ImageImageImageImageImage

Around the NBA - 2024-25 Season Continued Continued

Moderators: Deeeez Knicks, mpharris36, j4remi, NoLayupRule, HerSports85, GONYK, Jeff Van Gully, dakomish23

User avatar
mpharris36
Forum Mod - Knicks
Forum Mod - Knicks
Posts: 111,954
And1: 115,506
Joined: Nov 03, 2010
     

Re: Around the NBA - 2024-25 Season Continued Continued 

Post#521 » by mpharris36 » Fri Apr 25, 2025 7:04 pm

3toheadmelo wrote:
mpharris36 wrote:
3toheadmelo wrote:Wasn’t the whole point of going all in our assets was to be on the same tier as Boston and OKC though? So we have to compare us to those teams. What was the point of going all in just to be arguably worse than last year’s team then?



Your not entirely wrong but its beyond tough to be on that tier. That doesn't mean because you aren't on that tier you cant win a series against them (based on health, performance ect if things fall right). I think having a floor of a 50 win team with upside certainly isn't a bad place to be in.

We will always have some gap towards the top 2 teams because our 2 best players aren't great defenders. That doesn't mean they aren't good. They are two of the better players in the NBA. Its just BOS and OKC really don't have much weak links in terms of defense that you can consistently seek out. With Brunson we have an elite offensive hub and closer...but he will always get picked on defensively. KAT has picked it up in the playoffs but we know he is a high level defender either. It will always be something we have to overcome playing those teams.

If you always waiting for the move that would have clearly put us on that tier you probably waste away Brunson prime and that shouldn't be the case either.

This roster isn't a 1st round exit...or 2nd round get the doors blown off team though...that is where I put that on the margins with Thibs.

It just feels like we are betting against ourselves if we are hoping we can win with multiple bad defenders and their offense isn’t good enough to make up for it (besides Brunson).

But we’re wasting Brunson’s prime right now by being locked in a core that isn’t going to win a chip. We just wasted our assets. It’s really to me about using all of our assets and it didn’t even make us really better. I personally would’ve just stuck with what we had from last year and traded for a rim protector like Kessler. Then save the rest of your assets for someone else when they become available. Hell we actually even had the opportunity to get Donovan Mitchell a couple years ago, who would’ve been a major help for us. It’s puzzling to me that after all these years of us “waiting on that big fish” we used all of our assets on two players that didn’t do anything to make us a championship contender.

Personally for me, I think hiring a new coach is just trying to put a band aid on something that needs surgery. The roster needs to be fixed no matter who the coach is. We are probably gonna fire Thibs after we lose to Boston so I hope we make that leap that you guys think we will under a new coach.


its tough for me to reconcile you saying wasting away brunson prime of his career but also saying he is the reason we will never be in the tier because we acknowledge he isn't a good defender. The best player on a team being 6'1 just typically doesn't win historically in the NBA. So we were always going to have a uphill battle no matter what for the top of top teams.

We built this team around brunson (for better or worse). Is it at "peak form" no...do i thnk we played as well as we should have this year "no". Lets see if last night sparks some things because the team played with the most fire and desire (shout out clyde) pretty much all season. Just attacking the glass, being physical ect...

I also think people in CLE thought there roster was capped out as well and didn't think a coaching change would matter and that was huge for them. Also just meshing and building chemistry matters. I know we all think in that "video game" mindset where you make a trade(s) they all of a sudden everything clicks. Especially when you are going against fine tune teams like BOS and OKC who have been together for years.

Even Miami when they brought the big 3 in had ups and down there first year...because playing together and developing chemistry takes time. Now we are talking different levels to this because certainly our teams is not Lebron/Wade/Bosh ect...but the point remains. Chemistry takes time with players. And the coach thing is what it is...I will hold judgement until our final results in the playoffs before I make the call completely on Thibs for next year but I do think he is holding us back in some ways which you are overlooking the impact.
4-Peat! 22-25 BAF Champion Spurs:

