ImageImageImageImage

Official Spec Thread: Heart and Hustle Magic 2.0

Moderators: UCF, Knightro, UCFJayBird, Def Swami, Howard Mass, ChosenSavior

The Effect
Magic Forum Mock Draft Co-Champ
Posts: 4,890
And1: 2,119
Joined: Jul 09, 2004

Re: Official Spec Thread: Heart and Hustle Magic 2.0 

Post#1161 » by The Effect » Mon Dec 6, 2021 10:19 pm

Bulls2021 wrote:I made a Patrick Williams trade thread in the trades and transactions forum, and a magic fan suggested Isaac as a centerpiece for PWill. Bulls need interior defense and athleticism. Obviously both guys are coming off big injures. Does a trade revolving around PWill and Coby White make sense for Orlando? PWill can play SF and PF. May be a prototypical PF in the future though.

Just spitballing here. It would obviously be tough with 2 guys coming off major injuries. Sounds like the Magic have a logjam at PF/C though.

Id do that

get out of Isaac's contract and constant worry about if hes gonna be healthy and get a defensive SF with a ton of potential, and a good backup PG.. Cant ask for more for an always injured player
User avatar
SOUL
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 58,985
And1: 40,914
Joined: Dec 11, 2006
Location: Orl★ndo
     

Re: Official Spec Thread: Heart and Hustle Magic 2.0 

Post#1162 » by SOUL » Mon Dec 6, 2021 10:20 pm

The Effect wrote:get out of Isaac's contract and constant worry about if hes gonna be healthy and get a defensive SF with a ton of potential, and a good backup PG.. Cant ask for more for an always injured player


Patrick Williams will be playing less games in his first two years than Isaac
www.rareslums.com // please support my writing!
Bulls2021
Pro Prospect
Posts: 880
And1: 544
Joined: Nov 13, 2021

Re: Official Spec Thread: Heart and Hustle Magic 2.0 

Post#1163 » by Bulls2021 » Mon Dec 6, 2021 10:20 pm

The Effect wrote:
Bulls2021 wrote:I made a Patrick Williams trade thread in the trades and transactions forum, and a magic fan suggested Isaac as a centerpiece for PWill. Bulls need interior defense and athleticism. Obviously both guys are coming off big injures. Does a trade revolving around PWill and Coby White make sense for Orlando? PWill can play SF and PF. May be a prototypical PF in the future though.

Just spitballing here. It would obviously be tough with 2 guys coming off major injuries. Sounds like the Magic have a logjam at PF/C though.

Id do that

get out of Isaac's contract and constant worry about if hes gonna be healthy and get a defensive SF with a ton of potential, and a good backup PG.. Cant ask for more for an always injured player

Him being antivax probably kills all hope, though. Tough trying to compete when you can't use him at NYC or Golden State.
User avatar
SOUL
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 58,985
And1: 40,914
Joined: Dec 11, 2006
Location: Orl★ndo
     

Re: Official Spec Thread: Heart and Hustle Magic 2.0 

Post#1164 » by SOUL » Mon Dec 6, 2021 10:22 pm

Bulls2021 wrote:Him being antivax probably kills all hope, though. Tough trying to compete when you can't use him at NYC or Golden State.


Those are team specific rules, ie if he was on the Nets or GS.
www.rareslums.com // please support my writing!
Bulls2021
Pro Prospect
Posts: 880
And1: 544
Joined: Nov 13, 2021

Re: Official Spec Thread: Heart and Hustle Magic 2.0 

Post#1165 » by Bulls2021 » Mon Dec 6, 2021 10:24 pm

SOUL wrote:
Bulls2021 wrote:Him being antivax probably kills all hope, though. Tough trying to compete when you can't use him at NYC or Golden State.


Those are team specific rules, ie if he was on the Nets or GS.

