ImageImageImageImageImage

PG: KNICKS vs Pelicans: Cap'n Carried Us!!!

Moderators: j4remi, HerSports85, NoLayupRule, GONYK, Jeff Van Gully, dakomish23, Deeeez Knicks, mpharris36

User avatar
Fat Kat
RealGM
Posts: 35,160
And1: 36,256
Joined: Apr 19, 2004
     

Re: PG: KNICKS vs Pelicans: Cap'n Carried Us!!! 

Post#221 » by Fat Kat » Sun Dec 22, 2024 9:09 pm

GettinitDone wrote:I'm not very thrilled with the spacing when Josh is in SL

He occupies Mikal's attacking spots... strictly offensively Josh and Mikal do not necessarily complement each other although they're both very unselfish.

Josh has been great, but imo we're A LOT better as a team when Mikal, not Josh, is the playmaker other than JB.

We're lucky it's the 5 win Pelicans because in 3rd q they must have realized they wanted Flagg more than the W, but against title contenders we'd fight from down in a hole to get back into the game every time when not 1 of JB or KAT is on fire, it's not sustainable.

Bring Josh off the bench, he can boost our bench production and he'll play starter 30+ mins anyway and end up playing with starters too.

Start Precious at 4, we get more size, we get more paint protection, and don't necessarily lose rebounding and scoring with Josh to the bench.

I've been saying although KAT has been a beast as a L leading rebounder, imo he doesn't necessarily love being the lone presence in the paint, and esp doesn't love being the last line of defense. He loves some help in rebounding to ease his load... and esp loves another big to help him defensively in the paint.

Currently the spacing and passing with Josh as a starter are imo inorganic, clunky, and not very spontaneous. Do this move (bench Josh and start Precious), the spacing and ball movement will be organic, synergistic and SPONATENOUS. We need it !!!

I think we're better off as a team with an aggressive Mikal doing 25pts, 8 assists every game he'll be a demon defensively when he gets going offensively... we need to set the tone at the start of the game.

Also, out of everyone on roster Josh is probably the guy who'd complain the least with a bench "demotion"... I bet he'd still get 10+rpg, I remember he got 19 rebounds off the bench against us when he was still with Portland. In fact, at beginning of this season as we were losing he even publicly suggested to bench himself.

Of course, our "brilliant bball mind" coach would not see this.... or would SEE it and still not do anything about it :dontknow:


We lose spacing, ball-handling, rebounding and fast break opportunities replacing Josh with Precious. Precious has not inspired any confidence so far. Thankfully this change has 0% chance of happening.
All comments made by Fat Kat are given as opinion, which may or may not be derived from facts, and not made to personally attack anyone on Realgm. All rights reserved.®
Galvationknicks
General Manager
Posts: 7,610
And1: 6,493
Joined: Jul 25, 2008

Re: PG: KNICKS vs Pelicans: Cap'n Carried Us!!! 

Post#222 » by Galvationknicks » Sun Dec 22, 2024 9:13 pm

Total points scored in the year since Becky Hammon said Jalen Brunson is not a '1A Dude':

1. Jalen Brunson: 2,232
2. Giannis Antetokounmpo: 2,174
3. Anthony Edwards: 2,146
4. Luka Doncic: 2,098
5. Jayson Tatum: 2,040
6. Nikola Jokic: 1,995


Where has she been?
JB is Him :nod:
JayTWill
Veteran
Posts: 2,722
And1: 1,786
Joined: May 14, 2011

Re: PG: KNICKS vs Pelicans: Cap'n Carried Us!!! 

Post#223 » by JayTWill » Sun Dec 22, 2024 9:17 pm

Context wrote:this is food for thought for some of the Knick family members that think our Orlando win didnt count because they didnt have their top guys:
Read on Twitter


If the Knicks lost without KAT and Brunson you would not downplay the loss saying that we were missing our top guys?
User avatar
Fat Kat
RealGM
Posts: 35,160
And1: 36,256
Joined: Apr 19, 2004
     

Re: PG: KNICKS vs Pelicans: Cap'n Carried Us!!! 

Post#224 » by Fat Kat » Sun Dec 22, 2024 9:36 pm

Galvationknicks wrote:Total points scored in the year since Becky Hammon said Jalen Brunson is not a '1A Dude':

1. Jalen Brunson: 2,232
2. Giannis Antetokounmpo: 2,174
3. Anthony Edwards: 2,146
4. Luka Doncic: 2,098
5. Jayson Tatum: 2,040
6. Nikola Jokic: 1,995


Where has she been?


