ImageImageImageImageImage

Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely!

Moderators: Deeeez Knicks, HerSports85, j4remi, NoLayupRule, GONYK, dakomish23, mpharris36, Jeff Van Gully

Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely!

YAY - This is great News - Thibs will be good for us overall
15
13%
OKAY - He's not perfect ,but better than what we have and we'll benefit somewhat
39
34%
MEH I'm skeptical but will give it a chance
20
17%
NAY Thibs sucks for where we are and what we are trying to accomplish
41
36%
 
Total votes: 115

BLACKFEET 2010
RealGM
Posts: 10,285
And1: 3,847
Joined: Jun 26, 2009

Re: Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely! 

Post#101 » by BLACKFEET 2010 » Mon Feb 24, 2020 6:43 pm

Deeeez Knicks wrote:A good read. Some fair points if you are looking for the pro-Thibs side. I am not sure if it would be a good hire, but it does seem like some of the narratives against him are a little overblown.

https://chicago.suntimes.com/bulls/2020/2/13/21135479/tom-thibodeau-hungry-start-winning-again-bulls-timberwolves-nba-all-star-weekend

Few NBA coaches have been as successful as Thibodeau the last 15 years, and while he’s back in Chicago for All-Star Weekend, here’s a reminder that the numbers dispel a lot of false narratives.
Spoiler:
By Joe Cowley Feb 13, 2020, 12:40pm CST

Zach LaVine grinned as he put on his winter coat and reflected back.

“Mr. Thibs … he should damn well be coaching somewhere, that’s for sure.’’ the Bulls guard said, as he gathered his belongings from the visiting locker on Tuesday night in Washington, minutes from leaving for the team bus.

A sentiment not just isolated to LaVine, a player that worked under Tom Thibodeau for just one season in Minnesota before the then-Timberwolves coach/president of basketball operations traded him in a package for Jimmy Butler.

“Look, I understand the business of basketball,’’ LaVine continued. “Yeah, he traded me, but for that one season he did coach me, he gave me an opportunity. He put the ball in the hands of 20, 21-year-old kid and said, ‘Go hoop.’ That’s bigger than the business of basketball.’’

Ah yes, the current business of basketball.

A balance of politicking, staying in front of the narrative, all the while understanding that players and coaches are just pieces on the chessboard, there to help win or simply sacrificed along the way.

That’s where Thibodeau resides these days.

Just off the board, waiting for his chance to be brought back in.

Ironic that the All-Star Weekend is back in Chicago, the place where Thibodeau first made his mark as an NBA head coach a decade ago. A supposed three-day gathering of the best of the best in the world. From players, to coaches, to scouts and executives that make up the Association.

So how is it that one of the elite coaches the game has seen in the last 15 years is currently without a job?

Like Thibodeau himself, it’s complicated.

“I figured out that Thibs loved me unconditionally. He’s the first coach up here that I felt like loved me unconditionally and it wasn’t about what I did for him.’’ – Former Bulls guard Derrick Rose on Thibodeau to the Detroit News earlier this season.

Those close to Thibodeau have asked the coach to defend himself against the false narrative for years.

The same old tired storylines, whether they were created by an organization that wanted to justify splitting up with him, media members that found his approach too gruff for their liking, or players that would rather be catered to by the man in charge over being coached.

“Thibodeau grinds his players, Thibodeau doesn’t play young guys, Thibodeau’s offense is outdated, Thibodeau’s volume on the sidelines is always on 10.’’

That’s the lazy perception of him. The easy out.

The problem is that in a day and age where every franchise has an analytics department that they lean on, all the numbers surrounding Thibodeau scream just how wrong the perception of him actually is.

Even if he won’t.

“For me it’s always been about being true to yourself,’’ Thibodeau told the Sun-Times in a phone interview. “If you do the research, look at the numbers and talk to the players that have played for me, you would find the truth.

“It’s not frustrating because it’s all part of it, part of the league. We’re all going to get criticized for something. I’ve always been comfortable with that.’’

Easy to be when the track record is as stellar as Thibodeau’s. Over the last 15 seasons, whether he was head coach or associate head coach, Thibodeau coached teams have a .643 winning percentage.

In his five years as the head coach of the Bulls, the franchise was 255-139 (.647 winning percentage), posted a franchise-best 86 consecutive-game streak without losing more than two games in a row, and led the league in close-game winning percentage at .626 (66-40).

All of that even with a horrific torn anterior cruciate ligament derailing Rose’s career, as well as the dynasty the franchise thought it was building.

Thibodeau only had Rose for 47 percent of the games he coached with the Bulls, and when Rose was on the floor, the coach won 73 percent of those games.

When he took over in Minnesota after being fired by the Bulls, he inherited a franchise that was an NBA punchline. The Timberwolves only knew of the postseason on television, missing out on it for 13 straight seasons of ineptitude.

By Year 2, Thibodeau had acquired All-Star Jimmy Butler, watched his team go 36-25 with Butler — including an eye-opening 27-10 against the gantlet that was the Western Conference that season. Even when Butler went down, Thibodeau kept the boat afloat to get the young Wolves into the playoffs, finishing the regular season with a second-best 34-18 conference record.

His reward?

He was fired in Year 3, coincidentally after two 20-point wins.

The Thibodeau effect felt by both organizations since? The Bulls are 151-232 (.394), while Minnesota is 33-61 (.351).

“Coach Thibs is one of the best coaches I’ve ever played for, and when you get a coach like that, his basketball IQ is very high. I think it’s smart to listen to him and have a relationship where you always understand where he’s coming from.’’ – Former Bulls forward Luol Deng.

