ImageImageImageImageImage

With Carmelo are we a playoff team?

Moderators: moocow007, Capn'O, magnumt, Knickstape1214, j4remi, mrpoetryNmotion, King of Canada, Deeeez Knicks, Thorn, GONYK, NoLayupRule, Thugger HBC

Kristaps6_NYK
Starter
Posts: 2,323
And1: 1,141
Joined: Mar 11, 2014

With Carmelo are we a playoff team? 

Post#1 » by Kristaps6_NYK » Wed Aug 9, 2017 4:41 pm

We've done a lot of promising stuff this off season.. Not that I'm pro playoff team considering I want a clean rebuild personally but a lineup of..

Frank Ntilikina - Ramon Sessions - Ron Baker
Courtney Lee - Tim Hardaway Jr. - Dame Dotson
Carmelo Anthony - Lance Thomas
Kristaps Porzingis - Michael Beasley - KOQ
Willy Hernangomez - Joakim Noah - KOQ

Looks pretty reasonable especially in the east. Frank brings team play and passion. Timmy and Beas brings scoring off the bench, Joke, Baker and KOQ can bring grit if Noah is ever healthy.

Imo it's not a terrible team. We certainly won't compete with the worst teams so the lottery won't happen. We can bring meaningful basketball to guys like KP, Willy and Frank. We still have our firsts so we can bring in youth over the years.

I know it's beating a dead horse but I wouldn't be upset if Carmelo is still a Knick
User avatar
Fury
Knicks Forum Mock Draft Co-Champ
Posts: 17,170
And1: 6,773
Joined: Mar 07, 2007
       

Re: With Carmelo are we a playoff team? 

Post#2 » by Fury » Wed Aug 9, 2017 4:44 pm

I think we can sneak in. Which is why we need to trade him
shtolky
Analyst
Posts: 3,466
And1: 1,753
Joined: Apr 15, 2005

Re: With Carmelo are we a playoff team? 

Post#3 » by shtolky » Wed Aug 9, 2017 4:49 pm

Kristaps6_NYK wrote:We've done a lot of promising stuff this off season.. Not that I'm pro playoff team considering I want a clean rebuild personally but a lineup of..

Frank Ntilikina - Ramon Sessions - Ron Baker
Courtney Lee - Tim Hardaway Jr. - Dame Dotson
Carmelo Anthony - Lance Thomas
Kristaps Porzingis - Michael Beasley - KOQ
Willy Hernangomez - Joakim Noah - KOQ

Looks pretty reasonable especially in the east. Frank brings team play and passion. Timmy and Beas brings scoring off the bench, Joke, Baker and KOQ can bring grit if Noah is ever healthy.

Imo it's not a terrible team. We certainly won't compete with the worst teams so the lottery won't happen. We can bring meaningful basketball to guys like KP, Willy and Frank. We still have our firsts so we can bring in youth over the years.

I know it's beating a dead horse but I wouldn't be upset if Carmelo is still a Knick



I don't see how Lee starts at the 2 over THJ. Given how piss poor the east is, how we would have actual PG's who would look to get others involved (at least compared to Rose), and a likely KP year 3 leap, a playoff push is definitely possible. But as was said above, that's why you deal Melo. Getting the 8th seed is fine and dandy for all of 5 seconds, until we get swept or beaten in 5. Gotta keep the rebuild going, deal Melo, have Frank start by the end of the season, and add another lotto pick in time for that juicy 2019 FA class.
User avatar
mpharris36
RealGM
Posts: 43,781
And1: 16,469
Joined: Nov 03, 2010
     

Re: With Carmelo are we a playoff team? 

Post#4 » by mpharris36 » Wed Aug 9, 2017 4:51 pm

Image
BAT 18.0 Bulls:

C -Willie Cauley-Stein/Willie Hernangomez/Cristiano Felicio
PF -LeBron James/Lauri Markkanen/DJ Wilson
SF -Joe Ingles/Terrence Ferguson/James Jones
SG -Avery Bradley/Manu Ginobli/DeAndre Liggins
PG -Malik Monk/Bryn Forbes/Shabazz Napier
User avatar
ChaosHamster
Starter
Posts: 2,016
And1: 1,299
Joined: Oct 07, 2015

Re: With Carmelo are we a playoff team? 

Post#5 » by ChaosHamster » Wed Aug 9, 2017 4:51 pm

ECF
Kristaps6_NYK
Starter
Posts: 2,323
And1: 1,141
Joined: Mar 11, 2014

Re: With Carmelo are we a playoff team? 