She been busy dealing with her discrimination lawsuit.
All comments made by Fat Kat are given as opinion, which may or may not be derived from facts, and not made to personally attack anyone on Realgm. All rights reserved.®
User avatar
Guano
RealGM
Posts: 39,498
And1: 66,803
Joined: Dec 16, 2010
Location: any port

Re: PG: KNICKS vs Pelicans: Cap'n Carried Us!!! 

Post#225 » by Guano » Sun Dec 22, 2024 9:50 pm

Fat Kat wrote:
GettinitDone wrote:I'm not very thrilled with the spacing when Josh is in SL

He occupies Mikal's attacking spots... strictly offensively Josh and Mikal do not necessarily complement each other although they're both very unselfish.

Josh has been great, but imo we're A LOT better as a team when Mikal, not Josh, is the playmaker other than JB.

We're lucky it's the 5 win Pelicans because in 3rd q they must have realized they wanted Flagg more than the W, but against title contenders we'd fight from down in a hole to get back into the game every time when not 1 of JB or KAT is on fire, it's not sustainable.

Bring Josh off the bench, he can boost our bench production and he'll play starter 30+ mins anyway and end up playing with starters too.

Start Precious at 4, we get more size, we get more paint protection, and don't necessarily lose rebounding and scoring with Josh to the bench.

I've been saying although KAT has been a beast as a L leading rebounder, imo he doesn't necessarily love being the lone presence in the paint, and esp doesn't love being the last line of defense. He loves some help in rebounding to ease his load... and esp loves another big to help him defensively in the paint.

Currently the spacing and passing with Josh as a starter are imo inorganic, clunky, and not very spontaneous. Do this move (bench Josh and start Precious), the spacing and ball movement will be organic, synergistic and SPONATENOUS. We need it !!!

I think we're better off as a team with an aggressive Mikal doing 25pts, 8 assists every game he'll be a demon defensively when he gets going offensively... we need to set the tone at the start of the game.

Also, out of everyone on roster Josh is probably the guy who'd complain the least with a bench "demotion"... I bet he'd still get 10+rpg, I remember he got 19 rebounds off the bench against us when he was still with Portland. In fact, at beginning of this season as we were losing he even publicly suggested to bench himself.

Of course, our "brilliant bball mind" coach would not see this.... or would SEE it and still not do anything about it :dontknow:


We lose spacing, ball-handling, rebounding and fast break opportunities replacing Josh with Precious. Precious has not inspired any confidence so far. Thankfully this change has 0% chance of happening.


Same when thry talk about inserting mitch in the starting 5. Kills our offense for what a marginal improvement to our defense. It's not worth it.
Chanel Bomber wrote:This board really is full of bad people.
User avatar
RHODEY
RealGM
Posts: 25,302
And1: 22,813
Joined: May 18, 2007
Location: Straight out of a comic book

Re: PG: KNICKS vs Pelicans: Cap'n Carried Us!!! 

Post#226 » by RHODEY » Sun Dec 22, 2024 9:52 pm

GettinitDone wrote:I'm not very thrilled with the spacing when Josh is in SL

He occupies Mikal's attacking spots... strictly offensively Josh and Mikal do not necessarily complement each other although they're both very unselfish.

Josh has been great, but imo we're A LOT better as a team when Mikal, not Josh, is the playmaker other than JB.

We're lucky it's the 5 win Pelicans because in 3rd q they must have realized they wanted Flagg more than the W, but against title contenders we'd fight from down in a hole to get back into the game every time when not 1 of JB or KAT is on fire, it's not sustainable.

Bring Josh off the bench, he can boost our bench production and he'll play starter 30+ mins anyway and end up playing with starters too.

Start Precious at 4, we get more size, we get more paint protection, and don't necessarily lose rebounding and scoring with Josh to the bench.

I've been saying although KAT has been a beast as a L leading rebounder, imo he doesn't necessarily love being the lone presence in the paint, and esp doesn't love being the last line of defense. He loves some help in rebounding to ease his load... and esp loves another big to help him defensively in the paint.

Currently the spacing and passing with Josh as a starter are imo inorganic, clunky, and not very spontaneous. Do this move (bench Josh and start Precious), the spacing and ball movement will be organic, synergistic and SPONATENOUS. We need it !!!

