Polk377 wrote:Oscirus wrote:Polk377 wrote:
8th best? Really? I think Irving is the only clear cut better PG in the east. Everyone else is either worse or on par with Rose. A case can definitely be made for Lowery, Walker or Thomas but after that you are really pushing it. The difference this year for Rose is that he has clearly taken a step back for the good of the team and is letting the game come to him more rather than forcing the issue. He has Melo and KP to depend on to score the ball but when he has to turn it on he has been clutch down the stretches of games this year.
I'd put Wall above him as well. That would still makes him the sixth best guard in the east. He's not going to find a situation more desirable than this one in free agency. I'm not saying don't pay him, but at the same time the Knicks have to put a cap on how much they give him, he doesn't get to make franchise demands.
Sorry Wall is up there too. He still has to show he can lead his team to wins but I'll give him the benefit of the doubt because the rest of his team suck.
Just because there is 6 guys there does not make him the worst of the 6. I would take him over Walker and Lowery and would put Irving, Thomas and Wall over him at this point in the season. What separates Rose from these guys is the ability to break down a defense off the dribble and create for himself. While a third of Lowery and Walker's offense comes off of assists Rose makes it happen all by himself which makes him more dangerous.
I really don't think it will come down to franchise demands from him or the Knicks trying to low ball him either. This season has been going very well so far with him and the rest of the team. As long as it stays that way and they can make a playoff run I don't see why either side wouldn't work together amicably to make it happen.
I'm sorry, but Lowry, Irving, Wall, Thomas, Walker, and Dragic are clearly better than Rose right now in the East....and there's really no debate about it




