Ahhh ok, thanks for the heads up. I thought those were city mandates.
The Effect
Magic Forum Mock Draft Co-Champ
Posts: 4,890
And1: 2,119
Joined: Jul 09, 2004

Re: Official Spec Thread: Heart and Hustle Magic 2.0 

Post#1166 » by The Effect » Mon Dec 6, 2021 11:48 pm

SOUL wrote:
The Effect wrote:get out of Isaac's contract and constant worry about if hes gonna be healthy and get a defensive SF with a ton of potential, and a good backup PG.. Cant ask for more for an always injured player


Patrick Williams will be playing less games in his first two years than Isaac


Ok, and?
He played in all but 1 game last year and this year he got hurt in the first week
When he misses 60% of his games over a 5 year span (and counting), then ill worry about it

Also, 7 footers with a history of leg and feet problems are a bigger worry than a 6'6/6'7 guy with one freak injury

oh, not to mention one is on a rookie contract, the other is locked in to a 17m a year deal til 2025
orlando_joe
Lead Assistant
Posts: 4,899
And1: 1,913
Joined: Dec 27, 2015
     

Re: Official Spec Thread: Heart and Hustle Magic 2.0 

Post#1167 » by orlando_joe » Tue Dec 7, 2021 12:02 am

The Effect wrote:
Bulls2021 wrote:I made a Patrick Williams trade thread in the trades and transactions forum, and a magic fan suggested Isaac as a centerpiece for PWill. Bulls need interior defense and athleticism. Obviously both guys are coming off big injures. Does a trade revolving around PWill and Coby White make sense for Orlando? PWill can play SF and PF. May be a prototypical PF in the future though.

Just spitballing here. It would obviously be tough with 2 guys coming off major injuries. Sounds like the Magic have a logjam at PF/C though.

Id do that

get out of Isaac's contract and constant worry about if hes gonna be healthy and get a defensive SF with a ton of potential, and a good backup PG.. Cant ask for more for an always injured player

magic have a defensive sf with potential his name is franz...and backup pg...i think ji would be on court right now if magic never did trades.at this point in rebuild it helps he is not playing...have him playing for last 25-30 games this yr who cares? and then even keep him on 20 min restriction ..would let that knee get stronger and stronger...and if he looks good after 10 games might even shut him down for yr to keep pick at better odds ..just claim knee soreness..
The Effect
Magic Forum Mock Draft Co-Champ
Posts: 4,890
And1: 2,119
Joined: Jul 09, 2004

Re: Official Spec Thread: Heart and Hustle Magic 2.0 

Post#1168 » by The Effect » Tue Dec 7, 2021 12:22 am

orlando_joe wrote:
The Effect wrote:
Bulls2021 wrote:I made a Patrick Williams trade thread in the trades and transactions forum, and a magic fan suggested Isaac as a centerpiece for PWill. Bulls need interior defense and athleticism. Obviously both guys are coming off big injures. Does a trade revolving around PWill and Coby White make sense for Orlando? PWill can play SF and PF. May be a prototypical PF in the future though.

Just spitballing here. It would obviously be tough with 2 guys coming off major injuries. Sounds like the Magic have a logjam at PF/C though.

Id do that

get out of Isaac's contract and constant worry about if hes gonna be healthy and get a defensive SF with a ton of potential, and a good backup PG.. Cant ask for more for an always injured player

magic have a defensive sf with potential his name is franz...and backup pg...i think ji would be on court right now if magic never did trades.at this point in rebuild it helps he is not playing...have him playing for last 25-30 games this yr who cares? and then even keep him on 20 min restriction ..would let that knee get stronger and stronger...and if he looks good after 10 games might even shut him down for yr to keep pick at better odds ..just claim knee soreness..


