ImageImage

Who Should Be The 5th Starter?

Moderators: paulpressey25, MickeyDavis

Who Should Be The 5th Starter and why

MarJon Beauchamp
35
25%
Malik Beasley
23
16%
Pat Connaughton
38
27%
A.J. Green
11
8%
Andre Jackson Jr.
35
25%
 
Total votes: 142

GHOSTofSIKMA
RealGM
Posts: 22,803
And1: 8,973
Joined: Jan 21, 2007
Location: NC
     

Re: Who Should Be The 5th Starter? 

Post#181 » by GHOSTofSIKMA » Thu Oct 12, 2023 7:32 pm

skbucks1985 wrote:Having Pat gives them a safety valve to take a risk on someone else and if it doesn't work, you can pull the plug and there's a good option in the wings. And so if they go with Beasley its probably because they trust that his defense can be adequate and he'll have good shot selection. If one or both of those things change you can pull the plug on it anytime you want.


this is spot on. i think this is exactly what will happen
User avatar
Dick Tate
Analyst
Posts: 3,449
And1: 3,001
Joined: Aug 17, 2006

Re: Who Should Be The 5th Starter? 

Post#182 » by Dick Tate » Thu Oct 12, 2023 7:34 pm

MVP2110 wrote:And Beasley wasn't on the floor with Lebron in the playoffs because of the bad shots Beas was taking and his poor defense. Darvin Ham clearly didn't think Lebron being on the floor would help Beas a ton

That may be part of the reason but more to do with the ascension of Austin Reaves.
MVP2110 wrote:And I'm not saying Giannis & Dame won't give a massive amount of gravity to Beasley or any other player. But realistically the starting SG should at best be 4th in shots taken among the starting lineup. Beas is likely going to keep shooting and taking shots away from our top players

I don't think that's likely. Dude just lost out on $13-14M. He isn't stupid. He signed to be part a championship level team that didn't even have a starting spot open when he signed. He knows he'll need to play the way coach wants if there's to be a big pay day in the future.
jimmybones
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,757
And1: 3,297
Joined: May 29, 2009
Location: MKE
     

Re: Who Should Be The 5th Starter? 

Post#183 » by jimmybones » Thu Oct 12, 2023 10:35 pm

MVP2110 wrote:
FrieAaron wrote:
MVP2110 wrote:
Read on Twitter
?t=Tt7LIzHYpOwaU9JQSY5GGA&s=19

This is one of 2 main reasons Beas shouldn't start. Let him take these tough contested shots with the 2nd unit, not while Giannis, Dame, & Khris are on the floor


I agree Beasley should be coming off the bench, but the point of the tweet is that they won't be that contested playing with Giannis. There is absolutely no way playing with the starting unit wouldn't drop that number dramatically for him.


I get that the tweet is trying to spin this in a positive light but it shows that Beas is very much willing to take contested 3s and I highly doubt that habit of his is going to change. The thing about Beas starting is for the idea to work he has to drastically change his play style on both offense & defense and that's such a hard ask of a player.


Yeah, I don't buy that he'd defer to better players, he's played with good players. His willingness to take tough shots and make them at a decent rate can be an asset to a second unit but a detriment to a starting unit that has 3-4 players on the floor you'd prefer to see taking those shots most of the time.

Chuckers gonna chuck man. Rather have a 5th starter willing to take table scraps and bust their ass on both ends of the floor to get their seldom (and probably wide open) shots
Daver
Head Coach
Posts: 7,121
And1: 2,712
Joined: Feb 23, 2019
       

Re: Who Should Be The 5th Starter? 

Post#184 » by Daver » Thu Oct 12, 2023 10:58 pm

jimmybones wrote:
MVP2110 wrote:
FrieAaron wrote:
I agree Beasley should be coming off the bench, but the point of the tweet is that they won't be that contested playing with Giannis. There is absolutely no way playing with the starting unit wouldn't drop that number dramatically for him.


