Adrian_05 wrote:Yeah, Edmonton has played like **** this year. Seems like they have a bunch a young guns, who just play offense and no defense--a bunch of one dimensional players. They need some more vets to teach those kids a thing or two, and they somewhat addressed that by signing Boyd Gordon, but hes not enough. They also need some goaltending.
Yeah I've been following the Oilers as my second team, since I lived out here. They built one of the most messed up teams ever. It's all based around young good scorers, with TERRIBLE off the puck play, and a resounding lack of toughness. The top D-man is Smid for chrissakes! Goaltending is abysmal. Here is where I think the Leafs should pounce and secure a star player. I haven't checked it to see if it works under the cap yet, but here we go:
Lupul, Reimer, Gardiner, McLaren and Phaneuf for RNH, Devin Dubnyk, Justin Shultz, and Ryan Jones.
Why the Oilers do it.
1) Oilers love locals, and they are kicking themselves at giving up on Lupul so early (he couldn't handle the pressure of replacing Chris Pronger, but just said yesterday he wouldn't mind returning to the Oilers again. The guy they traded him for, Visnosky was a massive bust). Phanuef is also semi-local.
2) They desperately need size and talent on the defensive line. They also need size up front, Lupul and McLaren help there.
3) They need a starting goalie in the worst way. Dubnyk is a great BACKUP goalie, in the mold of a Glen Healey. He just can't handle the rigors of being the #1.
4) Having to pay all of Eberle, Hall, RNh, Yakupov in their prime is going to cap them out bad, and need to move per-emptively before they are making bad deals just because of the cap. Lupul and a resigned Phaneuf give them cost certainty for star players for a nice duration.
5) RNH is a phenomenal talent, but easily the most bullied and arguably the wimpiest player in the league. The Oilers have nobody to play with him, as they insist on keeping Eberle and Hall on a separate line. Yakupov gets to move back to C as well, or the Oilers can keep rolling Arcobello.
6) Phaneuf and Gardiner instantly become their #1 pairing, and will help their PP.
Why the Leafs do it
1) RNH centering Kessel and JVR for the next decade. Yes please.
2) #1 Goalie issue is settled. Bernier is clear starter. Dubnyk capable backup
3) Shultz should turn into a top 4 defenseman with time.
4) Jones is a prototypical 3rd liner that should play well with Bolland.