Worm Guts wrote:Of course it's debatable, and Brown isn't solely responsible, but you take away any part of that team and they probably don't win. I think Larry Brown is a better coach than Rick Carlisle, so that could be the difference between winning the championship or not.
I just don't really buy that. If you're talking about about upgrading from someone like Wittman to Brown, sure, but Carlisle's an excellent coach in his own right. It seems unlikely he wouldn't have had his wits about him enough to attack the mismatch in the backcourt (whichever of Billups or Rip that Kobe wasn't guarding), or draw Shaq out on the pick and roll.
I don't understand why people get so bullish about Brown and that Detroit team (although I guess the media pounding the Brown finally gets a ring angle to the ground has something to do with it). It had as much, if not more to do with the addition of Sheed (who had been the best player on that Blazer team that pushed the Lakers to the brink earlier in their Shaqobe years) and the implosion of that Laker squad than it did anything Brown did. It's also not like the Pistons just eked out that series against the Lakers. That was a 4-1 series and just about every Detroit victory was a resounding one.
Krapinsky wrote:It's a catch 22 to minutes matter in a players development. Kwame Brown was the #1 pick -- thus highly scouted -- and got tons of minutes to further his development. Whose fault is it that he sucks? Doug Collins? Phil Jackson? Michael Jordan? Kwame himself? Some picks don't pan out. No matter the circumstances, I wouldn't put much blame on anyone but the player and perhaps the scouting department.
I'm not sure I'd bring up the other well known recent example of an authority figure playing a prominent role in breaking the spirit of a highly drafted player in support of Brown's handling of Darko.
It's pretty obvious and well documented that both Larry Brown and Darko handled the Detroit situation poorly. Brown's a good coach, but he has his faults. His work with that Detroit team is vindicated by the ring, but that doesn't mean he was infallible during his time there.
Kwame's proven in his time post MJ that there wasn't as much to work with as originally thought, so it may not have really mattered how he was handled. In light of Darko's recent play it makes it a little more intriguing to play the what could have been game, even though it's more than likely Darko would have gotten in his own way even if Larry Brown hadn't.