I think Franz is a PF in time. Hes already in the 6'9-6'10 range and is still barely 20 years old. Theres a chance hes still growing. Also hes just down starting to work on his body. I think he mentioned that he took workout more seriously during covid and got bigger

Wouldnt surprise me if hes 6'10-6'11 240 in a couple years and moves to PF in the same way that Isaac did

As for backup PG, i dont know, i see cole and Suggs being the long term 1-2 so the backup would be whom? fultz? maybe RJ? I dont know, but wouldnt mind having Coby in that mix
orlando_joe
Lead Assistant
Posts: 4,899
And1: 1,913
Joined: Dec 27, 2015
     

Re: Official Spec Thread: Heart and Hustle Magic 2.0 

Post#1169 » by orlando_joe » Tue Dec 7, 2021 12:52 am

The Effect wrote:
orlando_joe wrote:
The Effect wrote:Id do that

get out of Isaac's contract and constant worry about if hes gonna be healthy and get a defensive SF with a ton of potential, and a good backup PG.. Cant ask for more for an always injured player

magic have a defensive sf with potential his name is franz...and backup pg...i think ji would be on court right now if magic never did trades.at this point in rebuild it helps he is not playing...have him playing for last 25-30 games this yr who cares? and then even keep him on 20 min restriction ..would let that knee get stronger and stronger...and if he looks good after 10 games might even shut him down for yr to keep pick at better odds ..just claim knee soreness..


I think Franz is a PF in time. Hes already in the 6'9-6'10 range and is still barely 20 years old. Theres a chance hes still growing. Also hes just down starting to work on his body. I think he mentioned that he took workout more seriously during covid and got bigger

Wouldnt surprise me if hes 6'10-6'11 240 in a couple years and moves to PF in the same way that Isaac did

As for backup PG, i dont know, i see cole and Suggs being the long term 1-2 so the backup would be whom? fultz? maybe RJ? I dont know, but wouldnt mind having Coby in that mix

we see things different i keep franz at sf ......not sure why you would think you can keep white at backup pg..how much you think he wants after next season to keep him? or is it just next yr ..when it still wont matter..i would not trade any of magic players on rookie deal or ji just yet have this yr and really next yr to figure it out then make moves..and sure not for unknowns..like can ji stay healthy ...can williams stay healthy what has he really shown when he was? potential ? i keep ji if thats what going on ji has more for me
The Effect
Magic Forum Mock Draft Co-Champ
Posts: 4,890
And1: 2,119
Joined: Jul 09, 2004

Re: Official Spec Thread: Heart and Hustle Magic 2.0 

Post#1170 » by The Effect » Tue Dec 7, 2021 2:06 am

orlando_joe wrote:
The Effect wrote:
orlando_joe wrote:magic have a defensive sf with potential his name is franz...and backup pg...i think ji would be on court right now if magic never did trades.at this point in rebuild it helps he is not playing...have him playing for last 25-30 games this yr who cares? and then even keep him on 20 min restriction ..would let that knee get stronger and stronger...and if he looks good after 10 games might even shut him down for yr to keep pick at better odds ..just claim knee soreness..


I think Franz is a PF in time. Hes already in the 6'9-6'10 range and is still barely 20 years old. Theres a chance hes still growing. Also hes just down starting to work on his body. I think he mentioned that he took workout more seriously during covid and got bigger

Wouldnt surprise me if hes 6'10-6'11 240 in a couple years and moves to PF in the same way that Isaac did

As for backup PG, i dont know, i see cole and Suggs being the long term 1-2 so the backup would be whom? fultz? maybe RJ? I dont know, but wouldnt mind having Coby in that mix

we see things different i keep franz at sf ......not sure why you would think you can keep white at backup pg..how much you think he wants after next season to keep him? or is it just next yr ..when it still wont matter..i would not trade any of magic players on rookie deal or ji just yet have this yr and really next yr to figure it out then make moves..and sure not for unknowns..like can ji stay healthy ...can williams stay healthy what has he really shown when he was? potential ? i keep ji if thats what going on ji has more for me


Its more about creating competition at the most important spot
And yeah, honestly i dont think he would be able to beat out Cole so for me he would stay a backup until he left, and im Ok with that because Coby would be a throw-in to me. If he pans out, awesome, if he wants, fine

