RealGM

Who's #19?

***Voting Deadline: Wednesday 1pm***

Here's the voting history of our Top 25 players threads since its inception:


Current Top 25 Rankings so far:
1) LBJ
2) KD
3) CP3
4) P.George
5) Curry
6) Harden
7) D12
8) LMA
9) Griffin
10) Melo
11) Love
12) Dirk
13) A. Davis
14) TP
15) Noah
16) Cousins
17) Dragic
18) Wade


Big Al?



Duncan?



Killa Kyrie?



Lillard?



M.Conley?



Wall?




Al Jefferson -
Duncan -
Kyrie -
Lillard -
M.Conley -
Wall -


Nominees from previous rounds:


Voting rules for non-Nets board posters:

V: Jefferson
N: Lowry

It is insane that Wade is at 18 and George is at 4. that should kind of be swapped around. Down year for wade but 20/5/5 on 60TS % is much better then what george has done, especially when george really just had 1 elite outlier month and has been the same 40-42ish percent shooter from the field in 2014 that we have seen to this point in his career.

the guy is insanely overrated.

I think George WAS insanely overrated but I don't think anyone thinks he's the #4 player in the league at this point in time.

He'd have to finish the regular season well and dominate the playoffs in order for him to crack top 10 for me.

Prokorov wrote:It is insane that Wade is at 18 and George is at 4. that should kind of be swapped around. Down year for wade but 20/5/5 on 60TS % is much better then what george has done, especially when george really just had 1 elite outlier month and has been the same 40-42ish percent shooter from the field in 2014 that we have seen to this point in his career.

the guy is insanely overrated.

We should all just make a top 40 list and take the average positions of each player instead. This poll thing takes so long things can drastically change from start to finish

Duncan

Pierce

Vote: Jefferson
Nominate: Lowry

Sent from my LG-MS770 using Tapatalk

624 wrote:

Prokorov wrote:It is insane that Wade is at 18 and George is at 4. that should kind of be swapped around. Down year for wade but 20/5/5 on 60TS % is much better then what george has done, especially when george really just had 1 elite outlier month and has been the same 40-42ish percent shooter from the field in 2014 that we have seen to this point in his career.

the guy is insanely overrated.

We should all just make a top 40 list and take the average positions of each player instead. This poll thing takes so long things can drastically change from start to finish

Part of the problem is that people sometimes there are only 3 votes in a round and sometimes there are 7-8 votes in a round.

Following your suggestion would get all of it done in one shot but it takes the fun out of the process and it's going to take sometime for the person who tallies everything to put everything into an excel sheet and have it tell us the average rank of each player.


What I'll probably do going forward is have people submit 3 players at a time along with their respective rank. It'll cut the project down into 2-3 week process instead of a 2 month process.

Vote: John Wall
Nominate: Kyle Lowry

i dont mind it taking long. i think it adds to the fun

Vote Wall
Nominate Chris Bosh

Sent from my SCH-I800 using RealGM Forums mobile app

NyCeEvO wrote:

624 wrote:

Prokorov wrote:It is insane that Wade is at 18 and George is at 4. that should kind of be swapped around. Down year for wade but 20/5/5 on 60TS % is much better then what george has done, especially when george really just had 1 elite outlier month and has been the same 40-42ish percent shooter from the field in 2014 that we have seen to this point in his career.

the guy is insanely overrated.

We should all just make a top 40 list and take the average positions of each player instead. This poll thing takes so long things can drastically change from start to finish

Part of the problem is that people sometimes there are only 3 votes in a round and sometimes there are 7-8 votes in a round.

Following your suggestion would get all of it done in one shot but it takes the fun out of the process and it's going to take sometime for the person who tallies everything to put everything into an excel sheet and have it tell us the average rank of each player.


What I'll probably do going forward is have people submit 3 players at a time along with their respective rank. It'll cut the project down into 2-3 week process instead of a 2 month process.

Yeah I don't mean to undermine the work you've been doing, it is a fun process..but the 2-3 month process dilutes it a bit.

Big Al and Wall are tied for votes. We need some tiebreakers votes.

Vote Wall
Nominate Lowry

Wall wins. Lowry is the new nominee.