I get that the tweet is trying to spin this in a positive light but it shows that Beas is very much willing to take contested 3s and I highly doubt that habit of his is going to change. The thing about Beas starting is for the idea to work he has to drastically change his play style on both offense & defense and that's such a hard ask of a player.


Yeah, I don't buy that he'd defer to better players, he's played with good players. His willingness to take tough shots and make them at a decent rate can be an asset to a second unit but a detriment to a starting unit that has 3-4 players on the floor you'd prefer to see taking those shots most of the time.

Chuckers gonna chuck man. Rather have a 5th starter willing to take table scraps and bust their ass on both ends of the floor to get their seldom (and probably wide open) shots




Please define what a chucker is someone that shoots more thsn 15xs a game from the SG spot.
If thsts your definition of a chucker thsn i guess anyone that shoots more thsn 15xs in one.Im sure if marjon shoot 15x a game no one would call him a chucker
Daver
Head Coach
Posts: 7,121
And1: 2,712
Joined: Feb 23, 2019
       

Re: Who Should Be The 5th Starter? 

Post#185 » by Daver » Thu Oct 12, 2023 11:00 pm

Seeing that this board loves patty C he starts he shoots 12 to 15xs a game you going to call him a chucker to
User avatar
theFireBlanket
RealGM
Posts: 11,654
And1: 4,616
Joined: Feb 23, 2011

Re: Who Should Be The 5th Starter? 

Post#186 » by theFireBlanket » Thu Oct 12, 2023 11:09 pm

Daver wrote:Seeing that this board loves patty C he starts he shoots 12 to 15xs a game you going to call him a chucker to



Hell yeah, Patty Chucknaughton McNoBrains. First he'll hang 80 on the Raps Nov 1st, game of his life.

Then he'll grow a rattail, shave the sides for a mohawk, dye it red & rock the bandana look that pisses his dad off.
MVP2110
General Manager
Posts: 8,833
And1: 4,655
Joined: Jun 28, 2012
Location: Appleton WI
       

Re: Who Should Be The 5th Starter? 

Post#187 » by MVP2110 » Thu Oct 12, 2023 11:12 pm

Daver wrote:Seeing that this board loves patty C he starts he shoots 12 to 15xs a game you going to call him a chucker to


Last year Beas put up 21 shots per 100 possessions. Pat put up 14 shots per 100 possessions.
Coach Drew: "Milwaukee has always been a team that I have been intrigued by. When we played them, they were a tough team for us to play. Although we did beat them all four times"
ShootingtheJ
RealGM
Posts: 11,861
And1: 7,483
Joined: Jun 20, 2010

Re: Who Should Be The 5th Starter? 

Post#188 » by ShootingtheJ » Thu Oct 12, 2023 11:27 pm

Daver wrote:
jimmybones wrote:
MVP2110 wrote:
I get that the tweet is trying to spin this in a positive light but it shows that Beas is very much willing to take contested 3s and I highly doubt that habit of his is going to change. The thing about Beas starting is for the idea to work he has to drastically change his play style on both offense & defense and that's such a hard ask of a player.


Yeah, I don't buy that he'd defer to better players, he's played with good players. His willingness to take tough shots and make them at a decent rate can be an asset to a second unit but a detriment to a starting unit that has 3-4 players on the floor you'd prefer to see taking those shots most of the time.

Chuckers gonna chuck man. Rather have a 5th starter willing to take table scraps and bust their ass on both ends of the floor to get their seldom (and probably wide open) shots




Please define what a chucker is someone that shoots more thsn 15xs a game from the SG spot.
If thsts your definition of a chucker thsn i guess anyone that shoots more thsn 15xs in one.Im sure if marjon shoot 15x a game no one would call him a chucker


It's not about the attempts, it's about whether they take shots they can make. Beasley had a lowly 52TS% last year while playing with Lebron. That's stealing shots from a better player
Daver
Head Coach
Posts: 7,121
And1: 2,712
Joined: Feb 23, 2019
       

Re: Who Should Be The 5th Starter? 