Ive stated before that i dont see Isaac as a part of our future, for many reasons with the injuries being at the top of the list, and so to me, this would be a way to get out of his deal 3 years early and get a top 5 pick (who fits our defensive minded mentality) out of the deal. Anything else (coby?) would just be a bonus
pepe1991
RealGM
Posts: 23,269
And1: 19,349
Joined: Jan 10, 2016
   

Re: Official Spec Thread: Heart and Hustle Magic 2.0 

Post#1171 » by pepe1991 » Tue Dec 7, 2021 7:04 am

Xatticus wrote:
Def Swami wrote:
pepe1991 wrote:in Brown trade Magic should offer just about everything but Stuff.

And the Celtics would still say no. These talks are crazy.


Of course they would say no, but it isn't really about value. Brown just isn't that good. Boston has been a .500 team since Hayward departed. Brown is a nice player, but he doesn't really move the needle. I could certainly see Boston wanting to make significant changes. The issue is that Brown could be the key piece in a package for a disgruntled star should one hit the market.


I don't know about that. I think Brown can be top 20-15-ish nba player once removed from Tatum.

I think they both are far too similar, occupy same spots and take similar shots and that's core issue with Celtics.
Right now, and it was similar in past, Tatum, Brown and whoever is third option averages around 55 out of 90 team shots. i think under that conditions rest of a team simply loses interest to play hard defense given they are being treated like extras on offence who hardly touch the ball. Robert and Grant Williams average less than 10 shots a game combined.

Other issue, imo, is PG play, and lack of bench production. They fill bench with very young and green players, they don't have starting level PG since IT ( Irving was more of a shooter, Walker was shell of former self, Schroder is like coin flip ) and they for sure have no bench PG. But again, that goes back to Brown- Tatum issue in dynamic. They fill no bench because they don't have salary and even if they did, they still use "bench" by sitting one of them and allowing other to take all the shots.

Wade- Lebron dynamic had same issues but they were just so overstacked with talent and worked (but kind a underachived).
George- Kawhi dynamic has same issues.

If you look at type of plays they recive, you will soon figure Brown is more effective than Tatum in just about everything. But Tatum still averages 5 more shots to climb 3 points more. Tatum leads league in isolation plays but is complete mess from it ( 40% EFG), Tatum leads them in most shots off screen, but is also mess from there, Tatum leads them in usage and raw shots taken. Brown does just about everything much better...but in hierarchy is lower because...ego of Tatum ... or coaching... or having no actual leader. IF Celtics made CP3 trade they would probably be defending champions right now. Instad, they always feel like team without actual leader and without actual center.

I don't watch them more than 10-15-20 times a year but have some Celtic fans among friends and most of them b*** and moan how in every playoff series their team looks like midget squad. If you look back, Kyrie Irving averaged more rebounds in that series than any Celtics player but T. Thompson :dontknow:

Regardless, at least imo, Brown will probably be traded once, and guy will look amazing in team with better structure and less Tatum's -ego-centric offence.
Life is what happens when you're busy making other plans. -John Lennon
User avatar
drsd
RealGM
Posts: 39,183
And1: 8,946
Joined: Mar 16, 2003
     

Re: Official Spec Thread: Heart and Hustle Magic 2.0 

Post#1172 » by drsd » Tue Dec 7, 2021 9:23 am

pepe1991 wrote:I think Brown can be top 20-15-ish nba player once removed from Tatum.

I think they both are far too similar, occupy same spots and take similar shots and that's core issue with Celtics.
Right now, and it was similar in past, Tatum, Brown and whoever is third option averages around 55 out of 90 team shots. i think under that conditions rest of a team simply loses interest to play hard defense given they are being treated like extras on offence who hardly touch the ball. Robert and Grant Williams average less than 10 shots a game combined.

