The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
Moderators: Deeeez Knicks, mpharris36, j4remi, HerSports85, NoLayupRule, GONYK, Jeff Van Gully, dakomish23
The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 8,199
- And1: 2,276
- Joined: Nov 15, 2014
The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
Knicks made the KAT trade in the off-season, but the real reason why we're in the ECF is the decision to hold on and wait for Mitchell Robinson. If he was traded for spare parts like many wanted, there's no way the Knicks get past Boston.
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
- Context
- RealGM
- Posts: 32,631
- And1: 21,968
- Joined: Jul 06, 2005
- Location: where the Gods dwell! shhhhhhh
-
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
TimRobbins wrote:Knicks made the KAT trade in the off-season, but the real reason why we're in the ECF is the decision to hold on and wait for Mitchell Robinson. If he was traded for spare parts like many wanted, there's no way the Knicks get past Boston.
1000%!

* | * | *
* | * | *
* | * | *
* | * | *
* | * | *
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 17,369
- And1: 5,599
- Joined: Jun 04, 2005
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
- Capn'O
- Retired Mod
- Posts: 89,374
- And1: 108,751
- Joined: Dec 16, 2005
- Location: Bone Goal
-
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
We also clearly were extra cautious on his return timetable. They may have cleaned up some underlying causes off the record too.
BAF Clippers: Great Team. No Future.
PG: SGA | Coleworld
SG: Big Ragu | Podz
SF: Kuminga | Thybulle
PF: KAT | K. Williams
C: BroLo | D. Sharpe
Deep Bench - Merrill | Craig | Reath | Saric | Lowry

PG: SGA | Coleworld
SG: Big Ragu | Podz
SF: Kuminga | Thybulle
PF: KAT | K. Williams
C: BroLo | D. Sharpe
Deep Bench - Merrill | Craig | Reath | Saric | Lowry

Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
- 3toheadmelo
- RealGM
- Posts: 94,519
- And1: 135,387
- Joined: Feb 15, 2015
-
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run

It’s like when lil bitches make subliminal records, if it ain’t directed directly at me, I don’t respect it
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
-
- Retired Mod
- Posts: 59,573
- And1: 5,856
- Joined: Jul 21, 2001
- Location: East of West and West of East.
- Contact:
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
3toheadmelo wrote:
That play is nuts.
I never understood all the Mitch trade talk, unless they figured his injury history was too risky, but when he's on the court, he gives us something we don't have from anyone else. I always thought he had more value than anyone we could acquire for him.
Bill Clinton slept with an intern. A consenting adult and he got impeached and nearly disbarred as a result. Donald Trump went to parties showcasing underaged women brought in as basically prostitutes, and he says it's nothing.
Double standard?
Double standard?
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
-
- Sixth Man
- Posts: 1,840
- And1: 1,479
- Joined: Apr 24, 2024
-
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
Luv those Knicks wrote:3toheadmelo wrote:
That play is nuts.
I never understood all the Mitch trade talk, unless they figured his injury history was too risky, but when he's on the court, he gives us something we don't have from anyone else. I always thought he had more value than anyone we could acquire for him.
something no one else in the sport can give you*
idk if there's another player in the league that can make that play.
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
- 3toheadmelo
- RealGM
- Posts: 94,519
- And1: 135,387
- Joined: Feb 15, 2015
-
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
Luv those Knicks wrote:3toheadmelo wrote:
That play is nuts.
I never understood all the Mitch trade talk, unless they figured his injury history was too risky, but when he's on the court, he gives us something we don't have from anyone else. I always thought he had more value than anyone we could acquire for him.
We just liked bullying sham for a bit

It’s like when lil bitches make subliminal records, if it ain’t directed directly at me, I don’t respect it
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
- 2010
- RealGM
- Posts: 37,335
- And1: 42,449
- Joined: Jul 24, 2008
-
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
Luv those Knicks wrote:3toheadmelo wrote:
That play is nuts.
I never understood all the Mitch trade talk, unless they figured his injury history was too risky, but when he's on the court, he gives us something we don't have from anyone else. I always thought he had more value than anyone we could acquire for him.
This is why you never make trades based on emotions or frustrations.

2024-25 Bubble Champs
1: White | Sexton | Porter
2: Sharpe | Smart | Okogie
3: Thompson | Dort | Rupert
4: Wembanyama | Porter Jr. | Bol
5: Gobert | Wood | Mamukelashvili
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
- gavran
- RealGM
- Posts: 18,159
- And1: 8,860
- Joined: Nov 02, 2005
- Location: crossing the line
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
Robinson's injury history is a concern. That is why he is only getting 12 million next year. Which means, if he plays only 35 games next season, he will still be criminally underpaid. Never doubted him for a second.
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 24,682
- And1: 4,884
- Joined: Jul 21, 2002
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
This was also an easy decision. You don’t give up on a DPOY potential center on a budget contract for no reason. Next we should extend that contract in the summer.
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
- Jeff Van Gully
- Forum Mod - Knicks
- Posts: 30,343
- And1: 30,372
- Joined: Jul 31, 2010
-
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
RIP magnumt
thanks for everything, thibs.
Knicks Forum: State of the Board - Summer 2025
avatar by evevale
thanks for everything, thibs.
Knicks Forum: State of the Board - Summer 2025
avatar by evevale
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
- Jeff Van Gully
- Forum Mod - Knicks
- Posts: 30,343
- And1: 30,372
- Joined: Jul 31, 2010
-
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
LFGK wrote:Luv those Knicks wrote:3toheadmelo wrote:
That play is nuts.
I never understood all the Mitch trade talk, unless they figured his injury history was too risky, but when he's on the court, he gives us something we don't have from anyone else. I always thought he had more value than anyone we could acquire for him.
something no one else in the sport can give you*
idk if there's another player in the league that can make that play.
certainly not a big.
and yes, i know evan mobley is DPOY.
RIP magnumt
thanks for everything, thibs.
Knicks Forum: State of the Board - Summer 2025
avatar by evevale
thanks for everything, thibs.
Knicks Forum: State of the Board - Summer 2025
avatar by evevale
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
- Jeff Van Gully
- Forum Mod - Knicks
- Posts: 30,343
- And1: 30,372
- Joined: Jul 31, 2010
-
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
i don't want to be too hyperbolic and say this is THE decision. you know me. it's always more nuanced. 
but definitely a MAJOR factor. always felt he would have made a huge difference deep into last year's run. and we're seeing why it was so important to prioritize his health.
this is also why we traded for and maintained KAT at C. so he could hold down the position during the regular season, grow, and be ready to complement mitch (even defensively) as part of a new era big rotation. we've got a lot of flexibility and we've been using it.

