Hollinger at The Athletic is posting his preseason predictions, and today he posted the 5 teams most likely to fall short of expectations as measured by Vegas Over/Unders on wins. Guess who made the list? Now I know we are up and coming because there is value in calling us overrated.
The 5 he predicted fall short are the Suns, Kings, Thunder, Magic and Bulls. His overachievers are the Raptors, Grizzlies, Nets, Rockets, and Hornets. Again this is based on Vegas expectations, not overall quality.
Also did NOT appreciate the gratuitous dig at the Jett Howard selection
Article LinkOrlando Magic (under 36.5 wins)
I find it almost inconceivable that over/unders project Orlando to have as many or more wins as Toronto next season. I don’t see any way the Magic will score enough points to realistically win nearly half their games, even with the FIBA World Champion Wunderbrothers on their side.
For starters, Orlando’s narrative from last season is pretty solid: Despite being a very young team, the Magic went 29-28 in their final 57 games after a brutal 5-20 start. They might have snagged one or two more wins in the final week if not for the realization that those were must-lose games for their draft lottery hopes; the Magic ended up “beating” Washington and Indiana by a single game in the reverse standings.
Defensively, Orlando has a strong case to be playoff-caliber. If Jonathan Isaac comes back (yeah, I know, but hear me out) and is anything close to his former self, this could be a top-10 outfit on that end. While they were helped by some Jedi 3-point defense last season, Orlando also had a huge possession advantage by forcing turnovers (eighth) and owning the defensive boards (third), and that part should carry over. Guards like Markelle Fultz, Jalen Suggs and rookie Anthony Black are harassing pests at the point of attack, while none of Orlando’s core pieces are a minus on that end except Cole Anthony.
Now … about the offense. The Magic can feel optimistic about their future because they have two very young forwards in Paolo Banchero and Franz Wagner who already showcase advanced shot-creation skills.
Unfortunately, they’re not quite at the level of being guys you give the ball to and get out of the way; they’re good, but it would be a surprise if either made the All-Star team this year. Moreover, each ends up having to do too much right now because the backcourt is so incredibly underskilled. It’s one thing to say your 6-foot-9 guy has guard-like skills; it’s another to actually have him playing point guard.
Aside from Anthony, Orlando’s guards are neither spacers nor creators. Fultz, Suggs and Black all are shooting liabilities, to say the least; Banchero is, at this point, a below-average shooter, and nobody the Magic play is all that concerned about Wendell Carter Jr. firing away from distance either. Additionally, which guard on this team do you feel good about running a pick-and-roll? Anthony with the second unit, maybe?
Orlando was so desperate for shooting in 2022-23 that it played Terrence Ross 22 minutes a game until Gary Harris returned and settled things down by erupting for 43.1 percent shooting from 3. That was an outlier, obviously, but more worryingly, there isn’t anybody else who is a deep threat. Harris and Wagner are the only ones of the 12 returning main roster players with career 3-point shooting marks above the very modest bar of 35 percent. The Magic were 22nd in 3-point frequency and 24th in accuracy last year, and even that felt borderline miraculous; they needed Harris and Mo Bamba to clear 40 percent to get there.
The Magic tried to address the shooting in the offseason by adding Joe Ingles and reaching for (er..drafting) Jett Howard, but both figure to be secondary players in this team’s rotation mix.
The biggest threat to my under call is that Orlando pushes in some chips on a win-now trade, which is possible given the surfeit of expiring contracts and young players. (Malcolm Brogdon would fit nicely, I must say.) However, as with the Thunder above, that moment still feels a year away.
In terms of, shall we say, other incentives, this isn’t perceived as a particularly strong draft, and the Magic have done enough losing already, so I don’t see them going into a Blazer-esque tank mode. They could lightly ease off on the throttle in the last week or two if they’re eliminated from the Play-In, though. I doubt that will matter; I think the Magic will have such a tough time scoring that they won’t get to 37 even if they sprint through the tape.