RealGM

A buddy and I were arguing over who was the better defender Corey Maggette or Redd. I expect the bucks board to lean towards Redd obviously but I was wondering if you guys could rate him what would you give Redd on a scale from 1(Jason Kapono) to 10(Gerald Wallace)?

-3

I can't be bothered making it look nice

no_hops_23 wrote:A buddy and I were arguing over who was the better defender Corey Maggette or Redd. I expect the bucks board to lean towards Redd obviously but I was wondering if you guys could rate him what would you give Redd on a scale from 1(Jason Kapono) to 10(Gerald Wallace)?

You expected wrong.

Michael Redd says defense is against his religion.

Wow, that bad. Thanks for the input.

no_hops_23 wrote:A buddy and I were arguing over who was the better defender Corey Maggette or Redd. I expect the bucks board to lean towards Redd obviously but I was wondering if you guys could rate him what would you give Redd on a scale from 1(Jason Kapono) to 10(Gerald Wallace)?

There is a lot of Redd hate on this board..they are generally dissatisfied with everything he does.

Redd and Defense do not belong in the same sentence let alone the same page, he is horrible

carmelbrownqueen wrote:-= original quote snipped =-

There is a lot of Redd hate on this board..they are generally dissatisfied with everything he does.

Agreed.

Redd isn't a horrible defensive player. He is average/slight below average on the defensive end.

I would say Maggette is a better defensive player though.

Discussed and over discussed.