LAL/ATL/CHI
Moderators: Andre Roberstan, HartfordWhalers, BullyKing, Texas Chuck, MoneyTalks41890, Mamba4Goat, pacers33granger, Trader_Joe, loserX
LAL/ATL/CHI
- SportsFan215
- Assistant Coach
- Posts: 3,992
- And1: 60
- Joined: Jun 23, 2007
- Location: Los Angeles
LAL/ATL/CHI
Lakers Get: J. Johnson/PJ Brown
Lakers Give: Odom/Mihm
Bulls Get: Odom/Mihm
Bulls Give: Gordon/Noah/PJ Brown (S&T 1yr/6mil)
Hawks Get: Gordon/Noah
Hawks Give: J. Johnson
Why for Lakers?
Joe Johnson would be Kobe's Pippen. He isn't playing as well as he could right now in Atlanta, and a change of scenery might be the right thing for him right now. PJ Brown bring another veteran presence to a young team, he can help mentor Bynum.
Why for Bulls?
They need to do something to turn around their season before it's too late. Lamar Odom might be the answer. He is extremely versatile and can play the 3 or 4. The Bulls were interested in Mihm in the offseason, and he could help out in the middle.
Why for Atlanta?
They are sliding a little bit right now, and Joe Johnson could be traded right now to get some pieces to improve the team. First they save a lot of money in this deal to help them sign Josh Smith, etc in the offseason. Ben Gordon will replace Joe Johnson at the 2 guard, and Noah could be the real center they need. Pairing him next to Al Horford would help him, too.
Thoughts?
Lakers Give: Odom/Mihm
Bulls Get: Odom/Mihm
Bulls Give: Gordon/Noah/PJ Brown (S&T 1yr/6mil)
Hawks Get: Gordon/Noah
Hawks Give: J. Johnson
Why for Lakers?
Joe Johnson would be Kobe's Pippen. He isn't playing as well as he could right now in Atlanta, and a change of scenery might be the right thing for him right now. PJ Brown bring another veteran presence to a young team, he can help mentor Bynum.
Why for Bulls?
They need to do something to turn around their season before it's too late. Lamar Odom might be the answer. He is extremely versatile and can play the 3 or 4. The Bulls were interested in Mihm in the offseason, and he could help out in the middle.
Why for Atlanta?
They are sliding a little bit right now, and Joe Johnson could be traded right now to get some pieces to improve the team. First they save a lot of money in this deal to help them sign Josh Smith, etc in the offseason. Ben Gordon will replace Joe Johnson at the 2 guard, and Noah could be the real center they need. Pairing him next to Al Horford would help him, too.
Thoughts?
-
- Forum Mod - Hawks
- Posts: 8,380
- And1: 1,495
- Joined: Jun 27, 2005
No from Atlanta. Having to resign 3 players would be very hard, especially when two wants the max and one could possibly take the QO and be ufa. Noah is solid but the trade doesn't fill a need for the Hawks. They still have a hole at pg, plus I don't like the idea of a backup being a major part of the deal (aka Noah).
The moderator formerly known as uga_dawgs24
- coldfish
- Forum Mod - Bulls
- Posts: 59,069
- And1: 35,309
- Joined: Jun 11, 2004
- Location: Right in the middle
Chicago isn't doing that on multiple levels.
Bulls after the trade:
Hinrich / Duhon
no one
Deng / Odom / Nocioni / Sefolosha / Thomas / Griffin
Smith
Wallace / Mihm / Gray
Several of those 3's can play the 4, but its not their natural position.
Quite frankly, if Atlanta would give up Joe Johnson for that, the Bulls would just cut out LA and take Johnson themselves.
This is one of those trades where a third team is just trying to screw over two other ones.
Bulls after the trade:
Hinrich / Duhon
no one
Deng / Odom / Nocioni / Sefolosha / Thomas / Griffin
Smith
Wallace / Mihm / Gray
Several of those 3's can play the 4, but its not their natural position.
Quite frankly, if Atlanta would give up Joe Johnson for that, the Bulls would just cut out LA and take Johnson themselves.
This is one of those trades where a third team is just trying to screw over two other ones.
- SportsFan215
- Assistant Coach
- Posts: 3,992
- And1: 60
- Joined: Jun 23, 2007
- Location: Los Angeles
First of all Odom struggles at the 3. He is much more effective playing the 4. Yes I agree that the Bulls wouldn't have much at the 2 guard, but last time I checked Thabo, Griffin, Hinrich could all play there. I could even see Deng get some minutes there, and Ty Thomas is a PF, not a SF.
