RealGM

Fury wrote:

Greenie wrote:

GONYK wrote:
Fair enough.

If current IT were 25, I wouldn't trade 2 1sts for him.

Gotta do more than score for that kind of price tag to me.

I value clutch bucket getters.

I already said what I would do.

Trade KP and Noah for Kyrie.
Nothing else, just KP and Noah.

Melo can still be moved or not be moved(I don't care at this point)

Walk into next offseason with a pocket full of money and all of your picks with the following:

Kyrie/Baker
Frank/Timmy
Lee/Dotson/Kuz
Lance
Willy


Make your 1st rd pick and then throw a bag at Paul George.

Insert PG at PF and that team takes the east in my opinion. An elite lead scorer, and elite defensive wing with two other really good defensive players(guessing on Frank), a really good shooting team with a post man that can punish dudes on the block. PG can also playmake, allowing Kyrie to play off ball as well, especially if Frank is more pure point than him.

After we sign George we can also sign LeBron because this is fantasy land right

Besart19 wrote:Melo, Lee, KOQ and top5 protected pick for Irving, Frye and RJ

Love and Shump for Bledsoe and Chandler

Wade after his buyout in Chi

Chandler/TT
Carmelo/KOQ
Lebron/Korver
Lee/JR Smith
Wade/Rose

Noah / Willy
KP / Frye
LT / Kuz
THJ / Baker
Irving / Frank

newyorker4ever wrote:

Greenie wrote:

newyorker4ever wrote:

Okay i was just trying to find out just how much of a Knicks fan you really are is all. Thank you for giving me my answer.

Throwing insults?

Huh??

Greenie wrote:

newyorker4ever wrote:

Greenie wrote:Throwing insults?

Huh??

How much of a Knick fan I really am?

newyorker4ever wrote:

Greenie wrote:

newyorker4ever wrote:

Huh??

How much of a Knick fan I really am?

Yeah i think there's different types of fans, don't you?

Greenie wrote:

newyorker4ever wrote:

Greenie wrote:How much of a Knick fan I really am?

Yeah i think there's different types of fans, don't you?

Not really.

god shammgod wrote:look, some people appreciated melo and some people didn't. just like some people thought phil was doing a bad job and some people were wrong. there's always 2 sides.

god shammgod wrote:look, some people appreciated melo and some people didn't. just like some people thought phil was doing a bad job and some people were wrong. there's always 2 sides.

TankCommander17 wrote:

god shammgod wrote:look, some people appreciated melo and some people didn't. just like some people thought phil was doing a bad job and some people were wrong. there's always 2 sides.

Both sides are wrong. And I hate you all. Am i doing it right?

newyorker4ever wrote:

Greenie wrote:

newyorker4ever wrote:

Yeah i think there's different types of fans, don't you?

Not really.

There definitely is. You'd rather Melo use his NTC to the full extent and make the Knicks trade him to Houston where our return wouldn't be all that great when i and others would like him to add teams to that one team list so the Knicks can actually get some assets to help our rebuild for the guy that we gave up so much for. I see that as different fandom is all. It's not a knock on you cause you're obviously a Knicks fan but not as extreme as others is all.

Greenie wrote:

newyorker4ever wrote:

Greenie wrote:Not really.

There definitely is. You'd rather Melo use his NTC to the full extent and make the Knicks trade him to Houston where our return wouldn't be all that great when i and others would like him to add teams to that one team list so the Knicks can actually get some assets to help our rebuild for the guy that we gave up so much for. I see that as different fandom is all. It's not a knock on you cause you're obviously a Knicks fan but not as extreme as others is all.

No I don't. I simply see the other side and I'm not upset at it.

I would love to be able to trade Melo anywhere that gives us young players, picks and cap relief. I just live in reality. He has a NTC. He's not evil for using it as some are trying to paint him. He wants to go to a specific place and has a NTC to make sure it's either there or here he will play.

That's where I stand. I personally want to trade him to Miami for Bam. He doesn't give a fuq though.

newyorker4ever wrote:

Greenie wrote:

newyorker4ever wrote:

There definitely is. You'd rather Melo use his NTC to the full extent and make the Knicks trade him to Houston where our return wouldn't be all that great when i and others would like him to add teams to that one team list so the Knicks can actually get some assets to help our rebuild for the guy that we gave up so much for. I see that as different fandom is all. It's not a knock on you cause you're obviously a Knicks fan but not as extreme as others is all.

No I don't. I simply see the other side and I'm not upset at it.

I would love to be able to trade Melo anywhere that gives us young players, picks and cap relief. I just live in reality. He has a NTC. He's not evil for using it as some are trying to paint him. He wants to go to a specific place and has a NTC to make sure it's either there or here he will play.

That's where I stand. I personally want to trade him to Miami for Bam. He doesn't give a fuq though.

I think we just agree to disagree on some parts but agree on others but you keep saying you live in reality about him having a NTC but that's the reality we all are living and have been talking about non stop, but there's plenty of teams out there that he could go win with other than Houston who's one of the few that want him that we won't get much of anything from is all.

god shammgod wrote:look, some people appreciated melo and some people didn't. just like some people thought phil was doing a bad job and some people were wrong. there's always 2 sides.

Greenie wrote:

newyorker4ever wrote:

Greenie wrote:
No I don't. I simply see the other side and I'm not upset at it.

I would love to be able to trade Melo anywhere that gives us young players, picks and cap relief. I just live in reality. He has a NTC. He's not evil for using it as some are trying to paint him. He wants to go to a specific place and has a NTC to make sure it's either there or here he will play.

That's where I stand. I personally want to trade him to Miami for Bam. He doesn't give a fuq though.

I think we just agree to disagree on some parts but agree on others but you keep saying you live in reality about him having a NTC but that's the reality we all are living and have been talking about non stop, but there's plenty of teams out there that he could go win with other than Houston who's one of the few that want him that we won't get much of anything from is all.

That's not how he feels. Maybe he really wants to play with Chris. I don't really know. We want him to want other teams. He doesn't. This should be a lesson. Don't give out anymore NTC's.

Greenie wrote:

battabing10 wrote:

Greenie wrote:
Never said he was transcendent.
I think that roster is simply imbalanced with LeBron out.

LeBron is the PG. A lot of good teams suck without their general on the floor if said general is the facilitator.

Who else on that team really playmakes for others? Kyrie does a little, but with Lebron out of the picture defense can key in.

It's why I would want Frank next to Kyrie. Frank's a defensive playmaker right?

Why try to build a team around a one-dimensional player? That's a non-starter. Name one team in the history of the NBA that won it all with such a player.

Dallas

god shammgod wrote:look, some people appreciated melo and some people didn't. just like some people thought phil was doing a bad job and some people were wrong. there's always 2 sides.

Greenie wrote:

blueNorange wrote:

dreamer3kx wrote:
I dont buy that at all, the ball is going to him down low still if he remains.

no, lol .. they're not going to stunt the growth of kristaps and willy because of melo.

the knicks are over melo.

Until you find out what you want doesn't matter and you see Melo with the ball in the low post on the first possession in a Knick uniform...