COUNT!

[Ackshun]

[quote="Harry Palmer"][/quote]

LOL...no but seriously.

If we're trading Bargnani, I want a bigger body than Noah. No way do I want to see Bosh/Noah in our front court.

Remember when Antonio Davis took us to the playoffs that one year. He would start, play mediocre, and then hit the bench. After sitting for a while, he would come back and dominate.

that was cool

[El Presidente]

I am not a Bargs fan, but I would not do this deal. Maybe if you include Nocioni then it could be fair. I would rather call Philly for Dalembert.

I second this, I think teams might still look at Bargnani as being a guy who has potential and might take on a project to unleash it. Kinda like the Raptors are.

[RapsVC15]

-= original quote snipped =-



No. Only our players are allowed such largesse. Anyways:

Code: Select all

           TS%    RbR   Ast%   Stl%  Blk%   PER
Noah      .524   15.0  11.1    3.1   4.0   18.2
Bargnani  .485    8.7   7.1    0.6   1.8    9.1   

According to those same stats, Calderon is the third best guard in the East.

[Harry Palmer]

-= original quote snipped =-



LOL...no but seriously.

If we're trading Bargnani, I want a bigger body than Noah. No way do I want to see Bosh/Noah in our front court.

Remember when Antonio Davis took us to the playoffs that one year. He would start, play mediocre, and then hit the bench. After sitting for a while, he would come back and dominate.

that was cool

I am NOT advocating getting Noah. I am just sleep-deprivation-stoned.

[foetopsy]

at this point , trade bargnani for anyone who can grab at least 3 rebs a game

[HeyIt'sMe]

Noah actually has quite a bit of skill. He's already a top five passing big man, he rebounds the ball, can block shots, and he's got a great handle for a big man. Bargnani can shoot the three ball and... well, that's about it.

[KingKover]

i'd rather have a player who has heart, can rebound and defend then a turnover prone, low IQ, heartless small forward in a centers body.

[yungal07]

i'd rather have a player who has heart, can rebound and defend then a turnover prone, low IQ, heartless small forward in a centers body.

100% Truth.

[hermes]

i wouldn't want noah on my team
maybe its just me