Here is another revised deal:
Lakers Get: J. Johnson/PJ Brown
Lakers Give: Odom/Crittenton
Bulls Get: Odom/Stoudamire
Bulls Give: Gordon/Noah/PJ Brown (S&T 1yr/4.5mil)
Hawks Get: Gordon/Noah/Crittenton
Hawks Give: J. Johnson/Stoudamire
If I were the Bulls, I would start both Duhon and Hinrich and have Thabo, Griffin, and Salim coming off the bench at the 2 guard.
Bulls
Duhon/Hinrich/Curry/Stoudamire
Hinrich/Thabo/Griffin/Stoudamire
Deng/Noc/Nichols
Odom/Thomas/Khryapa
Wallace/Smith/Gray
For the Hawks, nobody is going to give him the max, so he can keep dreaming. After this trade, they will save almost $6 million and most of the money coming in this trade is from Ben Gordon (Noah and Crittenton make almost nothing.) So they could resign Gordon with some of this money, and then resign the Joshes.
Hawks
Law/Johnson/Crittenton/Lue
Gordon/Childress
Williams/Childress/Smith
Smith/Williams/Horford/Jones
Horford/Noah/Pachulia/Wright
Here is another revised deal:
Lakers Get: J. Johnson/PJ Brown
Lakers Give: Odom/Crittenton
Bulls Get: Odom/Stoudamire
Bulls Give: Gordon/Noah/PJ Brown (S&T 1yr/4.5mil)
Hawks Get: Gordon/Noah/Crittenton
Hawks Give: J. Johnson/Stoudamire
If I were the Bulls, I would start both Duhon and Hinrich and have Thabo, Griffin, and Salim coming off the bench at the 2 guard.
Bulls
Duhon/Hinrich/Curry/Stoudamire
Hinrich/Thabo/Griffin/Stoudamire
Deng/Noc/Nichols
Odom/Thomas/Khryapa
Wallace/Smith/Gray
For the Hawks, nobody is going to give him the max, so he can keep dreaming. After this trade, they will save almost $6 million and most of the money coming in this trade is from Ben Gordon (Noah and Crittenton make almost nothing.) So they could resign Gordon with some of this money, and then resign the Joshes.
Hawks
Law/Johnson/Crittenton/Lue
Gordon/Childress
Williams/Childress/Smith
Smith/Williams/Horford/Jones
Horford/Noah/Pachulia/Wright
- coldfish
- Forum Mod - Bulls
- Posts: 59,069
- And1: 35,309
- Joined: Jun 11, 2004
- Location: Right in the middle
Again, I would rather just cut LA out of the deal and take Joe Johnson (which Atl would not do anyways). The resulting team would be far better.
Some background: The Bulls backcourt this year has sucked. Gordon has been the best player in there. Thabo and Duhon in particular have been horrible. In the frontcourt, the Bulls have too many people, but have got a lot of quality play out of the PF rotation, despite inconsistent minutes. Essentially, the Bulls would be left with 7 frontcourt players and only Hinrich in the backcourt.
Some background: The Bulls backcourt this year has sucked. Gordon has been the best player in there. Thabo and Duhon in particular have been horrible. In the frontcourt, the Bulls have too many people, but have got a lot of quality play out of the PF rotation, despite inconsistent minutes. Essentially, the Bulls would be left with 7 frontcourt players and only Hinrich in the backcourt.
-
- Junior
- Posts: 466
- And1: 9
- Joined: Jun 23, 2007
From ATL perspective, I doubt they'd move their franchise player for only Ben Gordon and Joakim Noah. It not THAT enticing to pair Horford and Noah together and then they go from having a PG problem to having both a PG and a SG problem.
The imbalance of the Bulls roster has already been pointed out and the only team that really benefits from this deal is the Lakers.
The imbalance of the Bulls roster has already been pointed out and the only team that really benefits from this deal is the Lakers.
- old rem
- RealGM
- Posts: 50,753
- And1: 1,080
- Joined: Jun 14, 2005
- Location: Witness Protection
coldfish wrote:Chicago isn't doing that on multiple levels.
Bulls after the trade:
Hinrich / Duhon
no one
Deng / Odom / Nocioni / Sefolosha / Thomas / Griffin
Smith
Wallace / Mihm / Gray
Several of those 3's can play the 4, but its not their natural position.
Quite frankly, if Atlanta would give up Joe Johnson for that, the Bulls would just cut out LA and take Johnson themselves.
This is one of those trades where a third team is just trying to screw over two other ones.
.....right.....more KY Jelly....
CENSORED... No comment.
- BrooklynBulls
- Retired Mod
- Posts: 32,733
- And1: 2,652
- Joined: May 13, 2007
- Location: Avidly reading WillPenney.com
- Contact:
Return to Trades and Transactions