The idea that the Thibodeau offense is old school in today’s modern NBA is laughable.

Thibodeau’s offensive rating with the Bulls was 11th his first season, improved to fifth overall his second season, and even in the final season in which the front office deemed that his offense needed improvement, it was 10th in the NBA.

Since Thibodeau left the Bulls, the team has never had an offense rating higher than 21st and have finished 28th or worse three times.

In Minnesota, Thibodeau’s offensive rating was 10th best in the league his first season, a franchise-record fourth-best (110.8) in the 2017-18 season, and even in the chaos of 2018-19 was still ranked 13th. This season Minnesota’s offensive rating is 23rd.

“Look, again it’s probably how the league goes,’’ Thibodeau said, when presented with the idea that he’s only an elite defensive mind. “You’re put into a box where you’re either an offensive, defensive coach or a player development guy. Fair or unfair.

“You have to be whatever your team needs you to be.’’

That’s why Thibodeau has always adapted his offense to the personnel, rather than being so stuck on his players running a certain offense.

Tom Thibodeau adapts his offense to the personnel he has, like turning Joakim Noah into a point-center in the 2013-14 season.

It’s that mind that turned Joakim Noah into a point-center during the 2013-14 season, earning Noah a fourth-place finish in the MVP voting, as well as resurrecting the careers of point guards like Nate Robinson, D.J. Augustine, and Aaron Brooks.

He made the Bulls “Bench Mob’’ a feared reserve group from 2010-12, and turned Luol Deng from an enigma into an All-Star.

Just to make sure he’s keeping up with offenses, like he did when the last time when he was between jobs, Thibodeau has been visiting other NBA teams this season, making stops in Miami, Los Angeles, and last week San Francisco. He’s also been attending analytics summits, attending college games, and talking ball with whoever wants to talk ball.

“You’re getting all kinds of good ideas, and you don’t know where a good idea may come from,’’ Thibodeau said. “You’re picking everyone’s brain.’’

“Like I tell everybody, Thibs is a big part — and you can tell I’m smiling because it’s the truth — of who I am today as a player.’’ – Heat guard Jimmy Butler last season.

The minutes police loved to follow Thibodeau around in his Chicago days. That’s where the narrative on long practice days and heavy game minutes started.

Meanwhile, forget the fact that numerous players that worked under Thibodeau have debunked the long-practice storyline, admitting that many in-season practices were more mental than physical, and praising the way Thibodeau paced players throughout the season.

Then there’s the notion that he somehow didn’t have the best welfare of his star players in mind, putting them out there for heavy minutes. That just wasn’t the case. Thibodeau is from the school of thought that generally speaking the best players on every team have historically played the most minutes, and most often they are positionally matched up with each other.

It’s that simple.

Then there’s the idea that he stayed away from playing rookies and young players.

Forget the fact that Rose was the league’s youngest ever MVP at 22, rookies like Omer Asik and Taj Gibson flourished under Thibodeau, and when he moved to Minnesota, he played the likes of a young LaVine, Andrew Wiggins and Karl-Anthony Towns, as they all had major bumps in their games.

“He trusted me, he played me 37 minutes a game as a young kid, put that ball in my hand,’’ LaVine said. “Thibs’ style works. He’s not a beat-around-the-bush type of guy. This is just a guy that once you buy into his coaching, I mean look at the track record. It’s pretty damn good.’’

“[Thibodeau] was great for me. Me and him, we were really good. I respect him as a coach, as a person. He’s the most consistent person I‘ve been around, whether we’re just talking or it’s the game-day routine leading up to the game. It was always the same no matter what.” – Wing Andrew Wiggins to the Mercury News this week.

It’s not like Thibodeau is hurting by any means.

He’s still being paid by Minnesota, appeared on ESPN, and of course is making the NBA camp rounds.

But it’s not coaching.

Sharks hunt. That’s what they were put on the planet to do. Thibodeau coaches. That’s what he was put on the planet to do.

“Trust me, I’ve kicked back and read a book on a beach somewhere, got some warm weather,’’ Thibodeau said. “This has been a great opportunity to recharge, to learn, visit with friends and family, things you normally can’t do in a season.

“But I love coaching. That’s my passion. When you’re not in it you miss the camaraderie, and I know for me I really miss the competition. That’s what I miss the most.’’

So how has he been replacing that competition vacancy?

“Well, I’m killing my walking … I mean my walking is off the charts,’’ Thibodeau joked. “Nah, it’s good.’’

Not that Thibodeau isn’t a rumor.

With every vacancy, his name comes up.

“As you look at our league there’s 30 chances and 30 jobs, so I’m sure every time a coach’s opening comes up his name is brought up by ownership and executives,’’ Bulls vice president of basketball operations John Paxson said on Tuesday.

As for the organization he started with, while Thibodeau’s departure from Chicago was less than harmonious, especially since board chairman Jerry Reinsdorf released a less than flattering statement upon the dismissal, amends have been made.

“I truly believe that 90 percent of my time there was very positive,’’ Thibodeau said of the Bulls. “I wasn’t perfect, they weren’t perfect. Part of it was circumstances where we had a great first two years and Derrick is 22, the team is getting better, and we’re going to have a great chance to win a championship, and I think we would have if he wouldn’t have gotten hurt. Everything changed. And look, after doing the president’s job [in Minnesota] I saw why they made some of the decisions they did. It’s not as easy at looks.