I think we're better off as a team with an aggressive Mikal doing 25pts, 8 assists every game he'll be a demon defensively when he gets going offensively... we need to set the tone at the start of the game.

Also, out of everyone on roster Josh is probably the guy who'd complain the least with a bench "demotion"... I bet he'd still get 10+rpg, I remember he got 19 rebounds off the bench against us when he was still with Portland. In fact, at beginning of this season as we were losing he even publicly suggested to bench himself.

Of course, our "brilliant bball mind" coach would not see this.... or would SEE it and still not do anything about it :dontknow:

Although I agree, I think Thibs is gonna need a bigger sample size than just the Minny game to make a permanent switch. And honestly starting Precious might only be best situationally. I really like how it look versus Minny but many other teams dont play that sames tradition linueup. I guess we'll see but its great to know we have options.
KnixinSix
Head Coach
Posts: 7,188
And1: 3,871
Joined: Jul 27, 2013
Location: In the Spirit
       

Re: PG: KNICKS vs Pelicans: Cap'n Carried Us!!! 

Post#227 » by KnixinSix » Sun Dec 22, 2024 10:22 pm

Guano wrote:
Fat Kat wrote:
GettinitDone wrote:I'm not very thrilled with the spacing when Josh is in SL

He occupies Mikal's attacking spots... strictly offensively Josh and Mikal do not necessarily complement each other although they're both very unselfish.

Josh has been great, but imo we're A LOT better as a team when Mikal, not Josh, is the playmaker other than JB.

We're lucky it's the 5 win Pelicans because in 3rd q they must have realized they wanted Flagg more than the W, but against title contenders we'd fight from down in a hole to get back into the game every time when not 1 of JB or KAT is on fire, it's not sustainable.

Bring Josh off the bench, he can boost our bench production and he'll play starter 30+ mins anyway and end up playing with starters too.

Start Precious at 4, we get more size, we get more paint protection, and don't necessarily lose rebounding and scoring with Josh to the bench.

I've been saying although KAT has been a beast as a L leading rebounder, imo he doesn't necessarily love being the lone presence in the paint, and esp doesn't love being the last line of defense. He loves some help in rebounding to ease his load... and esp loves another big to help him defensively in the paint.

Currently the spacing and passing with Josh as a starter are imo inorganic, clunky, and not very spontaneous. Do this move (bench Josh and start Precious), the spacing and ball movement will be organic, synergistic and SPONATENOUS. We need it !!!

I think we're better off as a team with an aggressive Mikal doing 25pts, 8 assists every game he'll be a demon defensively when he gets going offensively... we need to set the tone at the start of the game.

Also, out of everyone on roster Josh is probably the guy who'd complain the least with a bench "demotion"... I bet he'd still get 10+rpg, I remember he got 19 rebounds off the bench against us when he was still with Portland. In fact, at beginning of this season as we were losing he even publicly suggested to bench himself.

Of course, our "brilliant bball mind" coach would not see this.... or would SEE it and still not do anything about it :dontknow:


We lose spacing, ball-handling, rebounding and fast break opportunities replacing Josh with Precious. Precious has not inspired any confidence so far. Thankfully this change has 0% chance of happening.


Same when thry talk about inserting mitch in the starting 5. Kills our offense for what a marginal improvement to our defense. It's not worth it.


You are downplaying the effect a guy who was getting mentions for DPOY last year and a perfect fit for Thibs defensive system would have on the defense.

Secondly he would only be playing the 5 part of the time not most of the time and more or less depending on ebb and flow of game and for strategic matchup advantage.
New reality of Son ship!
All who receive and believe in Jesus, given the right to become children of God. Not born of flesh, but born of Spirit. The Word became flesh and dwelt among us. Glory that came from the Father, full of grace and truth.
-John 1
KnixinSix
Head Coach
Posts: 7,188
And1: 3,871
Joined: Jul 27, 2013
Location: In the Spirit
       

Re: PG: KNICKS vs Pelicans: Cap'n Carried Us!!! 

Post#228 » by KnixinSix » Sun Dec 22, 2024 10:26 pm

GettinitDone wrote:I'm not very thrilled with the spacing when Josh is in SL

He occupies Mikal's attacking spots... strictly offensively Josh and Mikal do not necessarily complement each other although they're both very unselfish.

Josh has been great, but imo we're A LOT better as a team when Mikal, not Josh, is the playmaker other than JB.