ROSTER

Walker Kessler/Daniel Gafford/Adem Bona
Nikola Jokic/Santi Aldama/Isaiah Stewart
Aaron Nesmith/Josh Hart/Jaime Jaquez
Alex Caruso/Keon Ellis/Justin Champagnie
Steph Curry/Chris Paul/Jase Richardson
User avatar
god shammgod
RealGM
Posts: 137,693
And1: 135,813
Joined: Feb 18, 2006

Re: Around the NBA - 2024-25 Season Continued Continued 

Post#522 » by god shammgod » Fri Apr 25, 2025 7:07 pm

it is very difficult to win with a short player as your best player. that's true. that's why we should have waited one more year until giannis was available. but instead we did this.
User avatar
mpharris36
Forum Mod - Knicks
Forum Mod - Knicks
Posts: 111,954
And1: 115,506
Joined: Nov 03, 2010
     

Re: Around the NBA - 2024-25 Season Continued Continued 

Post#523 » by mpharris36 » Fri Apr 25, 2025 7:07 pm

god shammgod wrote:if the coaching change isn't going to make us a contender then obviously the roster needs to the change which is what we've been saying all along. i don't think me or melo really care at all if thibs is fired. we just know, and you seem to now be admitting, that it isn't the biggest thing holding us back.



I'm not saying the roster is perfect...if we are keeping it a buck when has a team won with there best player being a 6'1 guard that is a negative on defense? Just putting that in perspect on the team we would have to build around to win it all to begin with.

And this is no shade at brunson...I appreciate and love him for what he has done for this franchise...but you also have to be realistic about it regardless of whatever build we put around him...
4-Peat! 22-25 BAF Champion Spurs:

ROSTER

Walker Kessler/Daniel Gafford/Adem Bona
Nikola Jokic/Santi Aldama/Isaiah Stewart
Aaron Nesmith/Josh Hart/Jaime Jaquez
Alex Caruso/Keon Ellis/Justin Champagnie
Steph Curry/Chris Paul/Jase Richardson
User avatar
NoDopeOnSundays
RealGM
Posts: 26,786
And1: 55,502
Joined: Nov 22, 2005
         

Re: Around the NBA - 2024-25 Season Continued Continued 

Post#524 » by NoDopeOnSundays » Fri Apr 25, 2025 7:12 pm

god shammgod wrote:it is very difficult to win with a short player as your best player. that's true. that's why we should have waited one more year until giannis was available. but instead we did this.




They waited on KD and Kyrie, that didn't work. Waiting around for stars to ask for trades is a wild card, he's signed for 3 more years, they don't even have to trade him even if he asks.
User avatar
Chanel Bomber
RealGM
Posts: 23,902
And1: 42,012
Joined: Sep 20, 2018
 

Re: Around the NBA - 2024-25 Season Continued Continued 

Post#525 » by Chanel Bomber » Fri Apr 25, 2025 7:12 pm

god shammgod wrote:it is very difficult to win with a short player as your best player. that's true. that's why we should have waited one more year until giannis was available. but instead we did this.

KAT is our best player
User avatar
Fury
RealGM
Posts: 24,620
And1: 18,487
Joined: Mar 07, 2007
       

Re: Around the NBA - 2024-25 Season Continued Continued 

Post#526 » by Fury » Fri Apr 25, 2025 7:12 pm

god shammgod wrote:it is very difficult to win with a short player as your best player. that's true. that's why we should have waited one more year until giannis was available. but instead we did this.


Assuming we waited, how would we have matched salaries for Giannis with both Randle and Bojan on expiring contracts? Are the Bucks taking OG, Hart, filler, and a bunch of picks for him? I don't know. I think they'd want someone to build around. Then is Brunson, DDV, Giannis (would Randle even fit under the cap?) winning the title? That's a bench that would be worse than the one we have now. With less money to manuever.
User avatar
god shammgod
RealGM
Posts: 137,693
And1: 135,813
Joined: Feb 18, 2006

Re: Around the NBA - 2024-25 Season Continued Continued 

Post#527 » by god shammgod » Fri Apr 25, 2025 7:16 pm

Chanel Bomber wrote:
god shammgod wrote:it is very difficult to win with a short player as your best player. that's true. that's why we should have waited one more year until giannis was available. but instead we did this.