Post#6 » by Kristaps6_NYK » Wed Aug 9, 2017 4:52 pm

shtolky wrote:
Kristaps6_NYK wrote:We've done a lot of promising stuff this off season.. Not that I'm pro playoff team considering I want a clean rebuild personally but a lineup of..

Frank Ntilikina - Ramon Sessions - Ron Baker
Courtney Lee - Tim Hardaway Jr. - Dame Dotson
Carmelo Anthony - Lance Thomas
Kristaps Porzingis - Michael Beasley - KOQ
Willy Hernangomez - Joakim Noah - KOQ

Looks pretty reasonable especially in the east. Frank brings team play and passion. Timmy and Beas brings scoring off the bench, Joke, Baker and KOQ can bring grit if Noah is ever healthy.

Imo it's not a terrible team. We certainly won't compete with the worst teams so the lottery won't happen. We can bring meaningful basketball to guys like KP, Willy and Frank. We still have our firsts so we can bring in youth over the years.

I know it's beating a dead horse but I wouldn't be upset if Carmelo is still a Knick



I don't see how Lee starts at the 2 over THJ. Given how piss poor the east is, how we would have actual PG's who would look to get others involved (at least compared to Rose), and a likely KP year 3 leap, a playoff push is definitely possible. But as was said above, that's why you deal Melo. Getting the 8th seed is fine and dandy for all of 5 seconds, until we get swept or beaten in 5. Gotta keep the rebuild going, deal Melo, have Frank start by the end of the season, and add another lotto pick in time for that juicy 2019 FA class.
Im for a rebuild 110% but if we don't we could be a good team. I'd put THJr on the bench as 6th man. Clear 6man winner
User avatar
3toheadmelo
RealGM
Posts: 11,306
And1: 6,091
Joined: Feb 15, 2015
 

Re: With Carmelo are we a playoff team? 

Post#7 » by 3toheadmelo » Wed Aug 9, 2017 4:54 pm

i think so...

i want him gone nao!
San Antonio Spurs aka sniiiiiiiper gang Co-GM: ctorres

PG: Rubio/Smart/Udrih
SG: Middleton/Harrison/Johnson
SF: Aminu/Harris/McRae
PF: Melo/Portis/Tavares
C:Vucevic/Len/Bogut
Caramel_Anton
Junior
Posts: 259
And1: 98
Joined: Aug 02, 2017

Re: With Carmelo are we a playoff team? 

Post#8 » by Caramel_Anton » Wed Aug 9, 2017 4:55 pm

Kristaps6_NYK wrote:We've done a lot of promising stuff this off season.. Not that I'm pro playoff team considering I want a clean rebuild personally but a lineup of..

Frank Ntilikina - Ramon Sessions - Ron Baker
Courtney Lee - Tim Hardaway Jr. - Dame Dotson
Carmelo Anthony - Lance Thomas
Kristaps Porzingis - Michael Beasley - KOQ
Willy Hernangomez - Joakim Noah - KOQ

Looks pretty reasonable especially in the east. Frank brings team play and passion. Timmy and Beas brings scoring off the bench, Joke, Baker and KOQ can bring grit if Noah is ever healthy.

Imo it's not a terrible team. We certainly won't compete with the worst teams so the lottery won't happen. We can bring meaningful basketball to guys like KP, Willy and Frank. We still have our firsts so we can bring in youth over the years.

I know it's beating a dead horse but I wouldn't be upset if Carmelo is still a Knick


Your depth chart is all sorts of wrong..

Pending no moves we are more than likely going to start the season like:
RS / Frank / Baker / Randle
THjr / Lee / Dotson / Baker
Melo / Thomas / Lee / Dotson
KP6 / Beasley / KOQ / Kornet
Willy / KOQ / Noah / Kornet

With Porzingis playing a lot of C and Melo playing a lot of 4. Lee will see 6th man minutes at the 2/3.

We really should make playoffs with that which is why Melo, Lee & even K'OQ should be moved.
Kristaps6_NYK
Starter
Posts: 2,323
And1: 1,141
Joined: Mar 11, 2014

Re: With Carmelo are we a playoff team? 

Post#9 » by Kristaps6_NYK » Wed Aug 9, 2017 4:59 pm

Caramel_Anton wrote:
Kristaps6_NYK wrote:We've done a lot of promising stuff this off season.. Not that I'm pro playoff team considering I want a clean rebuild personally but a lineup of..