We're lucky it's the 5 win Pelicans because in 3rd q they must have realized they wanted Flagg more than the W, but against title contenders we'd fight from down in a hole to get back into the game every time when not 1 of JB or KAT is on fire, it's not sustainable.

Bring Josh off the bench, he can boost our bench production and he'll play starter 30+ mins anyway and end up playing with starters too.

Start Precious at 4, we get more size, we get more paint protection, and don't necessarily lose rebounding and scoring with Josh to the bench.

I've been saying although KAT has been a beast as a L leading rebounder, imo he doesn't necessarily love being the lone presence in the paint, and esp doesn't love being the last line of defense. He loves some help in rebounding to ease his load... and esp loves another big to help him defensively in the paint.

Currently the spacing and passing with Josh as a starter are imo inorganic, clunky, and not very spontaneous. Do this move (bench Josh and start Precious), the spacing and ball movement will be organic, synergistic and SPONATENOUS. We need it !!!

I think we're better off as a team with an aggressive Mikal doing 25pts, 8 assists every game he'll be a demon defensively when he gets going offensively... we need to set the tone at the start of the game.

Also, out of everyone on roster Josh is probably the guy who'd complain the least with a bench "demotion"... I bet he'd still get 10+rpg, I remember he got 19 rebounds off the bench against us when he was still with Portland. In fact, at beginning of this season as we were losing he even publicly suggested to bench himself.

Of course, our "brilliant bball mind" coach would not see this.... or would SEE it and still not do anything about it :dontknow:


Im leaning towards this too. While I dont hate Hart in the starting lineup I kind him like him off the bench more.
New reality of Son ship!
All who receive and believe in Jesus, given the right to become children of God. Not born of flesh, but born of Spirit. The Word became flesh and dwelt among us. Glory that came from the Father, full of grace and truth.
-John 1
User avatar
Guano
RealGM
Posts: 39,498
And1: 66,803
Joined: Dec 16, 2010
Location: any port

Re: PG: KNICKS vs Pelicans: Cap'n Carried Us!!! 

Post#229 » by Guano » Sun Dec 22, 2024 10:35 pm

KnixinSix wrote:
Guano wrote:
Fat Kat wrote:
We lose spacing, ball-handling, rebounding and fast break opportunities replacing Josh with Precious. Precious has not inspired any confidence so far. Thankfully this change has 0% chance of happening.


Same when thry talk about inserting mitch in the starting 5. Kills our offense for what a marginal improvement to our defense. It's not worth it.


You are downplaying the effect a guy who was getting mentions for DPOY last year and a perfect fit for Thibs defensive system would have on the defense.

Secondly he would only be playing the 5 part of the time not most of the time and more or less depending on ebb and flow of game and for strategic matchup advantage.


lol.
He played 31 games last year - no one outside of sham and mitchs family was mentioning him as dpoy. What is true is his blocks per game went down last year. Along with his foot speed. Cause he is breaking down.

Sure he could be useful if he miraculously is healthy depending on the match ups in the playoffs. And he is a massive upgrade over Sims. But it's more important that our wings stay healthy than upgrading the back up big.
Chanel Bomber wrote:This board really is full of bad people.
User avatar
Besart19
RealGM
Posts: 13,788
And1: 5,056
Joined: Feb 12, 2012
Location: Dibra, Albania
   

Re: PG: KNICKS vs Pelicans: Cap'n Carried Us!!! 

Post#230 » by Besart19 » Sun Dec 22, 2024 10:51 pm

Fat Kat wrote:
GettinitDone wrote:I'm not very thrilled with the spacing when Josh is in SL

He occupies Mikal's attacking spots... strictly offensively Josh and Mikal do not necessarily complement each other although they're both very unselfish.

Josh has been great, but imo we're A LOT better as a team when Mikal, not Josh, is the playmaker other than JB.

We're lucky it's the 5 win Pelicans because in 3rd q they must have realized they wanted Flagg more than the W, but against title contenders we'd fight from down in a hole to get back into the game every time when not 1 of JB or KAT is on fire, it's not sustainable.

Bring Josh off the bench, he can boost our bench production and he'll play starter 30+ mins anyway and end up playing with starters too.

Start Precious at 4, we get more size, we get more paint protection, and don't necessarily lose rebounding and scoring with Josh to the bench.

I've been saying although KAT has been a beast as a L leading rebounder, imo he doesn't necessarily love being the lone presence in the paint, and esp doesn't love being the last line of defense. He loves some help in rebounding to ease his load... and esp loves another big to help him defensively in the paint.