“[Jerry] hiring me changed a lot for me. He took a chance on me, and I will always appreciate that.’’

The fact that Thibodeau and Paxson have mended bridges says a lot about where both men are in their lives and careers.

“We’ve talked,’’ Paxson said. “You know when you’re in the midst of things as we were, and I’m sure both of us, I would say it, he would say it, it didn’t end like either of us wanted it to. That’s part of this business sometimes.

“But you have to be really narrow-minded not to appreciate being in an NBA organizational environment together, trying to do great things. There’s no questioning that Tom is a really, really smart basketball guy and his passion for the game is something that’s always served him well.’’

The business of basketball all but demands that Thibodeau’s name should be brought up.

Thibodeau should be back on that chessboard.

Right where he belongs.


GREAT read.
I’m with it.
Clyde_Style
RealGM
Posts: 71,855
And1: 69,930
Joined: Jul 12, 2009

Re: Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely! 

Post#102 » by Clyde_Style » Mon Feb 24, 2020 6:45 pm

Thibs could end up disastrously or not

BUT

I can't lie and pretend I wouldn't enjoy seeing players like Randle and Knox get their azzes chewed out and benched for playing crap defense

Players who are still here that might benefit from Thibs are

Frank could be the luckiest one in the bunch. Thibs may extend his runway and allow him more time to lock down his outside shot

Woot! may get more of a shot under Thibs

Mitch would almost surely get more minutes

RJ may do well under Thibs because he will try to defend even if he can't contain everyone from penetrating

Dot would probably find a solid spot in the rotation

Iggy could easily benefit since his offensive game is pretty well developed and he may be willing to expend the defensive effort Thibs demands

Taj if he's brought back could also be in the rotation

One year deals like Portis, Ellington and Payton will be gone.

I could see Bullock coming back on a cheaper deal perhaps

Smith & Knox would be the biggest reclamation projects for Thibs and I doubt he'll care about them so I'd expect them to fade into oblivion if Thibs is the coach

That leaves the question mark of Trier. Could Thibs find a use for him?

SUMMARY: Our current and future youth may actually get MORE playing time under Thibs, so regardless of whether he's a good coach for today's NBA you'd probably get one of your wishes granted as a fan with more time for the kids
User avatar
dakomish23
Forum Mod - Knicks
Forum Mod - Knicks
Posts: 58,794
And1: 48,767
Joined: Sep 22, 2013
Location: Empire State
     

Re: Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely! 

Post#103 » by dakomish23 » Mon Feb 24, 2020 6:46 pm

CharlesOakley wrote:https://fansided.com/2014/02/03/nba-rumors-carlos-boozer-unhappy-tom-thibodeau-benching/

I would love to see Randle and whomever else get benched when they don't perform on the defensive side of the ball.


Which player was better?

Prime Carlos Boozer or Randle
Jimmit79 wrote:Yea RJ played well he was definitely the x factor


#FreeJimmit
Clyde_Style
RealGM
Posts: 71,855
And1: 69,930
Joined: Jul 12, 2009

Re: Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely! 

Post#104 » by Clyde_Style » Mon Feb 24, 2020 6:51 pm

dakomish23 wrote:
CharlesOakley wrote:https://fansided.com/2014/02/03/nba-rumors-carlos-boozer-unhappy-tom-thibodeau-benching/

I would love to see Randle and whomever else get benched when they don't perform on the defensive side of the ball.


Which player was better?

Prime Carlos Boozer or Randle


Boozer

He had those funky shots from mid-range where his arms would kick back like a wheat thresher that gave him a high release point that was hard to block. I'd take those shots that were fairly efficient without all of the bumbling the ball in the paint that Randle is guilty of too often.
User avatar
Deeeez Knicks
Forum Mod - Knicks
Forum Mod - Knicks
Posts: 49,443
And1: 55,506
Joined: Nov 12, 2004

Re: Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely! 

Post#105 » by Deeeez Knicks » Mon Feb 24, 2020 6:54 pm

dakomish23 wrote:
CharlesOakley wrote:https://fansided.com/2014/02/03/nba-rumors-carlos-boozer-unhappy-tom-thibodeau-benching/

I would love to see Randle and whomever else get benched when they don't perform on the defensive side of the ball.


Which player was better?

Prime Carlos Boozer or Randle


Boozer. He was a 2 time all-star and made the all-NBA 3rd team once.

Randle playing in this era hurts him a lot.
Mavs
C: Horford | Goga | Paul Reed |
PF: Lauri Markkanen | Randle | Tucker
SF: Trey Murphy | Trent | Anderson | Simone
SG: Vassell | Trent | Livingston
PG: Spida | Mann | Deuce
Clyde_Style
RealGM
Posts: 71,855
And1: 69,930
Joined: Jul 12, 2009

Re: Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely! 

Post#106 » by Clyde_Style » Mon Feb 24, 2020 6:54 pm

One important factor is you don't hire a big name like Thibs and tell him who to give minutes to.

All of our coaches may have had directives from the FO on whom to play and they didn't have the clout to only do what they personally wanted.

That would not happen with Thibs (or JVG, etc.) at least.
User avatar
dakomish23
Forum Mod - Knicks
Forum Mod - Knicks
Posts: 58,794
And1: 48,767
Joined: Sep 22, 2013
Location: Empire State
     

Re: Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely! 

