Top 25 Players - Who's #10?

[Shameer1016]

11-10 now, close is fast!!! lol

[Dagaustin2000]

11-10 now, close is fast!!! lol

Do you know when the voting is suppose to close?

[Shameer1016]

11-10 now, close is fast!!! lol

Do you know when the voting is suppose to close?

Whenever a NYCe closes it or when a player as a huge lead that won't be "caught"

[Dagaustin2000]

Nets forum XD

[therealbig3]

He's played bad for a good portion of the season, but he stepped it up to get his team into the playoffs with injuries. And I'm sorry he can't get past Lebron in the playoffs, but I think he's Top 10.

It's not the fact that he can't get past LeBron (geez, why do you make everything a 1 v 1 thing?), it's the fact that he's crapped the bed horribly through the first 3 games. All the talk about him being the best scorer in the league and being able to match LeBron head to head looks stupid now.

Games at the end of the season aren't more important than other games throughout the season...overall, for the season, Melo played like crap, and his style of play has never been conducive to winning basketball. He's a big time ball stopper, who works on isos 90% of the time...even when he's scoring, his team offense doesn't do that well, because he stagnates the offense and stops the ball. His defense is trash, and his playmaking ability is subpar. The only good thing he does outside of score is rebound.

LMA, on the other hand, is a legit post scorer, and a very good defender. He's one of the best two-way big men in the league, and I'd take a guy like that over Melo any day.

But like I said, I'd still take Nash over both of them, but since this is down to Melo or LMA, I'm going with LMA, I really don't see what makes Melo a better player other than reputation.

[Shameer1016]

He's played bad for a good portion of the season, but he stepped it up to get his team into the playoffs with injuries. And I'm sorry he can't get past Lebron in the playoffs, but I think he's Top 10.

It's not the fact that he can't get past LeBron (geez, why do you make everything a 1 v 1 thing?), it's the fact that he's crapped the bed horribly through the first 3 games. All the talk about him being the best scorer in the league and being able to match LeBron head to head looks stupid now.

Games at the end of the season aren't more important than other games throughout the season...overall, for the season, Melo played like crap, and his style of play has never been conducive to winning basketball. He's a big time ball stopper, who works on isos 90% of the time...even when he's scoring, his team offense doesn't do that well, because he stagnates the offense and stops the ball. His defense is trash, and his playmaking ability is subpar. The only good thing he does outside of score is rebound.

LMA, on the other hand, is a legit post scorer, and a very good defender. He's one of the best two-way big men in the league, and I'd take a guy like that over Melo any day.

But like I said, I'd still take Nash over both of them, but since this is down to Melo or LMA, I'm going with LMA, I really don't see what makes Melo a better player other than reputation.

Cool Story bro, then vote for him. What a job LMA did before he went out with his unfortunate injury

[Shameer1016]

Knicks fans visiting this board is helping my cause .

[vincecarter4pres]

Let's just give this to Melo and move on then lol, this is getting silly.

[Shameer1016]

^It took him a few months, but he's actually make sense now