ReasonablySober wrote:5 - ANH
4 - TLJ
3 - Rogue One
2 - Andor
1 - Empire
Those are the good star wars.
I haven't seen all the rest of the stuff on the list but of the stuff I've seen, I agree that this is the only good stuff.
Moderators: MickeyDavis, paulpressey25
ReasonablySober wrote:5 - ANH
4 - TLJ
3 - Rogue One
2 - Andor
1 - Empire
Those are the good star wars.

ReasonablySober wrote:Anxious to see opinions around here on Longlegs. Feel like it's been a decade since a theater released horror movie lived up to the hype for me.

jakecronus8 wrote:ReasonablySober wrote:Anxious to see opinions around here on Longlegs. Feel like it's been a decade since a theater released horror movie lived up to the hype for me.
Maxxxine was a fun conclusion to the X trilogy, albeit one that got away from the horror genre a little more. Can’t figure out if I loved the trilogy or if Mia Goth is just a supernova of charisma and talent.
ReasonablySober wrote:jakecronus8 wrote:ReasonablySober wrote:Anxious to see opinions around here on Longlegs. Feel like it's been a decade since a theater released horror movie lived up to the hype for me.
Maxxxine was a fun conclusion to the X trilogy, albeit one that got away from the horror genre a little more. Can’t figure out if I loved the trilogy or if Mia Goth is just a supernova of charisma and talent.
She's actually why I probably won't see Maxxxine. Just really don't like Goth, at all.

jakecronus8 wrote:ReasonablySober wrote:jakecronus8 wrote:
Maxxxine was a fun conclusion to the X trilogy, albeit one that got away from the horror genre a little more. Can’t figure out if I loved the trilogy or if Mia Goth is just a supernova of charisma and talent.
She's actually why I probably won't see Maxxxine. Just really don't like Goth, at all.
Whoa. Naturally to each their own but this is the first time I’ve heard this. I thought she was incredible in Pearl particularly

Haven't watched Andor but take off TLJ, kick to the bottom of the list a little above Solo and the Acolyte, and replace it with Revenge of the Sith and then you have somethingemunney wrote:ReasonablySober wrote:5 - ANH
4 - TLJ
3 - Rogue One
2 - Andor
1 - Empire
Those are the good star wars.
I haven't seen all the rest of the stuff on the list but of the stuff I've seen, I agree that this is the only good stuff.
trwi7 wrote:**** me deep, Giannis. ****. Me. Deep.
ReasonablySober wrote:Polygon ranked Star Wars TV and movies.THE “WELL, AT LEAST IT’S STAR WARS” TIER
23. THE RISE OF SKYWALKER
22. THE BOOK OF BOBA FETT
21. THE CLONE WARS MOVIE
20. STAR WARS RESISTANCE
19. OBI-WAN KENOBI
18. ATTACK OF THE CLONES
17. TALES OF THE JEDI
THE “NOW WE’RE GETTING SOMEWHERE” TIER
16. THE ACOLYTE
15. THE BAD BATCH
14. SOLO: A STAR WARS STORY
13. AHSOKA
12. REVENGE OF THE SITH
11. THE FORCE AWAKENS
10. THE PHANTOM MENACE
9. THE MANDALORIAN
THE “AH, THAT’S THE GOOD STUFF” TIER
8. REBELS
7. THE LAST JEDI
6. RETURN OF THE JEDI
5. ROGUE ONE: A STAR WARS STORY
4. THE CLONE WARS SHOW
THE “TOP-SHELF, BEST-OF-THE-BEST STAR WARS” TIER
3. A NEW HOPE
2. THE EMPIRE STRIKES BACK
1. ANDOR
They forgot Visions, but other than that, pretty solid list.

buckboy wrote:ReasonablySober wrote:Polygon ranked Star Wars TV and movies.THE “WELL, AT LEAST IT’S STAR WARS” TIER
23. THE RISE OF SKYWALKER
22. THE BOOK OF BOBA FETT
21. THE CLONE WARS MOVIE
20. STAR WARS RESISTANCE
19. OBI-WAN KENOBI
18. ATTACK OF THE CLONES
17. TALES OF THE JEDI
THE “NOW WE’RE GETTING SOMEWHERE” TIER
16. THE ACOLYTE
15. THE BAD BATCH
14. SOLO: A STAR WARS STORY
13. AHSOKA
12. REVENGE OF THE SITH
11. THE FORCE AWAKENS
10. THE PHANTOM MENACE
9. THE MANDALORIAN
THE “AH, THAT’S THE GOOD STUFF” TIER
8. REBELS
7. THE LAST JEDI
6. RETURN OF THE JEDI
5. ROGUE ONE: A STAR WARS STORY
4. THE CLONE WARS SHOW
THE “TOP-SHELF, BEST-OF-THE-BEST STAR WARS” TIER
3. A NEW HOPE
2. THE EMPIRE STRIKES BACK
1. ANDOR
They forgot Visions, but other than that, pretty solid list.
I'm fine with this list.
The important part is that they got #1 right.
Any list that doesn't have Andor at 1 is simply wrong.
ReasonablySober wrote:buckboy wrote:ReasonablySober wrote:Polygon ranked Star Wars TV and movies.
They forgot Visions, but other than that, pretty solid list.
I'm fine with this list.
The important part is that they got #1 right.
Any list that doesn't have Andor at 1 is simply wrong.
I love Andor but it's still a distant second behind Empire. Empire's in the short discussion with Godfather 2 and Aliens as the best sequel of all-time.
Ron Swanson wrote:The Bear S3 (or season 3, Part: 1) was solid. I think people just feel the need to call something a "disappointment" whenever it doesn't live up to or exceed the previous season, which in this case, was one of the best seasons of TV in recent memory. If they stick the landing it's still gonna go down as one of the best dramas of the 21st century.
buckboy wrote:ReasonablySober wrote:buckboy wrote:
I'm fine with this list.
The important part is that they got #1 right.
Any list that doesn't have Andor at 1 is simply wrong.
I love Andor but it's still a distant second behind Empire. Empire's in the short discussion with Godfather 2 and Aliens as the best sequel of all-time.
Agreed it's a great sequel.
Andor is vastly superior writing and story wise.
To me anyway.