RealGM

It is an absolute travesty that Carmelo Anthony was not guarding Lebron James yesterday for most if not all of the game. A top five player in the league goes to his coach and demands that assignment. If a rickety 34-year old Pierce can do it then so can a 27-year old Anthony. Offense can come and go but defense is the backbone of winning on the playoffs. Does anyone want to claim that Melo needs to conserve his energy for the offensive end? Phoooey

It's a bad sign that Woodson-- apparently known as a defensive coach and lover of isolation ball-- shied away from this issue, placing an undersized and mentally-weak defender like Smith on Lebron James.

If Anthony isn't up in Lebron's grill Monday then Woodson hasn't earned a contract for next season.

he was

Anthony started the game on LeBron and quickly got called for a foul. Maybe Woodson didn't want Melo to get into foul trouble and took him off LeBron.

What Melo really needs to do, more than guard LeBron, is make shots. The Knicks aren't going anywhere will Melo shooting 0-7 to start games.

[GR] wrote:he was

Yeah...I'm pretty sure he was. The only times he was not was when he either a) was not in the game or b) was forced to switch with Shump.

[GR] wrote:he was

dk7th doesn't watch the games. he's been caught so many times making these kind of statements and still persists. it's an embarrassment.

WTF is this nonsense? He was guarding him except for switches and fast breaks.

Too dk7th isn't a man of his word

Probably to keep Melo from tiring out. Miami did the same thing against Melo during the regular season. Battier had him through the first three quarters, then LeBron switched onto Melo for the fourth.

LOL

Elephant in the room-- why isn't Dk7th banned yet for being a troll who's only purpose is to make stuff up in order to stir up Melo hate?

why didnt you stop posting after the deal was made?

Can we lock this, this is a waste of the internetz.

Smokey9782 wrote:Anthony started the game on LeBron and quickly got called for a foul. Maybe Woodson didn't want Melo to get into foul trouble and took him off LeBron.

What Melo really needs to do, more than guard LeBron, is make shots. The Knicks aren't going anywhere will Melo shooting 0-7 to start games.

offense can come and go but defensive effort is the only constant player has. he wasn't guarding lebron nearly enough and what little time he spent on lebron the effort was not there. that has to change, especially that shumpert isn't there.

We also went small with Amar'e at the 5 and Mel at the 4 at times because Chandler caught a couple of early fouls and he was clearly drained... I saw for a period there Melo was guarding Joel.

god shammgod wrote:

[GR] wrote:he was

dk7th doesn't watch the games. he's been caught so many times making these kind of statements and still persists. it's an embarrassment.

that's a lie sonny jim. i saw the whole game online with a video stream. it was mostly jr smith and occasionally he was helped by jeffries or others.

when the game got out of hand melo was not guarding lebron at all.

wake the **** up dude.

dk7th wrote:

god shammgod wrote:

[GR] wrote:he was

dk7th doesn't watch the games. he's been caught so many times making these kind of statements and still persists. it's an embarrassment.

that's a lie sonny jim. i saw the whole game online with a video stream. it was mostly jr smith and occasionally he was helped by jeffries or others.

when the game got out of hand melo was not guarding lebron at all.

wake the **** up dude.

here are the highlights. do you not see melo guarding lebron at all ?

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=he_lflPIctw[/youtube]

god shammgod wrote:here are the highlights. do you not see melo guarding lebron at all ?

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=he_lflPIctw[/youtube]

Man, watching those 'highlights' just pissed me off all over again.

dk7th wrote:

Smokey9782 wrote:Anthony started the game on LeBron and quickly got called for a foul. Maybe Woodson didn't want Melo to get into foul trouble and took him off LeBron.

What Melo really needs to do, more than guard LeBron, is make shots. The Knicks aren't going anywhere will Melo shooting 0-7 to start games.

offense can come and go but defensive effort is the only constant player has. he wasn't guarding lebron nearly enough and what little time he spent on lebron the effort was not there. that has to change, especially that shumpert isn't there.

Wrong

The only thing he wasn't doing yesterday was knocking down shots. Everyone was saying how he was playing well defensively and passing the ball. He had 10 boards in the limited time he played

it's not that melo plays bad defense, it's that he doesnt play any defense. Not sure if he'll ever change this. Pierce didnt start playing defense till around age 28 too, so u never know.