but definitely a MAJOR factor. always felt he would have made a huge difference deep into last year's run. and we're seeing why it was so important to prioritize his health.
this is also why we traded for and maintained KAT at C. so he could hold down the position during the regular season, grow, and be ready to complement mitch (even defensively) as part of a new era big rotation. we've got a lot of flexibility and we've been using it.
RIP magnumt
thanks for everything, thibs.
Knicks Forum: State of the Board - Summer 2025
avatar by evevale
thanks for everything, thibs.
Knicks Forum: State of the Board - Summer 2025
avatar by evevale
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
- stuporman
- RealGM
- Posts: 31,786
- And1: 20,563
- Joined: Nov 27, 2005
- Location: optimistic skeptical realist
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
With as long as Mitch was out it has to be commended the shape he came back in, I'm not talking 'game shape', I'm referring to his weight. He came back pretty slender, maybe as slim as he has been since before he went through his 'bulk up phase' after his first two seasons.
In addition to helping put less pressure on his ankles it allowed him to become more effective sooner considering he wouldn't have all that much time to ramp up before the playoff. His mobility guarding the perimeter and covering ground has been crucial to his play these playoffs.
There's no lumber to his gait at all, he's back to nimble Mitch. Now if we can get KAT to tone up and trim down a little bit, I've noticed him lumbering and laboring at time these playoffs. It will help him on both ends of the court and again less pressure on legs for a big man.
In addition to helping put less pressure on his ankles it allowed him to become more effective sooner considering he wouldn't have all that much time to ramp up before the playoff. His mobility guarding the perimeter and covering ground has been crucial to his play these playoffs.
There's no lumber to his gait at all, he's back to nimble Mitch. Now if we can get KAT to tone up and trim down a little bit, I've noticed him lumbering and laboring at time these playoffs. It will help him on both ends of the court and again less pressure on legs for a big man.
If you'd rather see your team fail so you can be right
...you are a fan of your opinion not the team.
?
Knowledge is just information stuffed into a mental bag
Wisdom is knowing what to pull out of the bag to do the job
...you are a fan of your opinion not the team.

Knowledge is just information stuffed into a mental bag
Wisdom is knowing what to pull out of the bag to do the job
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
- CharlesOakley
- Veteran
- Posts: 2,899
- And1: 2,832
- Joined: Jun 27, 2006
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
He is a real-life unicorn. Vertical ability with length and lateral quickness plus a dog mentality.
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
- rajajackal
- Head Coach
- Posts: 7,399
- And1: 9,333
- Joined: Nov 04, 2013
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
i want to go on the record as saying most of this forum made very low IQ comments about mitchell robinson since he first went down last year and hartenstein became the starter. i have held it down and told you all what you see in these playoffs is why and you will recognize that i know ball
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
- Gravy
- Head Coach
- Posts: 6,932
- And1: 9,330
- Joined: Jun 25, 2015
-
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
Its crazy how much difference a rim-runner offensive liability made against a 5 out team that loves to spam threes. We tried to copy their offense signing KAT but Mitch was the game changer.
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
- Capn'O
- Retired Mod
- Posts: 89,374
- And1: 108,751
- Joined: Dec 16, 2005
- Location: Bone Goal
-
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
Credit due to Mitch himself. He's clearly trimmed down and that has allowed him to regain the requisite speed to guard the perimeter in addition to bang down low. He wasn't able to do that as well the past few years.
BAF Clippers: Great Team. No Future.
PG: SGA | Coleworld
SG: Big Ragu | Podz
SF: Kuminga | Thybulle
PF: KAT | K. Williams
C: BroLo | D. Sharpe
Deep Bench - Merrill | Craig | Reath | Saric | Lowry

PG: SGA | Coleworld
SG: Big Ragu | Podz
SF: Kuminga | Thybulle
PF: KAT | K. Williams
C: BroLo | D. Sharpe
Deep Bench - Merrill | Craig | Reath | Saric | Lowry

Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
-
- Sixth Man
- Posts: 1,840
- And1: 1,479
- Joined: Apr 24, 2024
-
Re: The Decision to hold on to Mitchell Robinson made this playoff run
Jeff Van Gully wrote:LFGK wrote:Luv those Knicks wrote:
That play is nuts.
I never understood all the Mitch trade talk, unless they figured his injury history was too risky, but when he's on the court, he gives us something we don't have from anyone else. I always thought he had more value than anyone we could acquire for him.
something no one else in the sport can give you*
idk if there's another player in the league that can make that play.
certainly not a big.
and yes, i know evan mobley is DPOY.
Promise you Mobley stinks, watching this guy that last series, I could not understand the hype.