unowen85 wrote:I don't got nothing against Ilgauskas, it's just that I don't see him as the center that I would want when building around LeBron.
Yeah, well, Dwight Howard isn't exactly available, nor are any of the other handful of guys that would qualify. Everyone wants things but Ilgauskas isn't on the books for a long time or an unreasonable price and he IS a valuable player. He's better than what most of the league has.
In fact, let's see...
The only guys who are CLEARLY superior to him are Camby, Yao, Kaman (this year only), Gasol, Dwight, Amare and Duncan.
Of those, several are perennial All-Stars, superstars even, and are completely inaccessible to the Cavs. Gasol was theoretically available and represents failure on the part of Cleveland management but really, you're looking at a DPOY and four perennial All-Stars among that group, those are the best of the best at the position.
Of the rest that matter (Okafor, Al Jefferson, Tyson Chandler, Bynum this year), each has something that makes him of comparable value (Jefferson's defensive inadequacy at the 5, for example, or Chandler's inadequacy as a scorer and lack of range). Bynum is debatable, since he was offering comparable production but worse man defense... but in any case, he was utterly unavailable and is therefore moot.
Okafor is perennially injured; Big Z has played 78+ games for about a half-decade straight now and has played in all of the Cavs' 52 games so far this season, so his value (which is actually less on O, comparable as a rebounder and not much better as a defender) is questionable relative to Z in all aspects except age... and Big Z is holding up better despite being older and having a critical foot issue.
So really, what other options were there?
He's on a reasonable contract that's not ridiculously long; in an ideal scenario, Lebron would have Redd next to him (and the Cavs did make offers to both Redd and Ray-Ray but were turned down on both fronts) in the backcourt and then there would be no questions about Ilgauskas.
There were no other options at the 5 and it was WISE to re-sign Ilgauskas.