Post#10 » by DarkXaero » Mon Jan 7, 2013 10:46 pm
Idk if I do it, even with Brook's foot problems. Like others said, Dwight's injuries are a huge red flag and I think it really isn't all that controversial to think that Brook has been better than Dwight this season. Dwight has looked like a shell of his former self with the Lakers. Granted he doesn't have the offense tailored to him (personally, I don't think he is good enough to get that many touches), but his real value was always on defense. Lakers are a below average defensive team, and the shocking part is that they're barely worse (defensively) with Howard off the floor. But even disregarding the statistics and looking only at the eye test, Dwight's defense hasn't been the same.
Meanwhile, we have an awful record (small sample size but shows his importance) without Brook this season, and Brook has been improving all season. Brook has started to develop really good chemistry with Deron. We all know how his defense has been better too, and his rebounding numbers have been better. People still keep forgetting how Brook is still only 24 and how he still has great upside. It's almost like people forget that Brook has no upside, and can't get any better than what he is. The biggest concern with Brook is his foot and that's a legitimate major concern. But Dwight's back problem is arguably worse going forward.
For those saying Dwight makes us a contender, well, isn't this Lakers team supposed to be a contender? What makes you think Dwight would make us a contender with a severely underperforming Deron Williams and iso Joe, if he can't do it with Kobe (who is having a great season regardless of his shot attempts), Steve Nash, Pau Gasol, and Metta World Peace? If Dwight can't even make them above average defensively, how is he going to make us an elite defensive team?
JJ has absolutely nothing on Kobe, and Nash is a better facilitator than Deron either way. Even current Pau is far better than Humphries/Evans and MWP spreads the floor better than Wallace, while providing defense. So if that's a sub .500 team, I don't know what we would be. And some of you might not care about the attitude/maturity stuff but it has its effect on the court. I don't know how anyone can say otherwise.