Post#189 » by Daver » Thu Oct 12, 2023 11:39 pm

MVP2110 wrote:
Daver wrote:Seeing that this board loves patty C he starts he shoots 12 to 15xs a game you going to call him a chucker to


Last year Beas put up 21 shots per 100 possessions. Pat put up 14 shots per 100 possessions.




That was last year man doesnt nean he will do that this year with dame midds giannis n lopez players can change hes never been in a lineup like this would be fair to give him 1 week or so before the knives come out.
MVP2110
General Manager
Posts: 8,833
And1: 4,655
Joined: Jun 28, 2012
Location: Appleton WI
       

Re: Who Should Be The 5th Starter? 

Post#190 » by MVP2110 » Thu Oct 12, 2023 11:41 pm

Daver wrote:
MVP2110 wrote:
Daver wrote:Seeing that this board loves patty C he starts he shoots 12 to 15xs a game you going to call him a chucker to


Last year Beas put up 21 shots per 100 possessions. Pat put up 14 shots per 100 possessions.




That was last year man doesnt nean he will do that this year with dame midds giannis n lopez players can change hes never been in a lineup like this would be fair to give him 1 week or so before the knives come out.


He was with Lebron & AD last year lol.
Coach Drew: "Milwaukee has always been a team that I have been intrigued by. When we played them, they were a tough team for us to play. Although we did beat them all four times"
User avatar
blazza18
RealGM
Posts: 56,887
And1: 29,677
Joined: Dec 02, 2010
Location: Upside Down
       

Re: Who Should Be The 5th Starter? 

Post#191 » by blazza18 » Fri Oct 13, 2023 12:11 am

Keep looking at the list of guys in the poll and I have next to no confidence in any of them defensively besides the rookie. Griff/Lopez/Giannis are going to need to cover up some mistakes no matter who is chosen.
Baddy Chuck wrote:I want to win but I also love chaos.
GHOSTofSIKMA
RealGM
Posts: 22,803
And1: 8,973
Joined: Jan 21, 2007
Location: NC
     

Re: Who Should Be The 5th Starter? 

Post#192 » by GHOSTofSIKMA » Fri Oct 13, 2023 1:06 am

blazza18 wrote:Keep looking at the list of guys in the poll and I have next to no confidence in any of them defensively besides the rookie. Griff/Lopez/Giannis are going to need to cover up some mistakes no matter who is chosen.


not only would he be instantly bad ass defensively but hed be an insane glue guy offensively. i imagine rookie MAM if he had handles and elite athleticism. like how is that not the starter here?

MAM developed a passable jumper in time too but you could play off him because he couldnt attack closeouts and deal lightening to his teammates with the pass.

i dont really care who starts but with pat and ajj on the roster im not really worried about the position. beasley, marjon, and green can have all the minutes they want but i feel pretty confident if theyre **** ups they arent gonna have free rein for long
ShootingtheJ
RealGM
Posts: 11,861
And1: 7,483
Joined: Jun 20, 2010

Re: Who Should Be The 5th Starter? 

Post#193 » by ShootingtheJ » Fri Oct 13, 2023 1:13 am

Dick Tate wrote:
MVP2110 wrote:And Beasley wasn't on the floor with Lebron in the playoffs because of the bad shots Beas was taking and his poor defense. Darvin Ham clearly didn't think Lebron being on the floor would help Beas a ton

That may be part of the reason but more to do with the ascension of Austin Reaves.
MVP2110 wrote:And I'm not saying Giannis & Dame won't give a massive amount of gravity to Beasley or any other player. But realistically the starting SG should at best be 4th in shots taken among the starting lineup. Beas is likely going to keep shooting and taking shots away from our top players

I don't think that's likely. Dude just lost out on $13-14M. He isn't stupid. He signed to be part a championship level team that didn't even have a starting spot open when he signed. He knows he'll need to play the way coach wants if there's to be a big pay day in the future.


He didn't know last season that he was in a contract year? How was he unmotivated in a contract year, playing with a top 3 player of all time, on a team that made the conference finals?
User avatar
Ill-yasova
RealGM
Posts: 13,364
And1: 2,562
Joined: Jul 13, 2006

Re: Who Should Be The 5th Starter? 