Post#107 » by dakomish23 » Mon Feb 24, 2020 7:36 pm

Clyde_Style wrote:
dakomish23 wrote:
CharlesOakley wrote:https://fansided.com/2014/02/03/nba-rumors-carlos-boozer-unhappy-tom-thibodeau-benching/

I would love to see Randle and whomever else get benched when they don't perform on the defensive side of the ball.


Which player was better?

Prime Carlos Boozer or Randle


Boozer

He had those funky shots from mid-range where his arms would kick back like a wheat thresher that gave him a high release point that was hard to block. I'd take those shots that were fairly efficient without all of the bumbling the ball in the paint that Randle is guilty of too often.


This is actually decent set if you have guards who teams will chase

https://youtu.be/6PHgBZkm6Mw

Get ready for a lot of Randle mid range jumpers with Mitch as the roll guy
Jimmit79 wrote:Yea RJ played well he was definitely the x factor


#FreeJimmit
User avatar
dakomish23
Forum Mod - Knicks
Forum Mod - Knicks
Posts: 58,794
And1: 48,767
Joined: Sep 22, 2013
Location: Empire State
     

Re: Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely! 

Post#108 » by dakomish23 » Mon Feb 24, 2020 7:43 pm

Deeeez Knicks wrote:
dakomish23 wrote:
CharlesOakley wrote:https://fansided.com/2014/02/03/nba-rumors-carlos-boozer-unhappy-tom-thibodeau-benching/

I would love to see Randle and whomever else get benched when they don't perform on the defensive side of the ball.


Which player was better?

Prime Carlos Boozer or Randle


Boozer. He was a 2 time all-star and made the all-NBA 3rd team once.

Randle playing in this era hurts him a lot.


Plus he made one of the best gifs of all time

Image

Can’t help Randle that he plays for an organization susceptible to trying to make players something they’re not. Put him on a team that would use him primarily in the PnR and I bet he looks 10x better.
Jimmit79 wrote:Yea RJ played well he was definitely the x factor


#FreeJimmit
Tornelyus
Sophomore
Posts: 177
And1: 83
Joined: Aug 19, 2017
   

Re: Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely! 

Post#109 » by Tornelyus » Mon Feb 24, 2020 7:47 pm

I'm not a fan but it is a bit unfair to say Thibs cannot develop. Surely not a Pop or Spo, but at least he is not shy to give minutes to talent.
In Chicago, Rose became youngest MVP. A really raw Jimmy Butler did fine also. Other than Doug McDermott in his last year, he did not had any youngsters. (in his defence, it was a 50 win team, built to win now and Doug was a bit disappointment at that times). Mirotic (23 or 24 at that time) had more than 20mpg with double digit ppg as well.
As for vets, Deng was a good player then and with Thibs he developed into an allstar. Fringe players like Omer Asik and Nate Robinson had their best times under him.

In Minny, first year other than Dunn (who played behind a 26 years old Rubio), 21 years old LaVine, Wiggings, KAT played 37 mpg at least. Okogie and Tyus was having +20 mpg as a 20 old (maybe 21, not so sure).

Offense, attempted 3's may be a concern but, "he cannot develop" is a bit prejudiced imo.
User avatar
GONYK
Forum Mod - Knicks
Forum Mod - Knicks
Posts: 67,037
And1: 45,914
Joined: Jun 27, 2003
Location: Brunson Gang
   

Re: Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely! 

Post#110 » by GONYK » Mon Feb 24, 2020 7:48 pm

dakomish23 wrote:
Deeeez Knicks wrote:
dakomish23 wrote:
Which player was better?

Prime Carlos Boozer or Randle


Boozer. He was a 2 time all-star and made the all-NBA 3rd team once.

Randle playing in this era hurts him a lot.


Plus he made one of the best gifs of all time

Image

Can’t help Randle that he plays for an organization susceptible to trying to make players something they’re not. Put him on a team that would use him primarily in the PnR and I bet he looks 10x better.


If he would just set actual screens, not dribble/shoot into double teams and play with consistent defensive effort, I bet he looks 10x better too.
User avatar
dakomish23
Forum Mod - Knicks
Forum Mod - Knicks
Posts: 58,794
And1: 48,767
Joined: Sep 22, 2013
Location: Empire State
     

Re: Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely! 

Post#111 » by dakomish23 » Mon Feb 24, 2020 7:50 pm

GONYK wrote:
dakomish23 wrote:
Deeeez Knicks wrote:
Boozer. He was a 2 time all-star and made the all-NBA 3rd team once.

Randle playing in this era hurts him a lot.


Plus he made one of the best gifs of all time

Image

Can’t help Randle that he plays for an organization susceptible to trying to make players something they’re not. Put him on a team that would use him primarily in the PnR and I bet he looks 10x better.


If he would just set actual screens and play with consistent defensive effort, I bet he looks 10x better too.


You’re asking for things that I’m not sure he’s capable of :lol:

I made my assumption based on what we know about his skillset. Maybe he can do those things too and it’s just the Knicks effect
Jimmit79 wrote:Yea RJ played well he was definitely the x factor


#FreeJimmit
User avatar
Deeeez Knicks
Forum Mod - Knicks
Forum Mod - Knicks
Posts: 49,443
And1: 55,506
Joined: Nov 12, 2004

Re: Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely! 

Post#112 » by Deeeez Knicks » Mon Feb 24, 2020 7:56 pm

dakomish23 wrote:
Deeeez Knicks wrote:
dakomish23 wrote:
Which player was better?

Prime Carlos Boozer or Randle


Boozer. He was a 2 time all-star and made the all-NBA 3rd team once.

Randle playing in this era hurts him a lot.


