NoLayupRule wrote:Basketball1981 wrote:god shammgod wrote:
you replaced rose's scoring with timmy who's more efficient. don't get your hopes up.
That may be true. Another reason I hated that Hardaway signing....made literally zero sense. It's like, if he plays great and justifies that contract then he'll surely hurt our draft position a lot. If on the other hand he plays less efficiently so that he doesn't hurt our draft position, then the contract will look terrible. It takes a whole level of incompetency to be in charge for one week and put yourself in a position with a particular signing where you can literally only lose. Well done Mills
.
But at least we have no solid PG. Baker is not really NBA material, Frank is a rookie and Sessions is 36 years old. I still think the combination of age, inexperience, inability at the PG position will cost us a lot of (close) games next season.
I don't get the rose = thjr conversation at all
Rose provided scoring. Sure. But his defense was a major negative. He didn't pass. He froze out Kp. Etc.
Thjr worries the hell out of me but he's not the same type of player as rose at all. Thjr won't dominate the ball. He might play some d. He won't be initiating the offense so he won't be freezing out Kp.
It's an ignorant argument
First off if were worried about the team winning a bunch more games with Hardaway we don't need to. The truth is the team is not strong enough to win more games than they did last year
Worried about Hardaway holding back Kp? That's almost as foolish as an argument can be
First off the real problem with KP's development is internal
Sure teamates freezing him out and team style of play are factors, but he has to be self-motivated. If he is going to be an all star, like so many people think he is, then he can't eat frozen out by the likes of rose and he has to get his.
Neither hardaway nor melo should be a detriment to this kids growth. You don't see other potential franchise players hurt in their growth by good or selfish players around them. Somehow butler developed fine next to rose, for example.
Hardaway will probably be a better team player than rose. Jesus, if not that's really a disaster.
But this team will still suck.
We will probably get a 5-9 pick and Kp will make significant improvements. As will Willy and others
That's a successful season.
A dream season is improvement all across the board and still getting a top 2 pick
Let me address this in a couple of steps because I actually not only disagree with your argument, but also am of the opinion that you are using faulty logic to defend a signing that in reality puts the Knicks in a bad position now and for the next few years.
1. I never mentioned being worried about KPs development at all, so I'm not sure where the bolded question is coming from. To me, KP is heads and shoulders above anything THjr can ever become so there is no reason to be worried about that. THjr is an 8th man on a good team, he can't take anything away from KP.
2.As for the Rose vs. THjr argument. You essentially argue that Rose had a lot of negative aspects to his game (scoring aside). Then you proceed to argue that THjr is more of a team player, won't dominate the ball and may play some D (although I'd need to see that before believing it). So you are essentially saying that THjr can come close to matching Rose's scoring without the negative aspects. So in your book, that should be a huge plus for THjr. But then you backpedal and say that all that is not going to translate into any more wins. Now this makes your whole argument either suspect or you pretty much argue in my favor.
First of all, it is suspect to argue that said player will do this and that and how he fits better etc. but then argue that all that is not going to translate into more wins. If Thjr can come close to all that it should surely translate into some wins, no? We lost an awful lot of close games last season, right? All those losses with less than 5 point margin....you think all that better team play, maybe some D, more ball movement, less freezing out KP that you assume THjr is gonna bring, is all of a sudden not going to translate into any more wins? That's wishful thinking. What you are hoping for is a scenario which in reality seems extremely unlikely. You are hoping for a scenario where Hardaway plays very strong , justifies that ridiculous contract, but yet the Knicks' draft position does not get hurt at all. That is the same type of wishful thinking that has gotten the franchise into trouble for two decades. Doing silly moves, hoping reality somehow bails you out. Not going to happen. The sane thing to believe is that Hardaway either plays great and justifies that contract , which in turn may make the difference between 27 wins and a 3rd pick or 31 wins and a 8th pick. Or Hardaway does not show much improvement rendering the contract terrible and immovable, and most importantly it will limit any sensible free agent moves for the next 3-4 years.
3.You argue that the team is not strong enough to win more games. That may be true, but did you figure into your calculation that with Indiana, Atlanta and Chicago three teams that were ahead of us last year are going to completely tank and suck this year? 31 wins last season meant the 7th/8th worst record last season, it could mean 10th place this season. Let us not kid ourselves there---any pick outside the top 5 is going to limit any quick progress that one can hope for. We need top talent , superstar level talent to make this a successful rebuild. If the organization and fans are ok with getting 8th picks every year and defend silly moves of management, then be aware that this process may take much longer than you wish for. If past drafts taught you anything (not trading picks aside), then it was that we should try to be as high as possible (Westbrook, Curry). It was of utmost importance to conduct roster management in a way where we maximize our chances at a top 5 pick, not minimize them. The most sensible thing was to refrain from any free agent signings, let this year play out and hope for the highest possible pick. The silly move was to hand out a highly questionable contract to an extremely mediocre player in hopes it works out. Truth is, if you offered THjr to any of the other 29 teams and only asked for a second round pick in return, all 29 would likely decline. That's the definition of terrible management and a waste of assets (cap space in this case).