VirginiaKnickFan wrote:MaseInYourFace wrote:thebuzzardman wrote:So, general thoughts about the Rose/Aller/Perrin/Zanin hires.
This is with the following caveats:
It could all suck
Dolan being around still can be the ultimate torpedo
There are still Dolan cronies around. Alan Houston for sure, others I'm less sure about.
Knicks have hired guys that seemed to be a decent idea and it failed before
Rose is still an ex agent and there isn't a big track record of success for those guys in the NBA as POBO/GM's
That out of the way, just general thoughts that in now way feel definitive.
Knicks SEEM to be on an upward trajectory of hiring guys who are liked around the league and have "been around"
Yes, ultimately TALENT is what matters. The talent seems to be there with Aller and Perrin. Rose's talent as a POBO is in question. I really know nothing about Zanin and pretty sure no one on here does either.
So, even though Mills sucked and was a snake, I THINK he was able to convince Dolan of some iterative moves towards respectability.
Holding onto picks. Getting more picks. Managing the cap and keeping $/space available for the truly excellent players. Hiring Perry, who is well liked around the league and has a long resume. Yes, Perry is probably a mediocre guy but bear with me.
I think Mills sold Dolan on some of these ideas, but also with the following: "I'm Steve Mills and I've got connections around the league, with players and FO's, and I can lure free agents once we build the base". Or, maybe Mills sold Dolan hard on his ability to bring in FA's once the KP situation fell apart and KP got traded. It's obvious that Mills put in Dolan's mind that "big time FA's are on the horizon" and "playoffs soon!" and Mills got the boot when neither happened.
Rose was hired to be the Mills that Mills couldn't be. Which is, have connections. Get trades done. And, also, I'd guess, be a generally competent POBO.
And Rose takes the following approach:
Continues the Knicks change of hiring guys with some respect around the league, and thankfully, some amount of talent: Aller/Perrin.
(Yes, I would prefer a big name GM hire, or well established "young exec on the rise". Oh well)
Keeps Perry around and doesn't sh*t on his head because Perry is WELL LIKED around the league. And connected. It might not make Perry good at his job - I think he's mediocre, but I think Rose keeps Perry around for "transition" reasons, but also to show the rest of the league the Knicks aren't the total d*ck organization they were before. This is just a hunch; I don't have a definitive opinion on it.
Rose keeps Perry on, but he brings in HIS OWN GUYS to do the heavy lifting. Cap. College Scouting. Pro Player Scouting.
I'm not saying Perry is a complete figurehead, but it's close.
What Rose is also doing is surrounding himself with loyalists. I'd assume this is important at MSG with Dolan always having his cronies.
Anyway, still looking forward to a different player development guy, analytics hire and maybe a hotshot young GM type next year (not sure on that one) but the outline of the approach Rose is taking seems reasonable.
Then again, It's the Knicks, and moves that've seemed reasonable before have turned into a total dungheap, so who knows.
Don’t the Warriors have an ex agent in their FO?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bob_Myers
Yup. And Pelinka for the Lakers has the agent background as well. Those are the cited success stories. I think there was one other instance of an agent getting involved in the FO in bball, but it didn't go well. It's in the "Leon Rose new POBO" topic somewhere.
My post was basically a thought that popped into my head where it kind of clicked "Why Rose?" Specifically, "Why Rose for DOLAN"
We can argue how much Dolan is involved in moves, how much he meddles, how much he is now "hands off" and I'm not sure. I think he's less hands on than he used to be, BUT, all owners will step in at some point and assert themselves. Nothing specifically wrong with that.
Of course, the million dollar questions are "how often does Dolan intervene" and, maybe more to the point "Does Dolan always have unrealistic expectations and/or unrealistic timelines"?
I mean, I think Mills was obviously stinking up the joint. But he seemed to have sold Dolan on a vision of "manage cap space, keep and acquire picks, and be in the mix for big FA's" I don't know if I covered it in the post, but I'm not sure how much Mills sold Dolan on "BIG FA's in 19-20!!!" after he traded KP, as maybe Dolan was kind of pissed about that and Mills oversold that to keep his job.
Or, Dolan misunderstood a more reasonable Mills take, that "KP being traded was unfortunate, but we got some assets, got cap room, we can TRY for the big FA's in 19-20, we might not get one, but we'll continue building the team, and we'll roll that cap space over and try again over the next few years, while building a young base through the draft"
I think Mills EXECUTION sucked. I don't trust his pro player scouting, or whoever advises him, as Mills decided to overpay and over commit years to THJr and Randler. Both guys not bad players, but not # 1's.
Anyway, it's clear that Mills was walking some tightrope with Dolan balancing "managing cap space" with "building the team" and "team getting competitive" and he wasn't doing a good job.
But Dolan pretty aggressively pulled the trigger on firing Mills and I made an attempt to understand what might be driving that process in DOLAN'S mind, so I'll kind of know what expectations Dolan has of Rose, which in turn tells me the parameters under which Rose will operate.
Dolan could have given Mills another year. I'm VERY GLAD he didn't. But the Knicks have sucked before. Why now?
IF Mills sold Dolan on landing some big FA's, but also that he'd be building the team to respectability, which helps with the FA draw/stars asking to be traded to you, I'm assuming Rose was brought in to do both.
Dolan sees the Nets getting respectable, probably starting to worry, valid or not, that the Nets will draw away fans, and he's embarrassed that not only did the Knicks NOT get FA's, which he was crowing about on TV, but the NETS! beat him to those guys. The second that happened, Mills was toast.
And Rose was hired to fix THAT.
Rose was hired to be POBO, but a POBO that can "get it done" when it comes to getting stars.
Either through FA, or the new school of players demanding trades while under contract
Think about it. Why a guy with an agent background instead of a GM/Exec background?
I hope it goes well, that the Knicks don't starph*ck lower tier stars that don't really move the franchise needle, cap themselves out and get on the mediocrity treadmill. We shall see.