Plus he made one of the best gifs of all time

Image

Can’t help Randle that he plays for an organization susceptible to trying to make players something they’re not. Put him on a team that would use him primarily in the PnR and I bet he looks 10x better.


Randle needs the right teammates too (spacing, defenders, good pg, etc). It’s a bad fit on this roster even if we adjust his role.

But yeah, agree on the right team, in the right situation he can be better. Kinda like Timmy, Kanter too. But it’s just probably not here. It will be too difficult to make it work, and just not worth it.

He needs to go.
Mavs
C: Horford | Goga | Paul Reed |
PF: Lauri Markkanen | Randle | Tucker
SF: Trey Murphy | Trent | Anderson | Simone
SG: Vassell | Trent | Livingston
PG: Spida | Mann | Deuce
User avatar
Dave DaButcher
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,698
And1: 4,301
Joined: May 16, 2017
     

Re: Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely! 

Post#113 » by Dave DaButcher » Mon Feb 24, 2020 8:29 pm

Deeeez Knicks wrote:A good read. Some fair points if you are looking for the pro-Thibs side. I am not sure if it would be a good hire, but it does seem like some of the narratives against him are a little overblown.

https://chicago.suntimes.com/bulls/2020/2/13/21135479/tom-thibodeau-hungry-start-winning-again-bulls-timberwolves-nba-all-star-weekend

Few NBA coaches have been as successful as Thibodeau the last 15 years, and while he’s back in Chicago for All-Star Weekend, here’s a reminder that the numbers dispel a lot of false narratives.
Spoiler:
By Joe Cowley Feb 13, 2020, 12:40pm CST

Zach LaVine grinned as he put on his winter coat and reflected back.

“Mr. Thibs … he should damn well be coaching somewhere, that’s for sure.’’ the Bulls guard said, as he gathered his belongings from the visiting locker on Tuesday night in Washington, minutes from leaving for the team bus.

A sentiment not just isolated to LaVine, a player that worked under Tom Thibodeau for just one season in Minnesota before the then-Timberwolves coach/president of basketball operations traded him in a package for Jimmy Butler.

“Look, I understand the business of basketball,’’ LaVine continued. “Yeah, he traded me, but for that one season he did coach me, he gave me an opportunity. He put the ball in the hands of 20, 21-year-old kid and said, ‘Go hoop.’ That’s bigger than the business of basketball.’’

Ah yes, the current business of basketball.

A balance of politicking, staying in front of the narrative, all the while understanding that players and coaches are just pieces on the chessboard, there to help win or simply sacrificed along the way.

That’s where Thibodeau resides these days.

Just off the board, waiting for his chance to be brought back in.

Ironic that the All-Star Weekend is back in Chicago, the place where Thibodeau first made his mark as an NBA head coach a decade ago. A supposed three-day gathering of the best of the best in the world. From players, to coaches, to scouts and executives that make up the Association.

So how is it that one of the elite coaches the game has seen in the last 15 years is currently without a job?

Like Thibodeau himself, it’s complicated.

“I figured out that Thibs loved me unconditionally. He’s the first coach up here that I felt like loved me unconditionally and it wasn’t about what I did for him.’’ – Former Bulls guard Derrick Rose on Thibodeau to the Detroit News earlier this season.

Those close to Thibodeau have asked the coach to defend himself against the false narrative for years.

The same old tired storylines, whether they were created by an organization that wanted to justify splitting up with him, media members that found his approach too gruff for their liking, or players that would rather be catered to by the man in charge over being coached.

“Thibodeau grinds his players, Thibodeau doesn’t play young guys, Thibodeau’s offense is outdated, Thibodeau’s volume on the sidelines is always on 10.’’

That’s the lazy perception of him. The easy out.

The problem is that in a day and age where every franchise has an analytics department that they lean on, all the numbers surrounding Thibodeau scream just how wrong the perception of him actually is.

Even if he won’t.

“For me it’s always been about being true to yourself,’’ Thibodeau told the Sun-Times in a phone interview. “If you do the research, look at the numbers and talk to the players that have played for me, you would find the truth.

“It’s not frustrating because it’s all part of it, part of the league. We’re all going to get criticized for something. I’ve always been comfortable with that.’’

Easy to be when the track record is as stellar as Thibodeau’s. Over the last 15 seasons, whether he was head coach or associate head coach, Thibodeau coached teams have a .643 winning percentage.

In his five years as the head coach of the Bulls, the franchise was 255-139 (.647 winning percentage), posted a franchise-best 86 consecutive-game streak without losing more than two games in a row, and led the league in close-game winning percentage at .626 (66-40).

All of that even with a horrific torn anterior cruciate ligament derailing Rose’s career, as well as the dynasty the franchise thought it was building.

Thibodeau only had Rose for 47 percent of the games he coached with the Bulls, and when Rose was on the floor, the coach won 73 percent of those games.

When he took over in Minnesota after being fired by the Bulls, he inherited a franchise that was an NBA punchline. The Timberwolves only knew of the postseason on television, missing out on it for 13 straight seasons of ineptitude.

By Year 2, Thibodeau had acquired All-Star Jimmy Butler, watched his team go 36-25 with Butler — including an eye-opening 27-10 against the gantlet that was the Western Conference that season. Even when Butler went down, Thibodeau kept the boat afloat to get the young Wolves into the playoffs, finishing the regular season with a second-best 34-18 conference record.

His reward?

He was fired in Year 3, coincidentally after two 20-point wins.

