ImageImageImageImage

Next fight...WCJ

Moderators: ChosenSavior, UCF, Knightro, UCFJayBird, Def Swami, Howard Mass

Skybox
RealGM
Posts: 18,354
And1: 8,421
Joined: Jan 21, 2017
 

Re: Next fight...WCJ 

Post#21 » by Skybox » Thu Nov 16, 2023 11:08 am

drsd wrote:
Def Swami wrote:Always been a WCJ fan, but feels very replaceable. He's solid. He plays his role well. I just wish he did one of protect the rim or shoot the 3 at a high level.


I am nt sure I would take Bitadze out of the starting lineup now, for example.


Bitadze is “good enough”, can WCJ get us Brogdon or Simons? (Or similar?)
User avatar
drsd
RealGM
Posts: 39,035
And1: 8,895
Joined: Mar 16, 2003
     

Re: Next fight...WCJ 

Post#22 » by drsd » Thu Nov 16, 2023 11:53 am

Skybox wrote:
drsd wrote:
Def Swami wrote:Always been a WCJ fan, but feels very replaceable. He's solid. He plays his role well. I just wish he did one of protect the rim or shoot the 3 at a high level.


I am nt sure I would take Bitadze out of the starting lineup now, for example.


Bitadze is “good enough”, can WCJ get us Brogdon or Simons? (Or similar?)


Why choose:
Brogdon AND Simons for Fultz, Carter, G-Harris, the Denver pick, two unprotected FRPs, and a future FRP pickswap.


Brogdon/Anthony/Black
Simons/Suggs/Howard
F-Wagner/Ingles/Houstan
Banchero/Isaac/Okeke
Bitadze/M-Wagner/some-dude

I like that starting five 200X over the Fultz/Suggs led starting five. If it costs Carter, so be it.
I could see that roster contending in 2024/25.
basketballRob
RealGM
Posts: 36,250
And1: 14,202
Joined: May 05, 2014
     

Re: Next fight...WCJ 

Post#23 » by basketballRob » Thu Nov 16, 2023 12:50 pm

2 expiring contracts, Wendell on a great contract, and 3 first round picks for Simons and Brogdon? I wouldn't do that. That package would get you Pascal, Markannen, Donovan Mitchell, or some other player of that caliber.

I'd give like Fultz, Okeke, and 3 seconds for Simons. Portland probably wants off his contract. Simons has been a negatively rated player for his whole career so far.

Sent from my SM-G781U using RealGM mobile app
User avatar
tiderulz
RealGM
Posts: 36,915
And1: 14,847
Joined: Jun 16, 2010
Location: Atlanta
 

Re: Next fight...WCJ 

Post#24 » by tiderulz » Thu Nov 16, 2023 1:28 pm

basketballRob wrote:2 expiring contracts, Wendell on a great contract, and 3 first round picks for Simons and Brogdon? I wouldn't do that. That package would get you Pascal, Markannen, Donovan Mitchell, or some other player of that caliber.

I'd give like Fultz, Okeke, and 3 seconds for Simons. Portland probably wants off his contract. Simons has been a negatively rated player for his whole career so far.

Sent from my SM-G781U using RealGM mobile app

for which stat?
pepe1991
RealGM
Posts: 22,960
And1: 18,953
Joined: Jan 10, 2016
   

Re: Next fight...WCJ 

Post#25 » by pepe1991 » Thu Nov 16, 2023 1:44 pm

Long term, you really can't compete for playoffs with Goga and Mortiz at C. If you get rid of Wendell for whatever reason, you need starting level nba C.
Life is what happens when you're busy making other plans. -John Lennon
basketballRob
RealGM
Posts: 36,250
And1: 14,202
Joined: May 05, 2014
     

Re: Next fight...WCJ 

Post#26 » by basketballRob » Thu Nov 16, 2023 1:47 pm

pepe1991 wrote:Long term, you really can't compete for playoffs with Goga and Mortiz at C. If you get rid of Wendell for whatever reason, you need starting level nba C.
I like Isaac playing center in crunch time. AG played backup center in the playoffs last season and was effective.

Sent from my SM-G781U using RealGM mobile app
Skybox
RealGM
Posts: 18,354
And1: 8,421
Joined: Jan 21, 2017
 

Re: Next fight...WCJ 

Post#27 » by Skybox » Thu Nov 16, 2023 1:50 pm

drsd wrote:
Skybox wrote:
drsd wrote:
I am nt sure I would take Bitadze out of the starting lineup now, for example.


Bitadze is “good enough”, can WCJ get us Brogdon or Simons? (Or similar?)


Why choose:
Brogdon AND Simons for Fultz, Carter, G-Harris, the Denver pick, two unprotected FRPs, and a future FRP pickswap.