Post#194 » by Ill-yasova » Fri Oct 13, 2023 1:13 am

The 5th starter position is less important to me than a capable all-around player of the bench. I like Marjon as a 6-7th man this year and I’m a big fan of him. Beas seems like he’s buying in on defense, he’s getting deflections and giving good effort on that side of the ball. He’s also the guy who could make the biggest impact feeding off of Giannis and Dame’s gravity. I’d rather see Marjon get more usage leading the second team.
old skool
General Manager
Posts: 8,015
And1: 3,766
Joined: Jul 07, 2005
Location: Chi

Re: Who Should Be The 5th Starter? 

Post#195 » by old skool » Fri Oct 13, 2023 1:24 am

Beasley has to be pretty humbled. 1st round pick in his 8th NBA season at age 26 signing a $2-million vet minimum contract.

That's a big come down from the 3 year $42-million deal he just completed. That's a wake up call message from the NBA that you are not wanted or valued.



Sent from my SM-N960U using RealGM mobile app
ShootingtheJ
RealGM
Posts: 11,861
And1: 7,483
Joined: Jun 20, 2010

Re: Who Should Be The 5th Starter? 

Post#196 » by ShootingtheJ » Fri Oct 13, 2023 1:33 am

old skool wrote:Beasley has to be pretty humbled. 1st round pick in his 8th NBA season at age 26 signing a $2-million vet minimum contract.

That's a big come down from the 3 year $42-million deal he just completed. That's a wake up call message from the NBA that you are not wanted or valued.



Sent from my SM-N960U using RealGM mobile app


And yet in his last preseason game he was out there chucking up contested 3, and not running the court to get back on defense. Just like he did with Denver, Minnesota, Utah, and the Lakers. He should have learned, but instead he continues on his career trajectory that will have him in China next season.
User avatar
GoldenAntlers
RealGM
Posts: 10,816
And1: 5,425
Joined: Feb 13, 2013
 

Re: Who Should Be The 5th Starter? 

Post#197 » by GoldenAntlers » Fri Oct 13, 2023 1:54 am

I feel like people tend to forget that coaches often tell shooters to shoot.
"Silence is a source of great strength." - Lao Tzu
old skool
General Manager
Posts: 8,015
And1: 3,766
Joined: Jul 07, 2005
Location: Chi

Re: Who Should Be The 5th Starter? 

Post#198 » by old skool » Fri Oct 13, 2023 2:35 am

Beasley is a big drop off from Grayson Allen. An ongoing failure to perform, but likely the best bet to fill that 5th starter role.

This thread talks about Crowder, Connaughton, Beauchamp, but none of those have meaningful recent experience guarding SGs. They are all SFs. Too slow to defend guards.

The rookies are likely lesser alternatives to the vets. It's just that we have yet to see their shortcomings.

Sent from my SM-N960U using RealGM mobile app
chonestown
General Manager
Posts: 9,563
And1: 13,403
Joined: Mar 13, 2010

Re: Who Should Be The 5th Starter? 

Post#199 » by chonestown » Fri Oct 13, 2023 2:57 am

GoldenAntlers wrote:I feel like people tend to forget that coaches often tell shooters to shoot.


Coach "bud" when he saw coaching the Bucks used the catch phrase "let it fry" case clothed
User avatar
raferfenix
RealGM
Posts: 24,267
And1: 4,585
Joined: Apr 05, 2003

Re: Who Should Be The 5th Starter? 

Post#200 » by raferfenix » Fri Oct 13, 2023 1:06 pm

…or maybe the starter come playoff time isn’t on our team yet?

Beasley will have every opportunity to resuscitate his career. But Horst also has a history of moving on quickly when guys flop (DJ Augustin / Cousins).

Connaughton ideally is a 3 and Crowder / Middleton should be a 3/4 combo not 2/3.

AJJ, MarJon and even AJ could absolutely seize the day. But when vet ring chasers start asking for trades and getting bought out from hapless teams the Bucks could be a huge opportunity.

Return to Milwaukee Bucks