The Thibodeau effect felt by both organizations since? The Bulls are 151-232 (.394), while Minnesota is 33-61 (.351).

“Coach Thibs is one of the best coaches I’ve ever played for, and when you get a coach like that, his basketball IQ is very high. I think it’s smart to listen to him and have a relationship where you always understand where he’s coming from.’’ – Former Bulls forward Luol Deng.

The idea that the Thibodeau offense is old school in today’s modern NBA is laughable.

Thibodeau’s offensive rating with the Bulls was 11th his first season, improved to fifth overall his second season, and even in the final season in which the front office deemed that his offense needed improvement, it was 10th in the NBA.

Since Thibodeau left the Bulls, the team has never had an offense rating higher than 21st and have finished 28th or worse three times.

In Minnesota, Thibodeau’s offensive rating was 10th best in the league his first season, a franchise-record fourth-best (110.8) in the 2017-18 season, and even in the chaos of 2018-19 was still ranked 13th. This season Minnesota’s offensive rating is 23rd.

“Look, again it’s probably how the league goes,’’ Thibodeau said, when presented with the idea that he’s only an elite defensive mind. “You’re put into a box where you’re either an offensive, defensive coach or a player development guy. Fair or unfair.

“You have to be whatever your team needs you to be.’’

That’s why Thibodeau has always adapted his offense to the personnel, rather than being so stuck on his players running a certain offense.

Tom Thibodeau adapts his offense to the personnel he has, like turning Joakim Noah into a point-center in the 2013-14 season.

It’s that mind that turned Joakim Noah into a point-center during the 2013-14 season, earning Noah a fourth-place finish in the MVP voting, as well as resurrecting the careers of point guards like Nate Robinson, D.J. Augustine, and Aaron Brooks.

He made the Bulls “Bench Mob’’ a feared reserve group from 2010-12, and turned Luol Deng from an enigma into an All-Star.

Just to make sure he’s keeping up with offenses, like he did when the last time when he was between jobs, Thibodeau has been visiting other NBA teams this season, making stops in Miami, Los Angeles, and last week San Francisco. He’s also been attending analytics summits, attending college games, and talking ball with whoever wants to talk ball.

“You’re getting all kinds of good ideas, and you don’t know where a good idea may come from,’’ Thibodeau said. “You’re picking everyone’s brain.’’

“Like I tell everybody, Thibs is a big part — and you can tell I’m smiling because it’s the truth — of who I am today as a player.’’ – Heat guard Jimmy Butler last season.

The minutes police loved to follow Thibodeau around in his Chicago days. That’s where the narrative on long practice days and heavy game minutes started.

Meanwhile, forget the fact that numerous players that worked under Thibodeau have debunked the long-practice storyline, admitting that many in-season practices were more mental than physical, and praising the way Thibodeau paced players throughout the season.

Then there’s the notion that he somehow didn’t have the best welfare of his star players in mind, putting them out there for heavy minutes. That just wasn’t the case. Thibodeau is from the school of thought that generally speaking the best players on every team have historically played the most minutes, and most often they are positionally matched up with each other.

It’s that simple.

Then there’s the idea that he stayed away from playing rookies and young players.

Forget the fact that Rose was the league’s youngest ever MVP at 22, rookies like Omer Asik and Taj Gibson flourished under Thibodeau, and when he moved to Minnesota, he played the likes of a young LaVine, Andrew Wiggins and Karl-Anthony Towns, as they all had major bumps in their games.

“He trusted me, he played me 37 minutes a game as a young kid, put that ball in my hand,’’ LaVine said. “Thibs’ style works. He’s not a beat-around-the-bush type of guy. This is just a guy that once you buy into his coaching, I mean look at the track record. It’s pretty damn good.’’

“[Thibodeau] was great for me. Me and him, we were really good. I respect him as a coach, as a person. He’s the most consistent person I‘ve been around, whether we’re just talking or it’s the game-day routine leading up to the game. It was always the same no matter what.” – Wing Andrew Wiggins to the Mercury News this week.

It’s not like Thibodeau is hurting by any means.

He’s still being paid by Minnesota, appeared on ESPN, and of course is making the NBA camp rounds.

But it’s not coaching.

Sharks hunt. That’s what they were put on the planet to do. Thibodeau coaches. That’s what he was put on the planet to do.

“Trust me, I’ve kicked back and read a book on a beach somewhere, got some warm weather,’’ Thibodeau said. “This has been a great opportunity to recharge, to learn, visit with friends and family, things you normally can’t do in a season.

“But I love coaching. That’s my passion. When you’re not in it you miss the camaraderie, and I know for me I really miss the competition. That’s what I miss the most.’’

So how has he been replacing that competition vacancy?

“Well, I’m killing my walking … I mean my walking is off the charts,’’ Thibodeau joked. “Nah, it’s good.’’

Not that Thibodeau isn’t a rumor.

With every vacancy, his name comes up.

“As you look at our league there’s 30 chances and 30 jobs, so I’m sure every time a coach’s opening comes up his name is brought up by ownership and executives,’’ Bulls vice president of basketball operations John Paxson said on Tuesday.

As for the organization he started with, while Thibodeau’s departure from Chicago was less than harmonious, especially since board chairman Jerry Reinsdorf released a less than flattering statement upon the dismissal, amends have been made.

“I truly believe that 90 percent of my time there was very positive,’’ Thibodeau said of the Bulls. “I wasn’t perfect, they weren’t perfect. Part of it was circumstances where we had a great first two years and Derrick is 22, the team is getting better, and we’re going to have a great chance to win a championship, and I think we would have if he wouldn’t have gotten hurt. Everything changed. And look, after doing the president’s job [in Minnesota] I saw why they made some of the decisions they did. It’s not as easy at looks.