Other issue, imo, is PG play, and lack of bench production. They fill bench with very young and green players, they don't have starting level PG since IT ( Irving was more of a shooter, Walker was shell of former self, Schroder is like coin flip ) and they for sure have no bench PG. But again, that goes back to Brown- Tatum issue in dynamic. They fill no bench because they don't have salary and even if they did, they still use "bench" by sitting one of them and allowing other to take all the shots.

Wade- Lebron dynamic had same issues but they were just so overstacked with talent and worked (but kind a underachived).
George- Kawhi dynamic has same issues.

If you look at type of plays they recive, you will soon figure Brown is more effective than Tatum in just about everything. But Tatum still averages 5 more shots to climb 3 points more. Tatum leads league in isolation plays but is complete mess from it ( 40% EFG), Tatum leads them in most shots off screen, but is also mess from there, Tatum leads them in usage and raw shots taken. Brown does just about everything much better...but in hierarchy is lower because...ego of Tatum ... or coaching... or having no actual leader. IF Celtics made CP3 trade they would probably be defending champions right now. Instad, they always feel like team without actual leader and without actual center.

I don't watch them more than 10-15-20 times a year but have some Celtic fans among friends and most of them b*** and moan how in every playoff series their team looks like midget squad. If you look back, Kyrie Irving averaged more rebounds in that series than any Celtics player but T. Thompson :dontknow:

Regardless, at least imo, Brown will probably be traded once, and guy will look amazing in team with better structure and less Tatum's -ego-centric offence.




So are you a fan of Orlando's FRP, Okeke, Anthony, Harris, the Denver, and the Bulls pick for Brown and filler?



..
Skybox
RealGM
Posts: 18,487
And1: 8,468
Joined: Jan 21, 2017
 

Re: Official Spec Thread: Heart and Hustle Magic 2.0 

Post#1173 » by Skybox » Tue Dec 7, 2021 12:46 pm

drsd wrote:
pepe1991 wrote:I think Brown can be top 20-15-ish nba player once removed from Tatum.

I think they both are far too similar, occupy same spots and take similar shots and that's core issue with Celtics.
Right now, and it was similar in past, Tatum, Brown and whoever is third option averages around 55 out of 90 team shots. i think under that conditions rest of a team simply loses interest to play hard defense given they are being treated like extras on offence who hardly touch the ball. Robert and Grant Williams average less than 10 shots a game combined.

Other issue, imo, is PG play, and lack of bench production. They fill bench with very young and green players, they don't have starting level PG since IT ( Irving was more of a shooter, Walker was shell of former self, Schroder is like coin flip ) and they for sure have no bench PG. But again, that goes back to Brown- Tatum issue in dynamic. They fill no bench because they don't have salary and even if they did, they still use "bench" by sitting one of them and allowing other to take all the shots.

Wade- Lebron dynamic had same issues but they were just so overstacked with talent and worked (but kind a underachived).
George- Kawhi dynamic has same issues.

If you look at type of plays they recive, you will soon figure Brown is more effective than Tatum in just about everything. But Tatum still averages 5 more shots to climb 3 points more. Tatum leads league in isolation plays but is complete mess from it ( 40% EFG), Tatum leads them in most shots off screen, but is also mess from there, Tatum leads them in usage and raw shots taken. Brown does just about everything much better...but in hierarchy is lower because...ego of Tatum ... or coaching... or having no actual leader. IF Celtics made CP3 trade they would probably be defending champions right now. Instad, they always feel like team without actual leader and without actual center.

I don't watch them more than 10-15-20 times a year but have some Celtic fans among friends and most of them b*** and moan how in every playoff series their team looks like midget squad. If you look back, Kyrie Irving averaged more rebounds in that series than any Celtics player but T. Thompson :dontknow:

Regardless, at least imo, Brown will probably be traded once, and guy will look amazing in team with better structure and less Tatum's -ego-centric offence.


