SA37 wrote:greg4012 wrote:Crazy-Canuck wrote:3 guard line up were in the blacks during practice. I dont think we'll be seeing the ware/bam/wiggins fronticourt.
Legitimately asking anyone on the board: has a team ever found real success in the modern NBA relying on a 3-guard starting lineup?
I feel like it's only really been in small spurts as a change up where it has been fruitful.
The problem you'll run into is defining "guard".
OKC is killing everyone with SGA, Dort and Wallace. In general, OKC's lineup is basically 4 guards since no one is taller than 6'6 except Hartenstein, Jaylin Williams, or Chet.
Boston is having a heck of a season right now. They literally have THE WORST frontcourt on paper that I can remember and they're starting Pritchard, White (who is having a brutal season shooting the ball), and Jaylen Brown and playing them big minutes.
Cleveland had a monster season last year and were playing Garland, Mitchell, and Strus.
That's the trap, right? The more skills any player has (pass, shoot, dribble, create space, screen, board, etc) the better it always is independent of position. Question #1 for me is "what position(s) can the player defend?" Then it becomes a further analysis of skills and advantages does the player bring to the table. The trap is wanting to put out as many players with a pass-dribble-shoot skillset as possible on the floor at all times without accounting for what they lack.
The more guards you put out there, the more they better be able to (1) legitimately defend up to Small Forward at a minimum; (2) rebound above their position level; and (3) physically be able to move people (boxing out, screening, etc) above their positional level. If not, then your lineup is simply subpar in that regard relative to the demands of an average NBA team.
That's why Miami got the 1 seed while trotting out lineups of Lowry (6'), Duncan/Herro, Jimmy (6'7), PJ (6'5) and Bam (6'9). The 2 "small" positional starters in Lowry and PJ were thicc boy units that could defend multiple positions, box out, create space by moving people on the floor.
SGA is nearly the same size as Andrew Wiggins and can clearly defend small forwards. Dort is a unit that can defend 1-4 (no one confused PJ Tucker for a guard just bc he's 6'5). And Cason Wallace and Caruso are in the NBA because of their defense, physicality and hustle.
If you just look at height then its a cheap surface level assessment that has little value.