Paul Pierce vs Jimmy Butler

ShulaDon92 · Post #1 » by **ShulaDon92** » Thu Apr 27, 2023 1:04 am

Is this even close anymore?

I will have to research when i have time.

-SHULA

RRR3 · Post #2 » by **RRR3** » Thu Apr 27, 2023 6:31 am

Career wise or peak wise?

ShulaDon92 · Post #3 » by **ShulaDon92** » Thu Apr 27, 2023 12:47 pm

RRR3 wrote:Career wise or peak wise?

Both.

Sign5 · Post #4 » by **Sign5** » Fri Apr 28, 2023 3:21 pm

Butler without even contemplating it because fk Pierce lol.

Miami_Lux · Post #5 » by **Miami_Lux** » Mon May 1, 2023 12:11 am

Weird question to ask on a Heat forum. Obviously everyone is going to say Jimmy. Plus it doesn’t help that Pierce is a garbage human being

ShulaDon92 · Post #6 » by **ShulaDon92** » Mon May 1, 2023 2:03 am

No cause it was about "can the heat surpass the Pierre/Garnett / allen core"?

SergiuRoBuc · Post #7 » by **SergiuRoBuc** » Tue May 9, 2023 8:41 am

I love me some Jimmy Butler but realistically speaking we haven't seen anything yet that proves beyond a reasonable doubt that he's a better basketball player than Paul Pierce. The latter is an NBA champion, Finals MVP, 10-time all-star, been in countless heavyweight playoff battles, was a better scorer than Jimmy is and was doing this in an era where there was a lot less spacing. Jimmy is getting to the basket against guys who can't afford to clog the lane (because they gotta stay out on shooters). The Truth was dropping 45 against Duncan, KG, Shaq, peak Dwight waiting to knock his ass down.

Talent-wise, Jimmy is probably somewhere in between a Paul George and a Kawhi Leonard, and it's Kawhi who I'd compare to a Paul Pierce, Tracy McGrady and so on...

ShulaDon92 · Post #8 » by **ShulaDon92** » Tue May 9, 2023 11:59 pm

SergiuRoBuc wrote:I love me some Jimmy Butler but realistically speaking we haven't seen anything yet that proves beyond a reasonable doubt that he's a better basketball player than Paul Pierce. The latter is an NBA champion, Finals MVP, 10-time all-star, been in countless heavyweight playoff battles, was a better scorer than Jimmy is and was doing this in an era where there was a lot less spacing. Jimmy is getting to the basket against guys who can't afford to clog the lane (because they gotta stay out on shooters). The Truth was dropping 45 against Duncan, KG, Shaq, peak Dwight waiting to knock his ass down.

Talent-wise, Jimmy is probably somewhere in between a Paul George and a Kawhi Leonard, and it's Kawhi who I'd compare to a Paul Pierce, Tracy McGrady and so on...

Oh, interesting to see someone stand up for Pierce. Interesting points. Have any YouTube vids to sharez??

SergiuRoBuc · Post #9 » by **SergiuRoBuc** » Wed May 10, 2023 8:03 am

ShulaDon92 wrote:
SergiuRoBuc wrote:I love me some Jimmy Butler but realistically speaking we haven't seen anything yet that proves beyond a reasonable doubt that he's a better basketball player than Paul Pierce. The latter is an NBA champion, Finals MVP, 10-time all-star, been in countless heavyweight playoff battles, was a better scorer than Jimmy is and was doing this in an era where there was a lot less spacing. Jimmy is getting to the basket against guys who can't afford to clog the lane (because they gotta stay out on shooters). The Truth was dropping 45 against Duncan, KG, Shaq, peak Dwight waiting to knock his ass down.

Talent-wise, Jimmy is probably somewhere in between a Paul George and a Kawhi Leonard, and it's Kawhi who I'd compare to a Paul Pierce, Tracy McGrady and so on...

Oh, interesting to see someone stand up for Pierce. Interesting points. Have any YouTube vids to sharez??

I mean.. I guess this clip works? Thing is, Pierce was the type of player that would always rise to the same level as Kobe, LeBron, Wade, Melo, KD in direct matchups, and would do it in the regular season too. His willpower was amazing. Playoff Jimmy can do that too, but I've yet to see him do it consistently - I'm not sure he's that type of driven scorer anyway. He's more of a facilitator during the regular season, picking his spots cleverly, taking advantage of spacing to score. Pierce would just attack everything and make something out of nothing.

[url]

Watch on YouTube

[/url]

ShulaDon92 · Post #10 » by **ShulaDon92** » Wed May 10, 2023 6:26 pm

SergiuRoBuc wrote:
ShulaDon92 wrote:
SergiuRoBuc wrote:I love me some Jimmy Butler but realistically speaking we haven't seen anything yet that proves beyond a reasonable doubt that he's a better basketball player than Paul Pierce. The latter is an NBA champion, Finals MVP, 10-time all-star, been in countless heavyweight playoff battles, was a better scorer than Jimmy is and was doing this in an era where there was a lot less spacing. Jimmy is getting to the basket against guys who can't afford to clog the lane (because they gotta stay out on shooters). The Truth was dropping 45 against Duncan, KG, Shaq, peak Dwight waiting to knock his ass down.

Talent-wise, Jimmy is probably somewhere in between a Paul George and a Kawhi Leonard, and it's Kawhi who I'd compare to a Paul Pierce, Tracy McGrady and so on...

Oh, interesting to see someone stand up for Pierce. Interesting points. Have any YouTube vids to sharez??

I mean.. I guess this clip works? Thing is, Pierce was the type of player that would always rise to the same level as Kobe, LeBron, Wade, Melo, KD in direct matchups, and would do it in the regular season too. His willpower was amazing. Playoff Jimmy can do that too, but I've yet to see him do it consistently - I'm not sure he's that type of driven scorer anyway. He's more of a facilitator during the regular season, picking his spots cleverly, taking advantage of spacing to score. Pierce would just attack everything and make something out of nothing.

[url]

Watch on YouTube
[/url]

Mixtapes are ok but i like to compare game footage, clutch moments, defensive moments. Full fourth quarter clips, etc

corner3ball · Post #11 » by **corner3ball** » Thu May 11, 2023 7:35 pm