Brogdon/Anthony/Black
Simons/Suggs/Howard
F-Wagner/Ingles/Houstan
Banchero/Isaac/Okeke
Bitadze/M-Wagner/some-dude

I like that starting five 200X over the Fultz/Suggs led starting five. If it costs Carter, so be it.
I could see that roster contending in 2024/25.


I love the outcome, but that's too many picks and too much depth, IMO...although I value picks lower than most (especially when we're getting better and we have ten children on our roster).
1)I'd be happy to send out more under contract talent (rather than bury them and less picks too) to still have some cap space.
2)Given our young guards' performance lately, I think I'd settle for Simons OR Brogdon, rather than overdo our makeover.
3)I'd rather send a pick than WCJ if at all possible, but moving him is kind of the point of the thread. He's worth a legit first, IMO.

Fultz and Carter for Simons (no picks) ...Fultz might be more enticing now that Scoot's out and Brogdon often misses some time

Fultz and Harris + DEN pick for Brogdon (might have to add worthless 2rps for them to publicly crow about picks)

Fultz, Harris, Carter, Houstan + ORL 24 frp for Simons and Brogdon (this one leads me to shop Cole next-just too many Guards)
...Cole and Chuma, DEN 25 frp to BRK for Claxton (knowing we'll pay him around $18m to keep-have to have a wink wink in place)

Simons/Black
Suggs/Brogdon/Jett...Guard lineups could be very different combos, but ALL are promising or proven
Franz/Ingles
Paolo/Isaac...If Isaac keeps healing, this is a nasty lineup...If not, waive and replace, M. Wagner also here along with SFs
Claxton/Goga/M. Wagner...guys like Kevon, Admiral, and Trevelin can fill in 3rd string (like they should)
Residual-Heat
Starter
Posts: 2,355
And1: 1,398
Joined: Feb 03, 2023
 

Re: Next fight...WCJ 

Post#28 » by Residual-Heat » Thu Nov 16, 2023 3:54 pm

Lets get a starting PG first and see what happens. No need to trade WCJ right now.
User avatar
JF5
RealGM
Posts: 12,192
And1: 4,159
Joined: Jul 23, 2010
Location: Disney World, Florida

Re: Next fight...WCJ 

Post#29 » by JF5 » Thu Nov 16, 2023 4:06 pm

There's really nothing wrong with Wendell. He's just always injured.
yoyojw17
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,809
And1: 3,441
Joined: Dec 26, 2011
Location: Gainesville,FL
 

Re: Next fight...WCJ 

Post#30 » by yoyojw17 » Thu Nov 16, 2023 4:23 pm

JF5 wrote:There's really nothing wrong with Wendell. He's just always injured.

Annnnnnd in this case... it's not knee or soft tissue issue. he got injured making a game winning play for the team in a freak situation. He had a slow start... kind of like franz and paolo... i'm good to wait.... especially at his contract and productivity.
User avatar
JF5
RealGM
Posts: 12,192
And1: 4,159
Joined: Jul 23, 2010
Location: Disney World, Florida

Re: Next fight...WCJ 

Post#31 » by JF5 » Thu Nov 16, 2023 5:12 pm

yoyojw17 wrote:
JF5 wrote:There's really nothing wrong with Wendell. He's just always injured.

Annnnnnd in this case... it's not knee or soft tissue issue. he got injured making a game winning play for the team in a freak situation. He had a slow start... kind of like franz and paolo... i'm good to wait.... especially at his contract and productivity.


On a fantastic contract... he's a good starting center who fits all the check boxes you want in a modern big. I'm trying to figure someone who isn't a star quality big that I would replace him with who are as young as he is. There is simply not too many guys like that.

Just seems like nitpicking. Like not every position you need a star player.
User avatar
JF5
RealGM
Posts: 12,192
And1: 4,159
Joined: Jul 23, 2010
Location: Disney World, Florida

Re: Next fight...WCJ 

Post#32 » by JF5 » Thu Nov 16, 2023 5:18 pm

drsd wrote:
Skybox wrote:
drsd wrote:
I am nt sure I would take Bitadze out of the starting lineup now, for example.


Bitadze is “good enough”, can WCJ get us Brogdon or Simons? (Or similar?)


Why choose:
Brogdon AND Simons for Fultz, Carter, G-Harris, the Denver pick, two unprotected FRPs, and a future FRP pickswap.


Brogdon/Anthony/Black
Simons/Suggs/Howard
F-Wagner/Ingles/Houstan
Banchero/Isaac/Okeke
Bitadze/M-Wagner/some-dude

I like that starting five 200X over the Fultz/Suggs led starting five. If it costs Carter, so be it.
I could see that roster contending in 2024/25.