KAT is our best player


i don't agree but even if that was true, you're not winning anything with him as your best player either.
User avatar
NoDopeOnSundays
RealGM
Posts: 26,786
And1: 55,502
Joined: Nov 22, 2005
         

Re: Around the NBA - 2024-25 Season Continued Continued 

Post#528 » by NoDopeOnSundays » Fri Apr 25, 2025 7:17 pm

Fury wrote:
god shammgod wrote:it is very difficult to win with a short player as your best player. that's true. that's why we should have waited one more year until giannis was available. but instead we did this.


Assuming we waited, how would we have matched salaries for Giannis with both Randle and Bojan on expiring contracts? Are the Bucks taking OG, Hart, filler, and a bunch of picks for him? I don't know. I think they'd want someone to build around. Then is Brunson, DDV, Giannis (would Randle even fit under the cap?) winning the title? That's a bench that would be worse than the one we have now. With less money to manuever.



Also, the elephant in the room is that Giannis needs a stretch 5 next to him, and those don't grow on trees. He should be playing center a hell of lot more than he does, but he doesn't want to do it, just like he and Dame are scoring an obscene amount of points per possession on screens together, but he doesn't like playing out of the pick.

Either convince him to play C or find a C that can shoot threes so your paint isn't packed.
User avatar
god shammgod
RealGM
Posts: 137,693
And1: 135,813
Joined: Feb 18, 2006

Re: Around the NBA - 2024-25 Season Continued Continued 

Post#529 » by god shammgod » Fri Apr 25, 2025 7:23 pm

Fury wrote:
god shammgod wrote:it is very difficult to win with a short player as your best player. that's true. that's why we should have waited one more year until giannis was available. but instead we did this.


Assuming we waited, how would we have matched salaries for Giannis with both Randle and Bojan on expiring contracts? Are the Bucks taking OG, Hart, filler, and a bunch of picks for him? I don't know. I think they'd want someone to build around. Then is Brunson, DDV, Giannis (would Randle even fit under the cap?) winning the title? That's a bench that would be worse than the one we have now. With less money to manuever.


there's really nowhere for randle to go which is why people think he'll pick up his option this summer. but if you read the writing on the wall that he's opting out, you trade him for a sightly longer contract even if it's a worse player. there's always options.

and if for whatever reason we don't get giannis, you wait on someone else. if someone never comes, at least you still have your picks to pivot.

i don't buy this argument that people make. well it's better to go all in even if it's likely to fail then to wait for the chance to actually be able to contend knowing that it also might not happen. and did we even get better ? we were losing in the 2nd round before all this.
User avatar
god shammgod
RealGM
Posts: 137,693
And1: 135,813
Joined: Feb 18, 2006

Re: Around the NBA - 2024-25 Season Continued Continued 

Post#530 » by god shammgod » Fri Apr 25, 2025 7:25 pm

NoDopeOnSundays wrote:
god shammgod wrote:it is very difficult to win with a short player as your best player. that's true. that's why we should have waited one more year until giannis was available. but instead we did this.




They waited on KD and Kyrie, that didn't work. Waiting around for stars to ask for trades is a wild card, he's signed for 3 more years, they don't even have to trade him even if he asks.


he's asking. they have no cards left to play to keep him there. and they're hemorrhaging money. they might be secretly relieved.
User avatar
NoDopeOnSundays
RealGM
Posts: 26,786
And1: 55,502
Joined: Nov 22, 2005
         

Re: Around the NBA - 2024-25 Season Continued Continued 

Post#531 » by NoDopeOnSundays » Fri Apr 25, 2025 7:27 pm

god shammgod wrote:
NoDopeOnSundays wrote:
god shammgod wrote:it is very difficult to win with a short player as your best player. that's true. that's why we should have waited one more year until giannis was available. but instead we did this.




They waited on KD and Kyrie, that didn't work. Waiting around for stars to ask for trades is a wild card, he's signed for 3 more years, they don't even have to trade him even if he asks.


he's asking. they have no cards left to play to keep him there. and they're hemorrhaging money. they might be secretly relieved.




I would expect a team to come out of nowhere for him, since he has 3 years left there's more teams that will enter.