In a heartbeat...I'm amazed at how willing fans are to throw away season after season in a quest for just a chance to draft a guy who might, if the stars align, just might be anywhere near as good as we know Brown is...but have to really think hard about losing Cole and Okeke to do it



So are you a fan of Orlando's FRP, Okeke, Anthony, Harris, the Denver, and the Bulls pick for Brown and filler?



..
basketballRob
RealGM
Posts: 37,300
And1: 14,944
Joined: May 05, 2014
     

Re: Official Spec Thread: Heart and Hustle Magic 2.0 

Post#1174 » by basketballRob » Tue Dec 7, 2021 1:09 pm

drsd wrote:
pepe1991 wrote:I think Brown can be top 20-15-ish nba player once removed from Tatum.

I think they both are far too similar, occupy same spots and take similar shots and that's core issue with Celtics.
Right now, and it was similar in past, Tatum, Brown and whoever is third option averages around 55 out of 90 team shots. i think under that conditions rest of a team simply loses interest to play hard defense given they are being treated like extras on offence who hardly touch the ball. Robert and Grant Williams average less than 10 shots a game combined.

Other issue, imo, is PG play, and lack of bench production. They fill bench with very young and green players, they don't have starting level PG since IT ( Irving was more of a shooter, Walker was shell of former self, Schroder is like coin flip ) and they for sure have no bench PG. But again, that goes back to Brown- Tatum issue in dynamic. They fill no bench because they don't have salary and even if they did, they still use "bench" by sitting one of them and allowing other to take all the shots.

Wade- Lebron dynamic had same issues but they were just so overstacked with talent and worked (but kind a underachived).
George- Kawhi dynamic has same issues.

If you look at type of plays they recive, you will soon figure Brown is more effective than Tatum in just about everything. But Tatum still averages 5 more shots to climb 3 points more. Tatum leads league in isolation plays but is complete mess from it ( 40% EFG), Tatum leads them in most shots off screen, but is also mess from there, Tatum leads them in usage and raw shots taken. Brown does just about everything much better...but in hierarchy is lower because...ego of Tatum ... or coaching... or having no actual leader. IF Celtics made CP3 trade they would probably be defending champions right now. Instad, they always feel like team without actual leader and without actual center.

I don't watch them more than 10-15-20 times a year but have some Celtic fans among friends and most of them b*** and moan how in every playoff series their team looks like midget squad. If you look back, Kyrie Irving averaged more rebounds in that series than any Celtics player but T. Thompson :dontknow:

Regardless, at least imo, Brown will probably be traded once, and guy will look amazing in team with better structure and less Tatum's -ego-centric offence.




So are you a fan of Orlando's FRP, Okeke, Anthony, Harris, the Denver, and the Bulls pick for Brown and filler?



..
I'd do that. Brown can play SG and has a 7' wingspan. A lineup of Suggs, Brown, Franz, Isaac, and WCJ would have so much length. Plus add a top 5 pick next season.

Sent from my SM-G950U using RealGM mobile app
User avatar
Knightro
Forum Mod - Magic
Forum Mod - Magic
Posts: 28,559
And1: 29,660
Joined: Dec 18, 2010
Location: Jersey
 

Re: Official Spec Thread: Heart and Hustle Magic 2.0 

Post#1175 » by Knightro » Tue Dec 7, 2021 2:24 pm

drsd wrote:So are you a fan of Orlando's FRP, Okeke, Anthony, Harris, the Denver, and the Bulls pick for Brown and filler?


Look... Jaylen Brown is a good player and would make the Magic better, but we have to ask ourselves how much better?

Does adding Brown to this Orlando roster (and subtracting the three rotation players you'd be sending out plus the three first round picks you'd be sending out) even put this team in the playoffs?

Suggs/Brown/Wagner/Carter/Bamba would be the starting lineup. With Ross, Fultz, Isaac (at some point) as the primary pieces off the bench. What is that lineup winning? 35 games? 40 games max?