Currently the spacing and passing with Josh as a starter are imo inorganic, clunky, and not very spontaneous. Do this move (bench Josh and start Precious), the spacing and ball movement will be organic, synergistic and SPONATENOUS. We need it !!!

I think we're better off as a team with an aggressive Mikal doing 25pts, 8 assists every game he'll be a demon defensively when he gets going offensively... we need to set the tone at the start of the game.

Also, out of everyone on roster Josh is probably the guy who'd complain the least with a bench "demotion"... I bet he'd still get 10+rpg, I remember he got 19 rebounds off the bench against us when he was still with Portland. In fact, at beginning of this season as we were losing he even publicly suggested to bench himself.

Of course, our "brilliant bball mind" coach would not see this.... or would SEE it and still not do anything about it :dontknow:


We lose spacing, ball-handling, rebounding and fast break opportunities replacing Josh with Precious. Precious has not inspired any confidence so far. Thankfully this change has 0% chance of happening.


McBride should start

Brunson / Payne
McBride / Shamet
Bridges / Hart
Anunoby / Warren
Towns / Achiuwa / Sims
Strength and Honour!
CDAZ
Head Coach
Posts: 7,285
And1: 2,699
Joined: Dec 13, 2004
Location: Harlem NYC

Re: PG: KNICKS vs Pelicans: Cap'n Carried Us!!! 

Post#231 » by CDAZ » Sun Dec 22, 2024 10:56 pm

thebuzzardman wrote:Knicks look to be escaping the mid orbit


Too soon
CDAZ
Head Coach
Posts: 7,285
And1: 2,699
Joined: Dec 13, 2004
Location: Harlem NYC

Re: PG: KNICKS vs Pelicans: Cap'n Carried Us!!! 

Post#232 » by CDAZ » Sun Dec 22, 2024 10:59 pm

NoDopeOnSundays wrote:
Guano wrote:
NoDopeOnSundays wrote:For December we're 4th in DRTG, we're 4th in Net rating for December as well and have jumped up to 13 DRTG for the season. Surprise surprise, the people who spent hundreds of posts saying we'd be a bottom 5 defensive team are nowhere to be found. KAT is down to 59% DFG in rim protection for the month, he's now down to 66% on the season as well and of course people have stopped harping on that aspect of his game :roll:


They stopped harping on it cause they stopped posting.

meLo get your @ss back in here. We got rim protection!




Team Villain went out sadder than sad, I always said true villains don't need to tell you they're villainous. The rim protection stuff was always going to shake out like this, KAT was bad at the start of the season while getting reacclimated to playing C, but there was nowhere to go but up from where he was at. The last 10 games he's at 59.4% DFG, and -3.6 diff, which means he's holding guys below their expected FG%. I don't know why you'd make that the backbone of your slander campaign of a player, especially when the numbers were so bad they could only improve.


And just for reference, IHart is at 60.6% DFG for the season.


What are our offensive rebounds looking like? I've been away on vacation and miss the last few games.
User avatar
thebuzzardman
RealGM
Posts: 82,194
And1: 96,135
Joined: Jun 24, 2006
Location: Villanovknicks

Re: PG: KNICKS vs Pelicans: Cap'n Carried Us!!! 

Post#233 » by thebuzzardman » Sun Dec 22, 2024 11:23 pm

Galvationknicks wrote:Total points scored in the year since Becky Hammon said Jalen Brunson is not a '1A Dude':

1. Jalen Brunson: 2,232
2. Giannis Antetokounmpo: 2,174
3. Anthony Edwards: 2,146
4. Luka Doncic: 2,098
5. Jayson Tatum: 2,040
6. Nikola Jokic: 1,995


Where has she been?


Image
Image
User avatar
GettinitDone
General Manager
Posts: 7,559
And1: 4,666
Joined: Feb 09, 2012

Re: PG: KNICKS vs Pelicans: Cap'n Carried Us!!! 

Post#234 » by GettinitDone » Mon Dec 23, 2024 12:24 am

Fat Kat wrote:
GettinitDone wrote:I'm not very thrilled with the spacing when Josh is in SL

He occupies Mikal's attacking spots... strictly offensively Josh and Mikal do not necessarily complement each other although they're both very unselfish.

Josh has been great, but imo we're A LOT better as a team when Mikal, not Josh, is the playmaker other than JB.

