Wiltside wrote:For whatever reason, Herro is a lightning rod for criticism and praise. The truth, to me atleast, lies somewhere in the middle.
I think BenoUdrihFTL said it best when comparing him to other young SG's in the past - reality is, the role is an inefficient one, particularly when dealing with growing pains, increased defensive attention and increased responsibilities. I think he's had a good year and shown some growth in many parts of his game. He's struggled of late prior to the Suns big game, but keep in mind that he's essentially our #1 option at present.
He isn't Luka or Trae. I don't think he's that calibre of player. But he can be an All-Star level 2 guard - albeit he will always likely have defensive limitations (like both Luka and Trae do too).
I don't see the lightning rod for praise part. He is easily the most criticized on the team without any pushback whatsoever. He's often scapegoated for things that everyone on the team is doing. I've seen Herro get raked over the coals for poor shooting nights when Jimmy shot worse. Crapped on for turning over the ball, when Bam got more turnovers. That's not to say its not somewhat understandable because those two bring other things that Herro doesn't, but a few posters act like Herro isn't a 20 point scorer on a team anemic with offense, especially with the way Duncan has played all year, and instant offense off the bench.
Spo is another person always scapegoated on here. That one is the one that pisses me off the most because its like if you look at this team roster compounded with the injuries we've sustained and see what the hell our record is, you have to be an absolute **** to give him the grief he's given.
People got more defensive about me rightfully calling Duncan trash than any criticism Herro gets. I had one weirdo quote me with an essay of condescension because I basically just said Yogurt has things he needs to work on

But you can **** on Tyler without any real flinching on here. Its basically the same 3 or 4 posters though, 2 of which are in this thread doing what they do. So its easy to not take them seriously on anything Herro related, because they will warp whatever he does into a negative and use some "advanced stats" to justify their hate instead of just saying with their chest they don't like Herro and never have. But still, its crazy.