So we trade for an older 30 year old injury prone guard in a guard centric league. Whilst trading away an versatile younger (yet injury prone big) big who is one of the better defensive/switching bigs who can stretch the floor in a league that covets such abilities since there are not too many of them.

On top of that you lose a lot of your defensive effectiveness due to Paolo and Franz being only decent to good defenders at best. Pair that with an aging/injury prone Brogdon and Simons who is a horrible defender. This wouldn't be a contending team IMO.

I don't understand trades like this.
basketballRob
RealGM
Posts: 36,250
And1: 14,202
Joined: May 05, 2014
     

Re: Next fight...WCJ 

Post#33 » by basketballRob » Thu Nov 16, 2023 5:32 pm

Delete
Residual-Heat
Starter
Posts: 2,355
And1: 1,398
Joined: Feb 03, 2023
 

Re: Next fight...WCJ 

Post#34 » by Residual-Heat » Thu Nov 16, 2023 5:42 pm

JF5 wrote:
drsd wrote:
Skybox wrote:
Bitadze is “good enough”, can WCJ get us Brogdon or Simons? (Or similar?)


Why choose:
Brogdon AND Simons for Fultz, Carter, G-Harris, the Denver pick, two unprotected FRPs, and a future FRP pickswap.


Brogdon/Anthony/Black
Simons/Suggs/Howard
F-Wagner/Ingles/Houstan
Banchero/Isaac/Okeke
Bitadze/M-Wagner/some-dude

I like that starting five 200X over the Fultz/Suggs led starting five. If it costs Carter, so be it.
I could see that roster contending in 2024/25.


So we trade for an older 30 year old injury prone guard in a guard centric league. Whilst trading away an versatile younger (yet injury prone big) big wh is one of the better defensive/switching bigs who can stretch the floor in a league that covets such abilities since there are not too many of them.

On top of that you're lose a lot of your defensive effectiveness due to Paolo and Franz being only decent to good defenders at best. Pair that with an aging/injury prone Brogdon and Simons who is a horrible defender. This wouldn't be a contending team IMO.

I don't understand trades like this.

and 3 picks, 2 of them unprotected, AND a pick swap. Just ridiculous.
yoyojw17
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,809
And1: 3,441
Joined: Dec 26, 2011
Location: Gainesville,FL
 

Re: Next fight...WCJ 

Post#35 » by yoyojw17 » Thu Nov 16, 2023 5:49 pm

Residual-Heat wrote:
JF5 wrote:
drsd wrote:
Why choose:
Brogdon AND Simons for Fultz, Carter, G-Harris, the Denver pick, two unprotected FRPs, and a future FRP pickswap.


Brogdon/Anthony/Black
Simons/Suggs/Howard
F-Wagner/Ingles/Houstan
Banchero/Isaac/Okeke
Bitadze/M-Wagner/some-dude

I like that starting five 200X over the Fultz/Suggs led starting five. If it costs Carter, so be it.
I could see that roster contending in 2024/25.


So we trade for an older 30 year old injury prone guard in a guard centric league. Whilst trading away an versatile younger (yet injury prone big) big wh is one of the better defensive/switching bigs who can stretch the floor in a league that covets such abilities since there are not too many of them.

On top of that you're lose a lot of your defensive effectiveness due to Paolo and Franz being only decent to good defenders at best. Pair that with an aging/injury prone Brogdon and Simons who is a horrible defender. This wouldn't be a contending team IMO.

I don't understand trades like this.

and 3 picks, 2 of them unprotected, AND a pick swap. Just ridiculous.

yeah... haaaaard pass!!
jonbob17
Analyst
Posts: 3,481
And1: 1,440
Joined: Jul 01, 2020

Re: Next fight...WCJ 

Post#36 » by jonbob17 » Thu Nov 16, 2023 8:18 pm

Well he has been absolutely horrible so far this year at just about everything, so it's kind of hard to judge how he fits in with current version of the team.

I'd argue he is rated appropriately on defense. He's a good defender in terms of positioning himself, can switch a little bit, but he's not a rim protector, so i doubt he impacts opponent's FG% in the paint.

Once again he's hurt. This is 6th season and he's lasted over 60 games once with 62. There are some COVID years baked in there but still.

If he's a long term keeper for this team I want him taking and making 3s at over 36%. If he's not spacing the floor, I'd rather have a big that is protecting the paint and cleaning up on any over-aggresiveness by our perimeter players. Shooting 3s with his positional defense, rebounds pretty well for his size, decent passer for a big, is a helpful player.

Look WCJ's a good player but if we got offered something interesting for him...sure explore... I mean he's getting paid back up center money, so it is all relative, if this about what his peak looks like, and he wants top 15 starter money, which is probably like $28M a year or so when is contract comes due...that might be a different conversation, because we should be looking at who is the perfect fit next to Paolo at that point....and i am not sure what Paolo will look like in 2.5 years.