Frank Ntilikina - Ramon Sessions - Ron Baker
Courtney Lee - Tim Hardaway Jr. - Dame Dotson
Carmelo Anthony - Lance Thomas
Kristaps Porzingis - Michael Beasley - KOQ
Willy Hernangomez - Joakim Noah - KOQ

Looks pretty reasonable especially in the east. Frank brings team play and passion. Timmy and Beas brings scoring off the bench, Joke, Baker and KOQ can bring grit if Noah is ever healthy.

Imo it's not a terrible team. We certainly won't compete with the worst teams so the lottery won't happen. We can bring meaningful basketball to guys like KP, Willy and Frank. We still have our firsts so we can bring in youth over the years.

I know it's beating a dead horse but I wouldn't be upset if Carmelo is still a Knick


Your depth chart is all sorts of wrong..

Pending no moves we are more than likely going to start the season like:
RS / Frank / Baker / Randle
THjr / Lee / Dotson / Baker
Melo / Thomas / Lee / Dotson
KP6 / Beasley / KOQ / Kornet
Willy / KOQ / Noah / Kornet

With Porzingis playing a lot of C and Melo playing a lot of 4. Lee will see 6th man minutes at the 2/3.

We really should make playoffs with that which is why Melo, Lee & even K'OQ should be moved.
I had Frank and Lee starting? How is that all sorts of wrong?
Caramel_Anton
Junior
Posts: 259
And1: 98
Joined: Aug 02, 2017

Re: With Carmelo are we a playoff team? 

Post#10 » by Caramel_Anton » Wed Aug 9, 2017 5:01 pm

Kristaps6_NYK wrote:
Caramel_Anton wrote:
Kristaps6_NYK wrote:We've done a lot of promising stuff this off season.. Not that I'm pro playoff team considering I want a clean rebuild personally but a lineup of..

Frank Ntilikina - Ramon Sessions - Ron Baker
Courtney Lee - Tim Hardaway Jr. - Dame Dotson
Carmelo Anthony - Lance Thomas
Kristaps Porzingis - Michael Beasley - KOQ
Willy Hernangomez - Joakim Noah - KOQ

Looks pretty reasonable especially in the east. Frank brings team play and passion. Timmy and Beas brings scoring off the bench, Joke, Baker and KOQ can bring grit if Noah is ever healthy.

Imo it's not a terrible team. We certainly won't compete with the worst teams so the lottery won't happen. We can bring meaningful basketball to guys like KP, Willy and Frank. We still have our firsts so we can bring in youth over the years.

I know it's beating a dead horse but I wouldn't be upset if Carmelo is still a Knick


Your depth chart is all sorts of wrong..

Pending no moves we are more than likely going to start the season like:
RS / Frank / Baker / Randle
THjr / Lee / Dotson / Baker
Melo / Thomas / Lee / Dotson
KP6 / Beasley / KOQ / Kornet
Willy / KOQ / Noah / Kornet

With Porzingis playing a lot of C and Melo playing a lot of 4. Lee will see 6th man minutes at the 2/3.

We really should make playoffs with that which is why Melo, Lee & even K'OQ should be moved.
I had Frank and Lee starting? How is that all sorts of wrong?


Because initially I was going to say KP6 was going to be our starting C but that really would only happen if these other guys get traded. So you weren't all sorts of wrong, just very wrong about THjr not starting.
User avatar
Knicksfan1992
Head Coach
Posts: 6,721
And1: 4,816
Joined: Jun 14, 2012
         

Re: With Carmelo are we a playoff team? 

Post#11 » by Knicksfan1992 » Wed Aug 9, 2017 5:04 pm

If you're starting Ramon Sessions on opening night you have no aspirations for being a good team... PGs will continuously out perform ours until Frank starts to improve. Melo will continue to regress and it's been proven he can't carry subpar casts anymore to enough wins to make the playoffs. Even with a KP jump, I don't see it... We're not going to be good enough defensively on a consistent basis to win the majority of our games. Only reason we would get in, is that the East is that bad after the top 4 and someone has to make it.
OVOXO

Drizzy Drake
Aaliyah
Noah "40" Shebib -producer
Fabolous
Kid Cudi
Khaled- executive/producer/hype man
Sampha
Boi 1da - Producer
Lloyd Banks
MF DOOM
YG
Jeezy
Mac Dre
Billy Goat
Pro Prospect
Posts: 925
And1: 306
Joined: Mar 08, 2017
 

Re: With Carmelo are we a playoff team? 