Ultimately, he's great, but he's going to take a lot of roster turnover to fit his game. If he were willing to play C, it would open up a lot more doors for team building, but if he's still insisting on being a PF and PF only, he's gonna be difficult to build around.
User avatar
god shammgod
RealGM
Posts: 137,693
And1: 135,813
Joined: Feb 18, 2006

Re: Around the NBA - 2024-25 Season Continued Continued 

Post#532 » by god shammgod » Fri Apr 25, 2025 7:28 pm

these are the arguments against ?

"it's not that easy to pull of a trade for giannis or build the perfect roster for him so let's settle for a team that really has no shot of winning it all"

c'mon fellas
User avatar
NoDopeOnSundays
RealGM
Posts: 26,786
And1: 55,502
Joined: Nov 22, 2005
         

Re: Around the NBA - 2024-25 Season Continued Continued 

Post#533 » by NoDopeOnSundays » Fri Apr 25, 2025 7:30 pm

god shammgod wrote:these are the arguments against ?

"it's not that easy to pull of a trade for giannis or build the perfect roster for him so let's settle for a team that really has no shot of winning it all"

c'mon fellas



This team needs some moves around the edges, Josh Hart being replaced by a big that can shoot, or a big wing that can guard would change things heavily. It's not an argument against him, it's an argument that you need a lot more assets than we had to fit his game. The Bucks have him and Lillard, and they're still ass.

The NBA right now is about depth, not simply just we got more stars than you. We're in year 1, we don't have the depth yet (or coaching).
User avatar
god shammgod
RealGM
Posts: 137,693
And1: 135,813
Joined: Feb 18, 2006

Re: Around the NBA - 2024-25 Season Continued Continued 

Post#534 » by god shammgod » Fri Apr 25, 2025 7:31 pm

NoDopeOnSundays wrote:
god shammgod wrote:
NoDopeOnSundays wrote:


They waited on KD and Kyrie, that didn't work. Waiting around for stars to ask for trades is a wild card, he's signed for 3 more years, they don't even have to trade him even if he asks.


he's asking. they have no cards left to play to keep him there. and they're hemorrhaging money. they might be secretly relieved.




I would expect a team to come out of nowhere for him, since he has 3 years left there's more teams that will enter.


Ultimately, he's great, but he's going to take a lot of roster turnover to fit his game. If he were willing to play C, it would open up a lot more doors for team building, but if he's still insisting on being a PF and PF only, he's gonna be difficult to build around.


i heard 1 week ago on the bill simmons podcast that it's kind of known giannis wants to be in the new york area but because we don't have the assets to trade for him anymore he may end up on the nets.

people will ask why would he do that ? well probably nike or someone is offering him an extra 100 mill if he comes to this area and he's partially using that to make a decision.
User avatar
god shammgod
RealGM
Posts: 137,693
And1: 135,813
Joined: Feb 18, 2006

Re: Around the NBA - 2024-25 Season Continued Continued 

Post#535 » by god shammgod » Fri Apr 25, 2025 7:35 pm

NoDopeOnSundays wrote:
god shammgod wrote:these are the arguments against ?

"it's not that easy to pull of a trade for giannis or build the perfect roster for him so let's settle for a team that really has no shot of winning it all"

c'mon fellas



This team needs some moves around the edges, Josh Hart being replaced by a big that can shoot, or a big wing that can guard would change things heavily. It's not an argument against him, it's an argument that you need a lot more assets than we had to fit his game. The Bucks have him and Lillard, and they're still ass.

The NBA right now is about depth, not simply just we got more stars than you. We're in year 1, we don't have the depth yet (or coaching).


we don't have depth now though and lillard is not close to his prime. and he missed some time. and with all that being said, we won 3 more games than them.
User avatar
Fury
RealGM
Posts: 24,620
And1: 18,487
Joined: Mar 07, 2007
       

Re: Around the NBA - 2024-25 Season Continued Continued 

Post#536 » by Fury » Fri Apr 25, 2025 7:40 pm

god shammgod wrote:these are the arguments against ?