“[Jerry] hiring me changed a lot for me. He took a chance on me, and I will always appreciate that.’’

The fact that Thibodeau and Paxson have mended bridges says a lot about where both men are in their lives and careers.

“We’ve talked,’’ Paxson said. “You know when you’re in the midst of things as we were, and I’m sure both of us, I would say it, he would say it, it didn’t end like either of us wanted it to. That’s part of this business sometimes.

“But you have to be really narrow-minded not to appreciate being in an NBA organizational environment together, trying to do great things. There’s no questioning that Tom is a really, really smart basketball guy and his passion for the game is something that’s always served him well.’’

The business of basketball all but demands that Thibodeau’s name should be brought up.

Thibodeau should be back on that chessboard.

Right where he belongs.

Excellent article, thanks for sharing.

I'm now a pro-Thibs convert. The data they cite regarding his teams' offensive ratings refute a main tenet of the anti-Thibs narrative. And the effusive praise from a number of former players speaks volumes.

Sounds like he's a relentless worker, is all steak and no sizzle, and what you see is what you get with him. Essentially, the anti-Fizdale.

Count me among those on Team Thibs.
seren
RealGM
Posts: 24,727
And1: 4,957
Joined: Jul 21, 2002

Re: Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely! 

Post#114 » by seren » Mon Feb 24, 2020 8:29 pm

thebuzzardman wrote:
Deeeez Knicks wrote:Some more info from Macri's newsletter.

To be clear, the crux of the article was supposed to be that Leon Rose is all but set to take over as Knicks President, and that the move could happen as soon as this week. In the process of researching that story, I heard from someone I trust that Thibs was also a heavy favorite to become the head coach.

I can’t emphasize this enough: a lot can change between now and the end of the season, especially with the possibility that other coaches could unexpectedly be fired or emerge as willing candidates for this job. But based on what the Knicks’ seem to be thinking right now, I’d be shocked if the Iceman himself isn’t the man that ends up with it.

Based on my replies and mentions last night, that doesn’t seem to be sitting well with a lot of people. And I get it. Thibs didn’t exactly leave Minnesota on a high note, getting fired midway through last season with a record of 19-21 after failing to bring his special brew with him from Chicago to the Wolves.


https://knicksfilmschool.substack.com/

Also, thought this quote from Taj was interesting...kinda a shot at Wiggins/KAT while vouching for Thibs.

Which brings us to today, or more accurately, a few weeks ago. I mentioned it here but in case you missed it, Taj Gibson was in the locker room right before the break talking about his former coach with both the Bulls and Wolves, and said in no uncertain terms that if you have players who are willing to be coached, Thibs is the guy you want.


Can't wait until next year, when Gibson is playing 40 mpg and Mitch is playing 8 mpg


His career high was 33.2 mpg under Thibs. Thibs best season in Chicago, Taj played less than 21 mpg. He played Luol Deng and Derrick Rose, ages 25 and 22 respectively, heavy minutes. Other than that everyone else averaged less than 33 mpg.

https://www.basketball-reference.com/teams/CHI/2011.html

Thibs played his best players heavy minutes. I doubt he would consider Taj as his best player at this point in time. The worry is more like he overplays the younger guys. RJ would average 35+. If we don’t get another PG, Frank would be under minute pressure too as well as Mitch. I don’t see Portis getting much time if he is still around.
BLACKFEET 2010
RealGM
Posts: 10,285
And1: 3,847
Joined: Jun 26, 2009

Re: Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely! 

Post#115 » by BLACKFEET 2010 » Mon Feb 24, 2020 8:39 pm

Doesn’t Thibbs run the triangle?

I know y’all would hate it but he’d probably love Randle (and find efficient ways to use him).

Hey...if he could give RJ some of what he gave Jimmy, it’s worth it.

And man, think about it: Shump, Kawhi and Jimmy, who woulda thought that would work out how it did? Shump on the surface was by far the most talented. Funny how things play out. The draft, the league for that matter, is so unpredictable.
User avatar
thebuzzardman
RealGM
Posts: 82,572
And1: 96,616
Joined: Jun 24, 2006
Location: Villanovknicks

Re: Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely! 

Post#116 » by thebuzzardman » Mon Feb 24, 2020 8:58 pm

JohnStarksTheDunk wrote:
thebuzzardman wrote:
JohnStarksTheDunk wrote:Putting aside for a moment the issue of whether or not Thibs would be a good hire, I don't like hearing that we are supposedly already 90% decided on ANY candidate, before the position is even technically open and before we've done interviews. Why not do an earnest coaching search in the off-season, when there is likely to be a bigger/better pool of candidates?

Relatedly, JVG is notorious for not wanting to comment on or consider a coaching position that isn't vacant, because he takes the brotherhood of coaching and professionalism very seriously. A process like ours doesn't seem to even be allowing for candidates like him or others who might feel the same way.

And let's also not forget current assistants or college coaches who are right now still focused on THIS season.


The last "big coaching search" produced Fizdale.

Maybe it's not a bad idea to just hire someone who is good. Or at least once was good.

At least 50% of the posters already dislike it, so this is shaping up quite nicely for me. I just need that minority of posters who like the hire to grow a bit more. Then, perfect!


So the logic here is that we can't trust the front office to choose the right candidate out of a larger pool, and therefore we should trust that same front office to choose the right candidate from a limited pool of their own choosing?