We're lucky it's the 5 win Pelicans because in 3rd q they must have realized they wanted Flagg more than the W, but against title contenders we'd fight from down in a hole to get back into the game every time when not 1 of JB or KAT is on fire, it's not sustainable.

Bring Josh off the bench, he can boost our bench production and he'll play starter 30+ mins anyway and end up playing with starters too.

Start Precious at 4, we get more size, we get more paint protection, and don't necessarily lose rebounding and scoring with Josh to the bench.

I've been saying although KAT has been a beast as a L leading rebounder, imo he doesn't necessarily love being the lone presence in the paint, and esp doesn't love being the last line of defense. He loves some help in rebounding to ease his load... and esp loves another big to help him defensively in the paint.

Currently the spacing and passing with Josh as a starter are imo inorganic, clunky, and not very spontaneous. Do this move (bench Josh and start Precious), the spacing and ball movement will be organic, synergistic and SPONATENOUS. We need it !!!

I think we're better off as a team with an aggressive Mikal doing 25pts, 8 assists every game he'll be a demon defensively when he gets going offensively... we need to set the tone at the start of the game.

Also, out of everyone on roster Josh is probably the guy who'd complain the least with a bench "demotion"... I bet he'd still get 10+rpg, I remember he got 19 rebounds off the bench against us when he was still with Portland. In fact, at beginning of this season as we were losing he even publicly suggested to bench himself.

Of course, our "brilliant bball mind" coach would not see this.... or would SEE it and still not do anything about it :dontknow:


We lose spacing, ball-handling, rebounding and fast break opportunities replacing Josh with Precious. Precious has not inspired any confidence so far. Thankfully this change has 0% chance of happening.


Doesn't make sense... Josh has been knocking down shots, but Precious has been knocking down outside shots too... let's be real Josh isn't a league beater at spacing, let's not act like we'd lose a sniper like Divo 3rd in 3pt makes last year.

Precious can rebound, plus add size and interior defense.

And we don't need Precious to ball handle, we only need a few at a time like JB and Mikal, who's freed to operate when he doesn't play with Josh. When we have too many like JB, Josh, and Mikal to want to be playmakers at the same time, it's when too much of a good thing becomes bad. We only Precious to facilitate, move the ball, not trying to break defenses down with dribbling or playmaking.

Josh has been racking up triple doubles he can absolutely be a playmaker, but Mikal can do it as well as Josh too, plus scoring that Josh can't.

We don't "demote" Josh, we put an absolute weapon as an ammo reserve on the bench and unleash him on opposing team when our starters get rest... again he'll likely play starter minutes anyway, so we're not really losing Josh's strengths by benching him.

Like the Minny game showed us, our offense clicks on all cylinders when JB, Mikal make plays early, the team ball movement is just smoother, free flowing, "no hiccups", both the ball and players movement are VERY SPONTANEOUS. That's what we wanna get to as a ball club.
User avatar
Fat Kat
RealGM
Posts: 35,160
And1: 36,256
Joined: Apr 19, 2004
     

Re: PG: KNICKS vs Pelicans: Cap'n Carried Us!!! 

Post#235 » by Fat Kat » Mon Dec 23, 2024 12:58 am

GettinitDone wrote:
Fat Kat wrote:
GettinitDone wrote:I'm not very thrilled with the spacing when Josh is in SL

He occupies Mikal's attacking spots... strictly offensively Josh and Mikal do not necessarily complement each other although they're both very unselfish.

Josh has been great, but imo we're A LOT better as a team when Mikal, not Josh, is the playmaker other than JB.

We're lucky it's the 5 win Pelicans because in 3rd q they must have realized they wanted Flagg more than the W, but against title contenders we'd fight from down in a hole to get back into the game every time when not 1 of JB or KAT is on fire, it's not sustainable.

Bring Josh off the bench, he can boost our bench production and he'll play starter 30+ mins anyway and end up playing with starters too.

Start Precious at 4, we get more size, we get more paint protection, and don't necessarily lose rebounding and scoring with Josh to the bench.

I've been saying although KAT has been a beast as a L leading rebounder, imo he doesn't necessarily love being the lone presence in the paint, and esp doesn't love being the last line of defense. He loves some help in rebounding to ease his load... and esp loves another big to help him defensively in the paint.

Currently the spacing and passing with Josh as a starter are imo inorganic, clunky, and not very spontaneous. Do this move (bench Josh and start Precious), the spacing and ball movement will be organic, synergistic and SPONATENOUS. We need it !!!

