Prokorov wrote:Hello Brooklyn wrote:
Porter has to get better by virtue of his age. Unless you think hes some type of bum like D-Will who just doesn't care.
Not everyone who is young gets better or significantly better... and if they dont it doesnt mean they are some kind of dog. some guys realize potential earlier then others. or simply never develop as well in some areas.
Agreed.
He hasn't reached his peak yet.
probably not. but that doesnt mean his peak is much higher, and either way he doesnt do what reddick does and is extremely unlikely to ever be able to (as mention, there are very few who have ever been able to... korver, allen, reggie)
Agreed.
Reddick is 32, he has to decline.
again, this seems like a really obtuse view point. especially when several guys have played well through 35-36. some guys even played their best from 32-34
I think this is far from obtuse.
It is reasonable to believe that a player like Redick would decline around this age. And citing that "several guys" have lasted longer still puts the forth the idea that a minority of players do. The question to answer is "Why would Redick be a part of that minority group?"
Do we know if he takes exceptional care of his body?
Most players over 30 prefer longer contracts which yield more total money (but less annual salary) over the life of the contract rather than taking a higher annual salary over a shorter term.
This is really a question of whether we have faith that Redick will be able to maintain his current level of playing ability over the next few years. You haven't said anything to specifically address that issue.
I can't believe you want to sign Reddick. Youre the same guy who was pissed about having to pay Thaddeus Young money.
Thad young is a glorified bench player who has a low impact on winning or offense, and in several instances has even had a net negative impact.
But this is conjecture.
Thad has started for much of his career but he's also been a 6th or 7th man. It depends where a team believes he'd be most effective in their overall scheme.
JJ Redick is currently a starter but I can envision him not starting on a team but he could yield a greater impact coming off the bench as a 6th or 7th man.
In a similar regard, Lin who has both started for long periods of time and has come off the bench. He can play well in either role depending on the situation and context of the team.
I personally think that Redick does provide a positive impact on an offense and can even be a greater threat if he's given the green light instead of placating to stars on the team. With that said, we have to provide much more than generalizations about both players in order to make a cogent statement. At this point, you've only really stated your opinion comparing the two.