I don't trust them for anything, but at least this pick is divisive! :D
Image
User avatar
thebuzzardman
RealGM
Posts: 82,572
And1: 96,616
Joined: Jun 24, 2006
Location: Villanovknicks

Re: Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely! 

Post#117 » by thebuzzardman » Mon Feb 24, 2020 9:17 pm

Deeeez Knicks wrote:
dakomish23 wrote:
Deeeez Knicks wrote:
Boozer. He was a 2 time all-star and made the all-NBA 3rd team once.

Randle playing in this era hurts him a lot.


Plus he made one of the best gifs of all time

Image

Can’t help Randle that he plays for an organization susceptible to trying to make players something they’re not. Put him on a team that would use him primarily in the PnR and I bet he looks 10x better.


Randle needs the right teammates too (spacing, defenders, good pg, etc). It’s a bad fit on this roster even if we adjust his role.

But yeah, agree on the right team, in the right situation he can be better. Kinda like Timmy, Kanter too. But it’s just probably not here. It will be too difficult to make it work, and just not worth it.

He needs to go.


Randle needs "the right kind of players"
RJ needs "the right kind of players"
Mitch needs "the right kind of players"
Frank needs "the right kind of players"

When a team has too many guys who need "the right kind of players", they have the wrong kinds of players.

Ok, a little hyberbolic.

Knicks need to decide who they are going to build around going forward and then cast off some guys and get in others that fit with "that guy"

Shooters who can shoot is a start. They go with lots of different kinds of players.
Image
User avatar
thebuzzardman
RealGM
Posts: 82,572
And1: 96,616
Joined: Jun 24, 2006
Location: Villanovknicks

Re: Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely! 

Post#118 » by thebuzzardman » Mon Feb 24, 2020 9:24 pm

If people want a "Riley Tree" guy around the Knicks, Thibs is that guy.
Hard working, gets the most out of his players; basketball lifer nut job.

Knicks tried for the "popular guy coach\Riley tree" guy and got a poser with glasses.

This is the real deal. Bring him in.
Image
User avatar
moocow007
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 98,264
And1: 25,725
Joined: Jan 07, 2002
Location: In front of the computer, where else?
       

Re: Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely! 

Post#119 » by moocow007 » Mon Feb 24, 2020 9:39 pm

Clyde_Style wrote:Thibs could end up disastrously or not

BUT

I can't lie and pretend I wouldn't enjoy seeing players like Randle and Knox get their azzes chewed out and benched for playing crap defense

Players who are still here that might benefit from Thibs are

Frank could be the luckiest one in the bunch. Thibs may extend his runway and allow him more time to lock down his outside shot

Woot! may get more of a shot under Thibs

Mitch would almost surely get more minutes

RJ may do well under Thibs because he will try to defend even if he can't contain everyone from penetrating

Dot would probably find a solid spot in the rotation

Iggy could easily benefit since his offensive game is pretty well developed and he may be willing to expend the defensive effort Thibs demands

Taj if he's brought back could also be in the rotation

One year deals like Portis, Ellington and Payton will be gone.

I could see Bullock coming back on a cheaper deal perhaps

Smith & Knox would be the biggest reclamation projects for Thibs and I doubt he'll care about them so I'd expect them to fade into oblivion if Thibs is the coach

That leaves the question mark of Trier. Could Thibs find a use for him?

SUMMARY: Our current and future youth may actually get MORE playing time under Thibs, so regardless of whether he's a good coach for today's NBA you'd probably get one of your wishes granted as a fan with more time for the kids


I would expect Thibodeau's head to explode after a couple games of no defense.
User avatar
Deeeez Knicks
Forum Mod - Knicks
Forum Mod - Knicks
Posts: 49,443
And1: 55,506
Joined: Nov 12, 2004

Re: Tom Thibodeau To The Knicks 90% Likely! 

Post#120 » by Deeeez Knicks » Mon Feb 24, 2020 9:41 pm

thebuzzardman wrote:
Deeeez Knicks wrote:
dakomish23 wrote:
Plus he made one of the best gifs of all time

Image

Can’t help Randle that he plays for an organization susceptible to trying to make players something they’re not. Put him on a team that would use him primarily in the PnR and I bet he looks 10x better.


Randle needs the right teammates too (spacing, defenders, good pg, etc). It’s a bad fit on this roster even if we adjust his role.

But yeah, agree on the right team, in the right situation he can be better. Kinda like Timmy, Kanter too. But it’s just probably not here. It will be too difficult to make it work, and just not worth it.

He needs to go.


Randle needs "the right kind of players"
RJ needs "the right kind of players"
Mitch needs "the right kind of players"
Frank needs "the right kind of players"

When a team has too many guys who need "the right kind of players", they have the wrong kinds of players.

Ok, a little hyberbolic.

Knicks need to decide who they are going to build around going forward and then cast off some guys and get in others that fit with "that guy"

Shooters who can shoot is a start. They go with lots of different kinds of players.


I mean, yeah, that statement is true for a lot of players. We need to build a roster that fits which goes without saying. It's just way more complicated to find the right kind of players for Randle while he is making $20mil, and when we brought him in after we had all those other guys who don't fit.
Mavs
C: Horford | Goga | Paul Reed |
PF: Lauri Markkanen | Randle | Tucker
SF: Trey Murphy | Trent | Anderson | Simone
SG: Vassell | Trent | Livingston
PG: Spida | Mann | Deuce

Return to New York Knicks