I think we're better off as a team with an aggressive Mikal doing 25pts, 8 assists every game he'll be a demon defensively when he gets going offensively... we need to set the tone at the start of the game.

Also, out of everyone on roster Josh is probably the guy who'd complain the least with a bench "demotion"... I bet he'd still get 10+rpg, I remember he got 19 rebounds off the bench against us when he was still with Portland. In fact, at beginning of this season as we were losing he even publicly suggested to bench himself.

Of course, our "brilliant bball mind" coach would not see this.... or would SEE it and still not do anything about it :dontknow:


We lose spacing, ball-handling, rebounding and fast break opportunities replacing Josh with Precious. Precious has not inspired any confidence so far. Thankfully this change has 0% chance of happening.


Doesn't make sense... Josh has been knocking down shots, but Precious has been knocking down outside shots too... let's be real Josh isn't a league beater at spacing, let's not act like we'd lose a sniper like Divo 3rd in 3pt makes last year.

Precious can rebound, plus add size and interior defense.

And we don't need Precious to ball handle, we only need a few at a time like JB and Mikal, who's freed to operate when he doesn't play with Josh. When we have too many like JB, Josh, and Mikal to want to be playmakers at the same time, it's when too much of a good thing becomes bad. We only Precious to facilitate, move the ball, not trying to break defenses down with dribbling or playmaking.

Josh has been racking up triple doubles he can absolutely be a playmaker, but Mikal can do it as well as Josh too, plus scoring that Josh can't.

We don't "demote" Josh, we put an absolute weapon as an ammo reserve on the bench and unleash him on opposing team when our starters get rest... again he'll likely play starter minutes anyway, so we're not really losing Josh's strengths by benching him.

Like the Minny game showed us, our offense clicks on all cylinders when JB, Mikal make plays early, the team ball movement is just smoother, free flowing, "no hiccups", both the ball and players movement are VERY SPONTANEOUS. That's what we wanna get to as a ball club.


Precious was the only rotation player with a negative plus minus in a game that we won by almost 30 points. He wasn’t good. You’re picturing a reality that just isn’t real. It’s like you’re trying to make changes for the sake of making a change.
All comments made by Fat Kat are given as opinion, which may or may not be derived from facts, and not made to personally attack anyone on Realgm. All rights reserved.®
User avatar
JBreezeNY
RealGM
Posts: 20,968
And1: 11,533
Joined: Nov 25, 2010
Location: Welp...we suck.
       

Re: PG: KNICKS vs Pelicans: Cap'n Carried Us!!! 

Post#236 » by JBreezeNY » Mon Dec 23, 2024 1:03 am

Bench Hart, Start McBride, Bench Precious and trade him along with Sims/or Mitch for a big Wing.
User avatar
GettinitDone
General Manager
Posts: 7,559
And1: 4,666
Joined: Feb 09, 2012

Re: PG: KNICKS vs Pelicans: Cap'n Carried Us!!! 

Post#237 » by GettinitDone » Mon Dec 23, 2024 1:08 am

Fat Kat wrote:
GettinitDone wrote:
Fat Kat wrote:
We lose spacing, ball-handling, rebounding and fast break opportunities replacing Josh with Precious. Precious has not inspired any confidence so far. Thankfully this change has 0% chance of happening.


Doesn't make sense... Josh has been knocking down shots, but Precious has been knocking down outside shots too... let's be real Josh isn't a league beater at spacing, let's not act like we'd lose a sniper like Divo 3rd in 3pt makes last year.

Precious can rebound, plus add size and interior defense.

And we don't need Precious to ball handle, we only need a few at a time like JB and Mikal, who's freed to operate when he doesn't play with Josh. When we have too many like JB, Josh, and Mikal to want to be playmakers at the same time, it's when too much of a good thing becomes bad. We only Precious to facilitate, move the ball, not trying to break defenses down with dribbling or playmaking.

Josh has been racking up triple doubles he can absolutely be a playmaker, but Mikal can do it as well as Josh too, plus scoring that Josh can't.

We don't "demote" Josh, we put an absolute weapon as an ammo reserve on the bench and unleash him on opposing team when our starters get rest... again he'll likely play starter minutes anyway, so we're not really losing Josh's strengths by benching him.