"it's not that easy to pull of a trade for giannis or build the perfect roster for him so let's settle for a team that really has no shot of winning it all"

c'mon fellas


I’m not saying it would not be easy to pull off, I’m saying that it couldn’t have happened. Every superstar player that gets traded is for a mix of good players, usually young and a bunch of picks. And you’re asking them to take the bad contract we get for Randle, no young players and picks? I don’t see it.
User avatar
NoDopeOnSundays
RealGM
Posts: 26,786
And1: 55,502
Joined: Nov 22, 2005
         

Re: Around the NBA - 2024-25 Season Continued Continued 

Post#537 » by NoDopeOnSundays » Fri Apr 25, 2025 7:40 pm

god shammgod wrote:
NoDopeOnSundays wrote:
god shammgod wrote:these are the arguments against ?

"it's not that easy to pull of a trade for giannis or build the perfect roster for him so let's settle for a team that really has no shot of winning it all"

c'mon fellas



This team needs some moves around the edges, Josh Hart being replaced by a big that can shoot, or a big wing that can guard would change things heavily. It's not an argument against him, it's an argument that you need a lot more assets than we had to fit his game. The Bucks have him and Lillard, and they're still ass.

The NBA right now is about depth, not simply just we got more stars than you. We're in year 1, we don't have the depth yet (or coaching).


we don't have depth now though and lillard is not close to his prime. and he missed some time. and with all that being said, we won 3 more games than them.



We won 3 more games than them with Brunson missing a month, they haven't been a threat since they traded Jrue, they got caught up in thinking star power was the only way. The depth for us will come over the next year or two as we use our MLE, trades etc.

Giannis wasn't on the market when we made our moves, you can't just sit around hoping guys ask for trades. That's the place the Heat had been in, and even when a guy wanted to go there the GM was like "Nah, we got you on an extension, you go where we want" and sent Dame to hell :lol: I don't think where Giannis wants to go will factor in too much, he's signed till 2028, if the Spurs or someone like that traded for him he's staying there.
seren
RealGM
Posts: 24,680
And1: 4,883
Joined: Jul 21, 2002

Re: Around the NBA - 2024-25 Season Continued Continued 

Post#538 » by seren » Fri Apr 25, 2025 7:49 pm

It is impossible to build a championship team as any given season only one out of 30 teams wins. I think our current squad is as close as we ever got in the last couple of decades. It has a lot of holes but a lot of recent champions also had holes. Take Milwaukee and Denver for instance. They had holes on the roster but they won. I think the right kind of action is to continue building on what we have and move on to a new coach.
spree2kawhi
RealGM
Posts: 12,471
And1: 5,652
Joined: Mar 01, 2005

Re: Around the NBA - 2024-25 Season Continued Continued 

Post#539 » by spree2kawhi » Fri Apr 25, 2025 8:53 pm

Okay… is that really the argument? Working under the assumption that Giannis might or might not force his way out of Milwaukee soon (we’re talking a year ago when they had basically just added Damian Lillard)… and maybe even forcing his way ooooonly to the Knicks, of all teams, and the Bucks then gladly accepting our trade offer of … uhhh… Randle and Bogdanovic? And of course an unmatched collection of picks… Is that supposed to be professional planning?

IMO a president of basketball operations would be fired if that was his best answer.
User avatar
god shammgod
RealGM
Posts: 137,693
And1: 135,813
Joined: Feb 18, 2006

Re: Around the NBA - 2024-25 Season Continued Continued 

Post#540 » by god shammgod » Fri Apr 25, 2025 8:58 pm

spree2kawhi wrote:Okay… is that really the argument? Working under the assumption that Giannis might or might not force his way out of Milwaukee soon (we’re talking a year ago when they had basically just added Damian Lillard)… and maybe even forcing his way ooooonly to the Knicks, of all teams, and the Bucks then gladly accepting our trade offer of … uhhh… Randle and Bogdanovic? And of course an unmatched collection of picks… Is that supposed to be professional planning?

IMO a president of basketball operations would be fired if that was his best answer
.



but not for trading away all our picks for a team that isn't a contender and has no money under the apron to even add any more pieces ? that's fine :lol:

p.s. leon's plan all along was to trade for a superstar. but waiting 1 more year is somehow preposterous.

Return to New York Knicks