WCJ is currently the 17th highest paid center...there are worse older guys paid more and better younger guys paid less...21st based on average salary. I'd say he is probably a top 17-20 center in this league...there are quite a few young centers that look pretty good. I guess if WCJ still can't shoot I'd rather pay one of these young guys a contract something like Poeltl got this offseason. Give me a guy who is going to score 12 points a game on 65%+ from the field. Make guys shots harder in the lane. Maybe we can find the next Kristaps to play next to Paolo in 3 years....i don't know...i also expect Paolo to be making shots by then.
RichCollab
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,317
And1: 1,401
Joined: Oct 23, 2019
         

Re: Next fight...WCJ 

Post#37 » by RichCollab » Thu Nov 16, 2023 8:51 pm

jonbob17 wrote:Well he has been absolutely horrible so far this year at just about everything, so it's kind of hard to judge how he fits in with current version of the team.

I'd argue he is rated appropriately on defense. He's a good defender in terms of positioning himself, can switch a little bit, but he's not a rim protector, so i doubt he impacts opponent's FG% in the paint.

Once again he's hurt. This is 6th season and he's lasted over 60 games once with 62. There are some COVID years baked in there but still.

If he's a long term keeper for this team I want him taking and making 3s at over 36%. If he's not spacing the floor, I'd rather have a big that is protecting the paint and cleaning up on any over-aggresiveness by our perimeter players. Shooting 3s with his positional defense, rebounds pretty well for his size, decent passer for a big, is a helpful player.

Look WCJ's a good player but if we got offered something interesting for him...sure explore... I mean he's getting paid back up center money, so it is all relative, if this about what his peak looks like, and he wants top 15 starter money, which is probably like $28M a year or so when is contract comes due...that might be a different conversation, because we should be looking at who is the perfect fit next to Paolo at that point....and i am not sure what Paolo will look like in 2.5 years.

WCJ is currently the 17th highest paid center...there are worse older guys paid more and better younger guys paid less...21st based on average salary. I'd say he is probably a top 17-20 center in this league...there are quite a few young centers that look pretty good. I guess if WCJ still can't shoot I'd rather pay one of these young guys a contract something like Poeltl got this offseason. Give me a guy who is going to score 12 points a game on 65%+ from the field. Make guys shots harder in the lane. Maybe we can find the next Kristaps to play next to Paolo in 3 years....i don't know...i also expect Paolo to be making shots by then.



I’m not worried about WCJ’s start. I’m not sure that even merits being part of the conversation.
Skybox
RealGM
Posts: 18,354
And1: 8,421
Joined: Jan 21, 2017
 

Re: Next fight...WCJ 

Post#38 » by Skybox » Fri Nov 17, 2023 2:00 am

RichCollab wrote:
jonbob17 wrote:Well he has been absolutely horrible so far this year at just about everything, so it's kind of hard to judge how he fits in with current version of the team.

I'd argue he is rated appropriately on defense. He's a good defender in terms of positioning himself, can switch a little bit, but he's not a rim protector, so i doubt he impacts opponent's FG% in the paint.

Once again he's hurt. This is 6th season and he's lasted over 60 games once with 62. There are some COVID years baked in there but still.

If he's a long term keeper for this team I want him taking and making 3s at over 36%. If he's not spacing the floor, I'd rather have a big that is protecting the paint and cleaning up on any over-aggresiveness by our perimeter players. Shooting 3s with his positional defense, rebounds pretty well for his size, decent passer for a big, is a helpful player.

Look WCJ's a good player but if we got offered something interesting for him...sure explore... I mean he's getting paid back up center money, so it is all relative, if this about what his peak looks like, and he wants top 15 starter money, which is probably like $28M a year or so when is contract comes due...that might be a different conversation, because we should be looking at who is the perfect fit next to Paolo at that point....and i am not sure what Paolo will look like in 2.5 years.

WCJ is currently the 17th highest paid center...there are worse older guys paid more and better younger guys paid less...21st based on average salary. I'd say he is probably a top 17-20 center in this league...there are quite a few young centers that look pretty good. I guess if WCJ still can't shoot I'd rather pay one of these young guys a contract something like Poeltl got this offseason. Give me a guy who is going to score 12 points a game on 65%+ from the field. Make guys shots harder in the lane. Maybe we can find the next Kristaps to play next to Paolo in 3 years....i don't know...i also expect Paolo to be making shots by then.



I’m not worried about WCJ’s start. I’m not sure that even merits being part of the conversation.


I agree...I'm not even pondering the concept that WCJ isn't a good player...just what's the right move

Return to Orlando Magic