Post#12 » by Billy Goat » Wed Aug 9, 2017 5:04 pm

Why would the same exact team as last year win 10 more games?
Kristaps6_NYK
Starter
Posts: 2,323
And1: 1,141
Joined: Mar 11, 2014

Re: With Carmelo are we a playoff team? 

Post#13 » by Kristaps6_NYK » Wed Aug 9, 2017 5:10 pm

Billy Goat wrote:Why would the same exact team as last year win 10 more games?
Added youth and legit scoring options, got rid of DRose and the triangle. Could be a 45 win team imo..
ChilledAlex
Rookie
Posts: 1,096
And1: 474
Joined: Jun 26, 2015
 

Re: With Carmelo are we a playoff team? 

Post#14 » by ChilledAlex » Wed Aug 9, 2017 5:11 pm

Just watch Noah come out healthy, in shape and hungry... In this weak conference we can really be a treadmill team
shtolky
Analyst
Posts: 3,466
And1: 1,753
Joined: Apr 15, 2005

Re: With Carmelo are we a playoff team? 

Post#15 » by shtolky » Wed Aug 9, 2017 5:13 pm

Billy Goat wrote:Why would the same exact team as last year win 10 more games?



Not really the exact same team. New SG, new PGs, probable big improvements from Willy and KP, and a net negative in Rose gone. Plus, you're assuming it takes 41 wins to make the playoffs. The east got a lot worse this offseason. Atlanta, Indy, and Chicago are all out. That's three spots up for grabs. Figure Miami gets one. That's two spots among Bk, Phi, NY, Orl, Cha, Det. Who of the other 5 are demonstrably better than us? Maybe Detroit adding Bradley? 8th seed isn't out of the question with Melo, which is why we need him gone, and get Frank in the starting role sooner rather than later.
User avatar
Deeeez Knicks
Forum Mod - Knicks
Forum Mod - Knicks
Posts: 25,650
And1: 8,993
Joined: Nov 12, 2004
Location: Bar stool

Re: With Carmelo are we a playoff team? 

Post#16 » by Deeeez Knicks » Wed Aug 9, 2017 5:16 pm

The east is bad so I would not count any team out.

No PG, bad defense...most likely we will be bad again
Pelicans
C: KP | Lucas Noguiera | Deyonta Davis
PF: Thad Young | Montrezl Harrell| D Powell
SF: Gordon Hayward | Paul Zipser |Mario Hez
SG: Danny Green | Josh Hart | Stuckey
PG: Jrue Holiday | Tyus Jones |Jerian Grant
DaKnicksAreBack
Analyst
Posts: 3,554
And1: 1,684
Joined: Jan 29, 2015
 

Re: With Carmelo are we a playoff team? 

Post#17 » by DaKnicksAreBack » Wed Aug 9, 2017 5:16 pm

I think whether we make the playoffs or not will be determined more by what Tim and KP can produce for us. Melo fell off a lot last year.
User avatar
K-DOT
Assistant Coach
Posts: 3,782
And1: 2,717
Joined: Nov 25, 2016
       

Re: With Carmelo are we a playoff team? 

Post#18 » by K-DOT » Wed Aug 9, 2017 5:16 pm

No
That white frost on that pound cake
So your Duncan Hines is irrelevant
Savageknick2190
Junior
Posts: 278
And1: 90
Joined: Jun 22, 2017
 

Re: With Carmelo are we a playoff team? 

Post#19 » by Savageknick2190 » Wed Aug 9, 2017 5:18 pm

Kristaps6_NYK wrote:
Billy Goat wrote:Why would the same exact team as last year win 10 more games?
Added youth and legit scoring options, got rid of DRose and the triangle. Could be a 45 win team imo..


Stop smoking that good stuff. The Knicks are mediocre with Carmelo and will fall outside the playoffs by a couple of games if he stays. If he is gone then the team will be in the top five of the lottery with a very good shot at number 1
Kristaps6_NYK
Starter
Posts: 2,323
And1: 1,141
Joined: Mar 11, 2014

Re: With Carmelo are we a playoff team? 

Post#20 » by Kristaps6_NYK » Wed Aug 9, 2017 5:21 pm

Savageknick2190 wrote:
Kristaps6_NYK wrote:
Billy Goat wrote:Why would the same exact team as last year win 10 more games?
Added youth and legit scoring options, got rid of DRose and the triangle. Could be a 45 win team imo..


Stop smoking that good stuff. The Knicks are mediocre with Carmelo and will fall outside the playoffs by a couple of games if he stays. If he is gone then the team will be in the top five of the lottery with a very good shot at number 1
You do realize how bad the east is right?

Return to New York Knicks