Like the Minny game showed us, our offense clicks on all cylinders when JB, Mikal make plays early, the team ball movement is just smoother, free flowing, "no hiccups", both the ball and players movement are VERY SPONTANEOUS. That's what we wanna get to as a ball club.


Precious was the only rotation player with a negative plus minus in a game that we won by almost 30 points. He wasn’t good. You’re picturing a reality that just isn’t real. It’s like you’re trying to make changes for the sake of making a change.


We do this change to unlock Mikal

I don't get why people are down on Precious, like he's a Kwame Brown... he has very good hands, can catch passes, he can actually shoot, he can actually put the ball on the floor, he actually blocks shots (how about that clutch block on Embiid in last season's playoffs), he actually rebounds

The 2000s Lakers had stiffs playing at 4 next to Shaq like Samaki Walker, and a washed Horace Grant... I bet Samaki's +- were horrendous, but they got the job done... Precious is better than them


But again we do this move to bench Josh so we can free Mikal to operate, not so much about Precious. We're at our best with an aggressive Mikal !!

But Precious can be more than just be "6 fouls"... he's imo a REALLY REALLY GOOD role player, like Josh.
User avatar
BKlutch
RealGM
Posts: 18,401
And1: 16,573
Joined: Jan 11, 2015
Location: A magical land of rainbows and cotton candy trees where the Knicks D gonna F you up
   

Re: PG: KNICKS vs Pelicans: Cap'n Carried Us!!! 

Post#238 » by BKlutch » Mon Dec 23, 2024 1:14 am

Knick4Real wrote:
Deeeez Knicks wrote:
Guano wrote::lol:
Read on Twitter



That's the perfect picture too. Looks like he just spotted some Mike's hot n honey chicken fingers


This is a prime example of the slogan: "Be careful what you ask for, or you just might get it."

KNICKS fans everywhere wanted Zion badly. We truly dodged a bullet by not winning the draft that year.

Remember Tank for Zion!
.

____________________
____________________


:basketball: _______ M U C K A_________ :basketball:
*Make Us Champion Knicks Again*
:basketball: ** GO NY GO NY GO NY GO! ** :basketball:
____________________
____________________

.
.
User avatar
Context
RealGM
Posts: 32,703
And1: 22,040
Joined: Jul 06, 2005
Location: where the Gods dwell! shhhhhhh
 

Re: PG: KNICKS vs Pelicans: Cap'n Carried Us!!! 

Post#239 » by Context » Mon Dec 23, 2024 1:25 am

JayTWill wrote:
Context wrote:this is food for thought for some of the Knick family members that think our Orlando win didnt count because they didnt have their top guys:
Read on Twitter


If the Knicks lost without KAT and Brunson you would not downplay the loss saying that we were missing our top guys?

I think for us at this point- 28 games in with this new group (10 new players)we dont have our culture, chemistry and bench; fully
developed...we're getting there but at this point Brunson and Kat represent a large portion of our engine...

So in context- I dont think its a good comp Jay...
Image
Luka | Scotty |Dunn
Bane | Pritchard | Branham
Watson | Jmac | *
AD | Jaylin | Clarke
Chet | Edey | Neemias
JayTWill
Veteran
Posts: 2,722
And1: 1,786
Joined: May 14, 2011

Re: PG: KNICKS vs Pelicans: Cap'n Carried Us!!! 

Post#240 » by JayTWill » Mon Dec 23, 2024 1:56 am

Context wrote:
JayTWill wrote:
Context wrote:this is food for thought for some of the Knick family members that think our Orlando win didnt count because they didnt have their top guys:
Read on Twitter


If the Knicks lost without KAT and Brunson you would not downplay the loss saying that we were missing our top guys?

I think for us at this point- 28 games in with this new group (10 new players)we dont have our culture, chemistry and bench; fully
developed...we're getting there but at this point Brunson and Kat represent a large portion of our engine...

So in context- I dont think its a good comp Jay...


So if this group had a full year of experience together and a fan from an opposing fan base came to this board to brag about beating this team without KAT and Brunson with OG struggling to create his own offense you would be ok with that? I wouldn't. I would say we were missing important pieces and guys were forced into roles they shouldn't be in.

And if the fan responded "You guys have a culture, chemistry, depth and OG scored 40 against Denver" it still wouldn't change anything in my mind. Personally I rather see how both teams matchup at full strength to provide a better barometer of where both teams stand. The Knicks haven't peaked yet but it is easier for me to measure the progress the team is making when they are going up against the best versions of the best teams.

Return to New York Knicks