Narf wrote:Krapinsky wrote:Your reliance on these stats is flawed. By this logic Joakim Noah is a bad defender since Chicago is 7 points better defensively when he is of the court. Your stats ignore Wallace's impact and the Noah stats ignore Asik/Gibson's impact, among other rotation players.
Your understanding of these stats is the problem.
Ask any Bulls fan who's defense is better, Asik's or Noah's. Then you'll figure out why Chicago is better defensively when Noah is on the bench.
I'm just showing you that year in and year out when Batum is on the floor Portland's defense is terrible. And there's no arguing it either.
You either didn't read my post or failed to comprehend. The fact that Chicago is better defensively with Noah on the bench (true) does not make Noah a bad defender. In fact, it doesn't say anything about Noah defensively, only that the Bulls second unit (w/ Asik) is better defensively then the first unit (w/ Noah), and it certainly does not help you compare Noah to other defensive centers.










