RealGM

Knicks are against Miami.
Game 7 of the ECF.
Game's tied at 82-82 with 4 minutes left in the quarter.

You're really going to keep Amar'e on the bench? A man capable of such scoring ability (especially with our excellent PGs) is going to sit on the bench in the final 4 minutes?

Doesn't work. Whether you believe Amar'e and Melo can gel or not doesn't matter. These two have to play together and work together to win (and they will cause I believe in this team and I know Amar'e does too).

Are we posting our fantasies here? I have one with Scarlett Johansson if yall willing to hear me out.

frogfood wrote:Are we posting our fantasies here? I have one with Scarlett Johansson if yall willing to hear me out.

I'm just playing a scenario that can happen in any game. Congrats on missing the point.

KingzAndQueenz wrote:

frogfood wrote:Are we posting our fantasies here? I have one with Scarlett Johansson if yall willing to hear me out.

I'm just playing a scenario that can happen in any game. Congrats on missing the point.

Your point was well taken but these two can't play together. Melo is better playing the 4 next to Chandler opposed to playing the 3 with Stoudemire in the line up. He needs to be traded, but who will take him

AdonisDeMarion wrote:

KingzAndQueenz wrote:

frogfood wrote:Are we posting our fantasies here? I have one with Scarlett Johansson if yall willing to hear me out.

I'm just playing a scenario that can happen in any game. Congrats on missing the point.

Your point was well taken but these two can't play together. Melo is better playing the 4 next to Chandler opposed to playing the 3 with Stoudemire in the line up. He needs to be traded, but who will take him

As long as Amar'e can hit the mid-range jumper, which he CAN do at good percentages, then it can most definitely work.

I'm not sure I want to rely on Amare to get a crucial stop and rebound in that situation.

Does his offense outweigh that? I dunno... is Melo gonna be posting up in that situation? If so, does Amare bring that much to the table as a perimeter spot-up shooter?

Knickstape1214 wrote:
As long as Amar'e can hit the mid-range jumper, which he CAN do at good percentages, then it can most definitely work.

The best justification for keeping Amare on the floor would be that he basically allows us to call a mid-play audible on a Melo post up. E.g. if a team is fronting Melo too hard, we can go into a p/r with Amare. If we're using him as a spot up shooter who plays lousy defense, why not just have Novak?

ORANGEandBLUE wrote:I'm not sure I want to rely on Amare to get a crucial stop and rebound in that situation.

Knicks had a very good record with Woodson-Melo-Stat.

The start to this season is suggesting that maybe that wasn't a fluke.

We're call giving credit for Melo genuinely trying to change-up his game.

Stands to reason we should at least give Stat a chance to show he can make the same adjustments.

Isn't that reasonable?

suicidedeuce wrote:

ORANGEandBLUE wrote:I'm not sure I want to rely on Amare to get a crucial stop and rebound in that situation.

Knicks had a very good record with Woodson-Melo-Stat.

The start to this season is suggesting that maybe that wasn't a fluke.

We're call giving credit for Melo genuinely trying to change-up his game.

Stands to reason we should at least give Stat a chance to show he can make the same adjustments.

Isn't that reasonable?

Yeah but Amare was awful on the boards against Miami in the playoffs, so I'm a little skeptical. Of course I'm willing to try it out and see how it works though.

All Im saying is, the way Woody has reached JR and made him such an indispensable, the way he has reached Melo and have him playing both sides on the floor.........I cant see why Amare cannot be reached as well.

We all had serious questions pertaining to Felton, Melo, JR, and to an extent Mike Woodson. Its not the fact that we're 6-0. Its how we're playing.

If Amare were playing and Melo was out for 2 months the issue would be if Melo would mess things up. Would Melo buy in to Woodson philosophy?

blumatic wrote:All Im saying is, the way Woody has reached JR and made him such an indispensable, the way he has reached Melo and have him playing both sides on the floor.........I cant see why Amare cannot be reached as well.

We all had serious questions pertaining to Felton, Melo, JR, and to an extent Mike Woodson. Its not the fact that we're 6-0. Its how we're playing.

If Amare were playing and Melo was out for 2 months the issue would be if Melo would mess things up. Would Melo buy in to Woodson philosophy?

Very good point.

Amare could be a weapon if Woodson wanted to make Offense/Defense substitutions.

Use amare for Offensive possession, then put Camby in on defense.

Amare is not coming off the bench. If anything they will showcase for trade. No way they make him a 20mil paperweight and expect full value in a trade later. Thats just stupid. Amare comes back and after 2 weeks traded with Brewer to the Charlotte Bobcats who can use all the help they can get. Knicks get Ben Gordon, Tyrus Thomas, and Charlotte's #1 pick

ORANGEandBLUE wrote:

suicidedeuce wrote:

ORANGEandBLUE wrote:I'm not sure I want to rely on Amare to get a crucial stop and rebound in that situation.

Knicks had a very good record with Woodson-Melo-Stat.

The start to this season is suggesting that maybe that wasn't a fluke.

We're call giving credit for Melo genuinely trying to change-up his game.

Stands to reason we should at least give Stat a chance to show he can make the same adjustments.

Isn't that reasonable?

Yeah but Amare was awful on the boards against Miami in the playoffs, so I'm a little skeptical. Of course I'm willing to try it out and see how it works though.

JR was a joke along with Amare last playoffs. JR was god-awful. I was in shock how a player with his talent would make so many mistakes and shoot so poorly.

Today JR has been so awesome, just Mr. Reliable.

falcindor wrote:Amare is not coming off the bench. If anything they will showcase for trade. No way they make him a 20mil paperweight and expect full value in a trade later. Thats just stupid. Amare comes back and after 2 weeks traded with Brewer to the Charlotte Bobcats who can use all the help they can get. Knicks get Ben Gordon, Tyrus Thomas, and Charlotte's #1 pick

Charlotte says no.

Charlotte cant net a top tier free agent. Unless they pay a middle of road player no way they get a max worthy player. Say what you want about Amare meshing with Melo. But alone hes a beast. He and Melo play too similarly and get in easy others way. But as an acquisition Charlotte cant do much better than that. Charlotte puts a top 4 protection on the pick thats all.

falcindor wrote:Charlotte cant net a top tier free agent. Unless they pay a middle of road player no way they get a max worthy player. Say what you want about Amare meshing with Melo. But alone hes a beast. He and Melo play too similarly and get in easy others way. But as an acquisition Charlotte cant do much better than that. Charlotte puts a top 4 protection on the pick thats all.

MJ isn't gonna get himself on the books for a completely non-insured contract. GMs can't make a move without the approval of ownership.

Also, the #1 would have to be lottery protected for them to even consider making the trade.


Also, let's see how they play when healthy/with a normal practice schedule. I do not think they clash as much as others do.