But you'd also have no first round pick in 2022 and you wouldn't have max cap space. Plus you'd have Bamba a free agent to be with no tangible way to replace him either, so the odds of resigning him would go up.

I get people don't enjoy losing and I get that adding more young players to this mix isn't going to immediately make the team better, but there's no tangible benefit to rushing to try and get back to respectability as quickly as possible either.

Like it or not, the Magic need to add more high end lottery talent, maintain their cap flexibility, and *then* when they have 2-3 young guys they feel really great about as the start of a core, then they can start adding veteran pieces via trades and free agency.

That's what the Hawks did. They drafted Young, Collins, Reddish, Huerter and Hunter and then when the time was right they were aggressive and acquired Bogdanović and Capela and Gallinari to supplement their young core.

Cavs same thing. Drafted Garland and Mobley and Okoro and then when the time was right supplemented their young core with veterans like Rubio and young guys entering their prime like Allen and Markkanen.

The Magic just aren't there yet.
User avatar
drsd
RealGM
Posts: 39,183
And1: 8,946
Joined: Mar 16, 2003
     

Re: Official Spec Thread: Heart and Hustle Magic 2.0 

Post#1176 » by drsd » Tue Dec 7, 2021 2:48 pm

Knightro wrote:
drsd wrote:So are you a fan of Orlando's FRP, Okeke, Anthony, Harris, the Denver, and the Bulls pick for Brown and filler?


Look... Jaylen Brown is a very good player and would make the Magic better, but we have to ask ourselves how much better?

Does adding Brown to this Orlando roster (and subtracting the three rotation players you'd be sending out plus the three first round picks you'd be sending out) even put this team in the playoffs?

Suggs/Brown/Wagner/Carter/Bamba would be the starting lineup. With Ross, Fultz, Isaac (at some point) as the primary pieces off the bench. What is that lineup winning? 35 games? 40 games max?

But you'd also have no first round pick in 2022 and you wouldn't have max cap space. Plus you'd have Bamba a free agent to be with no tangible way to replace him either, so the odds of resigning him would go up.

I get people don't enjoy losing and I get that adding more young players to this mix isn't going to immediately make the team better, but there's no tangible benefit to rushing to try and get back to respectability as quickly as possible either.

Like it or not, the Magic need to add more high end lottery talent, maintain their cap flexibility, and *then* when they have 2-3 young guys they feel really great about as the start of a core, then they can start adding veteran pieces via trades and free agency.

That's what the Hawks did. They drafted Young, Collins, Reddish, Huerter and Hunter and then when the time was right they were aggressive and acquired Bogdanović and Capela and Gallinari to supplement their young core.

Cavs same thing. Drafted Garland and Mobley and Okoro and then when the time was right supplemented their young core with veterans like Rubio and young guys entering their prime like Allen and Markkanen.

The Magic just aren't there yet.



I do not agree with the outcome, but this is a very strong view of this roster.

For me, this depth chart can rise to mediocrity in 2022/23:
Suggs/Fultz
Brown/Hampton
F-Wagner/Ross
Isaac/M-Wagner
Carter/Bamba

And then where this leads to 2023, I think there is hope.


..
User avatar
Knightro
Forum Mod - Magic
Forum Mod - Magic
Posts: 28,559
And1: 29,660
Joined: Dec 18, 2010
Location: Jersey
 

Re: Official Spec Thread: Heart and Hustle Magic 2.0 

Post#1177 » by Knightro » Tue Dec 7, 2021 2:55 pm

drsd wrote:I do not agree with the outcome, but this is a very strong view of this roster.

For me, this depth chart can rise to mediocrity in 2022/23:
Suggs/Fultz
Brown/Hampton
F-Wagner/Ross
Isaac/M-Wagner
Carter/Bamba

And then where this leads to 2023, I think there is hope.


That roster is barely a playoff roster or not even a playoff roster at all IMO.

