therealbig3 wrote:enetric wrote:Deron has played so much better since the break. But there are some obvious flaws to his game that people do not want to acknowledge. I actually have more issues with his play making that his offense this season. I think his decision making with the ball screams scorer over play maker. I know he "can" make plays and he can pile up assists...but his decisions for where to drive, where to pass how to move his players on a nightly basis? I mean Marbury put up stats too. So what? We knew going in that JJ was declining and has always had certain flaws...however at what he does well...if you throw out the value per $ from his horrid contract..still a player as part of your core he is valuable. Brook is the best offensive center in the NBA. Horrid rebounder and he plays soft.
Just to comment on this part, specifically Deron:
You've been doing a lot of complaining about him lately. What expectations did you have of him, exactly? You yourself said that he wasn't as good as Paul, and you never thought he was. So why are you acting like you expect him to play as well as him? I understand that overall, he hasn't been what we thought we were getting, but specifically after the ASB, he has been. He's returned to Utah form. Your complaints about him now seem like nitpicking, in all honesty, because there isn't a player in the league that is flawless. And compared to every PG EXCEPT for Paul, D-Will is a far better creator and operates with a higher IQ. So again, unless you're expecting him to be like Chris Paul, which you've already said he's not, then what is there to keep complaining about as long as he plays the way HE'S capable of?
That's a perfectly fair question and I can understand why you feel I am nitpicking as that my comments have been repetitive. But that has been more of a by product of having to read the garbage that comes out of Petrodouche and feeling the need to say...stop the madness already. This used to be a board where you didnt open your pie hole with authority unless you actually understood basketball. 99% of the comments I read are stated as fact and 80% of them have severe inaccuracy.
I am not looking to nitpick Dwil. I am looking to single out what the #1 issue is as I read through post from our guys that say....if so and so role guy would only do this or if we upped the level of player at the 4 like that is as simple as going to the grocery store and picking up a can of soup we would be fine. We are off the mark on the "main problem".
My primary issue is a cold hard dose of reality. The superstar is not as super as advertised, its a superstars league...and ours is billed as an elite play making PG. I find that even with his uptick in his own scoring has been noticeable since the break...that his play making game by game leaves a lot to be desired. And assist totals cen be deceiving. Rondo to me makes many terrible decisions on the court as well and he is an elite assist guy.
So I read a foolish diagnosis of these lesser guys and their failings and not seeing that the play maker isnt setting up his guys to succeed...I GET what Sloan had a beef with now that I get to see him every day. I GET why as talented as our big 3 is...and while we have good pieces...we arent under achieving. We are doing FINE for year one...we will improve in year 2...but...the real issue is that the top guy isnt maximizing what he has even now.
I disagree with several things you said about Kidd the other day but I havent had time to respond. You and I agree on most things from what I have seen of late. But by example? What was missed was that Kidd by way of example took a team of inferior offensive players and set them up for shots that were higher % for THEM by the way he set up. His feel for the game drive, shoot and most importantly when and where to pass to your guys. His flaw was he couldnt shoot off the dribble. He could hit the set shot 3 and has made a living of punishing teams who played off of him which many dont get. But, give me a choice between self creator point guad and one who makes everyone better and imposes his will on every play of the game...I will take the later every time. I see A LOT of poor fundamental passing from Deron in each game that happens because he made a bad choice just before the pass. He does not see the floor moments ahead. Now...you want to say that we are in an era of scoring PG's over play makers? Wont disagree. But that doesnt mean it isnt hurting us with the team WE have assembled.
My goal is to start to focus on what matters. To see it improved and to understand that all the whining we do is a lot about nothing until we either get a second superstar or until he "gets it". Otherwise...this is who we are. The ceiling is conf. finals at any time for the next 4 years...and most likely this season...getting to rd 2 would be great.
Anyway, sorry for my frustration and thanks for the question. You were right to challenge me with it. Nice job.