Throw in the fact that Brown's making almost 30M and you'd have to resign Bamba for this 22/23 scenario to be real and you'd have no real cap space.

Like where's the upside there?

A decent, but ultimately not great roster with 6 of the top 9 guys already off their rookie contracts.
Skybox
RealGM
Posts: 18,487
And1: 8,468
Joined: Jan 21, 2017
 

Re: Official Spec Thread: Heart and Hustle Magic 2.0 

Post#1178 » by Skybox » Tue Dec 7, 2021 4:11 pm

Knightro wrote:
drsd wrote:So are you a fan of Orlando's FRP, Okeke, Anthony, Harris, the Denver, and the Bulls pick for Brown and filler?


Look... Jaylen Brown is a good player and would make the Magic better, but we have to ask ourselves how much better?

Does adding Brown to this Orlando roster (and subtracting the three rotation players you'd be sending out plus the three first round picks you'd be sending out) even put this team in the playoffs?

Suggs/Brown/Wagner/Carter/Bamba would be the starting lineup. With Ross, Fultz, Isaac (at some point) as the primary pieces off the bench. What is that lineup winning? 35 games? 40 games max?

But you'd also have no first round pick in 2022 and you wouldn't have max cap space. Plus you'd have Bamba a free agent to be with no tangible way to replace him either, so the odds of resigning him would go up.

I get people don't enjoy losing and I get that adding more young players to this mix isn't going to immediately make the team better, but there's no tangible benefit to rushing to try and get back to respectability as quickly as possible either.

Like it or not, the Magic need to add more high end lottery talent, maintain their cap flexibility, and *then* when they have 2-3 young guys they feel really great about as the start of a core, then they can start adding veteran pieces via trades and free agency.

That's what the Hawks did. They drafted Young, Collins, Reddish, Huerter and Hunter and then when the time was right they were aggressive and acquired Bogdanović and Capela and Gallinari to supplement their young core.

Cavs same thing. Drafted Garland and Mobley and Okoro and then when the time was right supplemented their young core with veterans like Rubio and young guys entering their prime like Allen and Markkanen.

The Magic just aren't there yet.


-Jaylen Brown is more than a GOOD player. Getting a guy like him is less common than selecting well, even if guaranteed #1
-Making a big step better does not mean we can't continue getting better. His salary matters, but not fatally.
-I would not give up 3 draft picks except for the fact that we have two to burn from those trades...and IF we only get to 35 wins, our own picks will still be in the lotto in '23...
-Not having max cap space isn't that big a deal. Who were you going to sign? Certainly no-one approaching Jaylen Brown's significance.
-Our roster is already overflowing with "high end lottery talent"...for whatever that's worth...more accurately "picks" not talent (as one does not ever come close to guaranteeing the other). ATL scored with their star in Trae...the others are supporting actors-even Collins with his 20/10 numbers. I think we have guys already here that are (at least potentially) in the same stratosphere of value of any of those guys other than Trae.

*Given the volume of outgoing pieces, I'd ask for Nesmith to be thrown in as a project.
pepe1991
RealGM
Posts: 23,269
And1: 19,349
Joined: Jan 10, 2016
   

Re: Official Spec Thread: Heart and Hustle Magic 2.0 

Post#1179 » by pepe1991 » Tue Dec 7, 2021 7:41 pm

Image

You guys just undersell how good Brown actually is. Odds are, you won't draft player that by age of 25 is capable of being effective 25ppg player and not suck on defense and in same time capable of playing off ball as well.
Life is what happens when you're busy making other plans. -John Lennon
basketballRob
RealGM
Posts: 37,300
And1: 14,944
Joined: May 05, 2014
     

Re: Official Spec Thread: Heart and Hustle Magic 2.0 

Post#1180 » by basketballRob » Tue Dec 7, 2021 8:06 pm

I wouldn't include a top 5 pick for him.

Sent from my SM-G950U using RealGM mobile app

Return to Orlando Magic