SOUL wrote:pepe1991 wrote:Moronic comment by Weltman, and shows how coach is just puppet and why they elected to select coach without previous coaching experience, because he can be bullied and told what to do.
Fact that we are 5 months away from opening night and have president of basketball operations talking about "starting lineups" before free agency tells me a lot what i pretty much knew . Weltman is hands on in every aspect of this team and all post failures are direct result of his misjudgments.
Suggs and Fultz starting 5 is squivlvalent of starting Reggie Jackson and MCW in same starting 5 . Sentiment is only " expetations" that are subjective thing.
This is "starting 5" is another nugget that somebody in Vegas was banking on when they projected Magic to have 29th record for upcomming season.
Just for sake or argument, what if Hampton goes into a season camp and just kills Futlz and Suggs? HE still isn't starting because it hurts Weltman's ego or?
What if Cole is best guard by wide margin, we still don't start him? What if Isaac is head and shoulders better than Banchero?
What if whoever at C position outplays Wendell, we still not starting that guy?
Fact that we are 22-60 team and have cemented starting 5, handpicked by nothing but ego of president of basketball operations is major red flag for rebuild.
Young lineup means jack s***. Suns had youngest starting 5 in nba history . From that starting 5 grand total of One player stayed long term
Didn't you complain with Oladipo lineup that nobody knew their roles and everybody was fighting for stardom though?
If Suggs is outworking everybody in preseason even if his shot was bad last year, does he not deserve to start because of a bad shot? Can he shoot league average or just below it next year? If our forwards are the one providing the shooting and our guards are setting pace/playing great defense, maybe that'll be our style. We have to play to our strengths because we certainly don't have the shooting that the Warriors do or the star power like Nuggets/Bucks/Sixers with superstars.
And if you set roles/rotations early or what you expect them to be, it lets people settle into roles more easily. It can easily change if it works out or if it doesn't work out. Nobody thought our crappy little lineup last year would have the best +/- and advanced metrics early on, but we found that out just by playing it. Obviously it turned bad pretty quick but.. people said it was too young yet it was actually working for a bit.
I see no real advantage of seeking the most optimal lineup day 1 of the season. Put the guys in that you put draft stock into and tanked a year for. Give them time to mess up, but hold them accountable/sub them out when it becomes obvious their play is a complete negative. It's not rocket science.
I feel like we're one of the few forums that looks at our young players and goes "Nah, don't play them together, they don't have the x/y/z it takes to be world champions" while they're literally 19 and 20 year olds trying to figure out their roles.
Didn't you complain with Oladipo lineup that nobody knew their roles and everybody was fighting for stardom though?
Oladipo complained. So you had "cornerstone" who thought whole thought process was bu****.
If Suggs is outworking everybody in preseason even if his shot was bad last year, does he not deserve to start because of a bad shot?
Yes, in that scenario he does deserve starting PG. In that case, Fultz is bench player.
If our forwards are the one providing the shooting and our guards are setting pace/playing great defense, maybe that'll be our style.
What forwards will provide you spacing?
Banchero shot 33,8% for 3 at college, where line is foot shorter.
Wendell Cartere is career 29,8% three point shooter who peaked at 32,7%.
Isaac is career 33% three point shooter.
Wagner is only player who can make shots.
leagues average 3 point shooting over last 3 yeras has been close to 36,3%I see no real advantage of seeking the most optimal lineup day 1 of the season. Put the guys in that you put draft stock into and tanked a year for. Give them time to mess up, but hold them accountable/sub them out when it becomes obvious their play is a complete negative. It's not rocket science.
Who will hold them accountable? Coach who is stripped from main purpose of his job, so he has other people behind him, who make lineup decision ? Don't you see how toxic this Weltman comment is? He pretty much showed that coach has no power on team. Why even have him? Why Weltman isn't coach? Too lazy to travel?
Her'es the crazy idea. Sign f*** shooting guard who will start at his natural positon. There are plenty of cheap optoins who don't command long term salary. ( Bryn Forbes for example or just resign Harris for 1 year , or 1+1 on team option)
Not only that it will help your PG ( Fultz, Suggs, whoever) look better, it will also showcase Banchero in better light.
AND, it will allow you to even play Fultz and Suggs in sporadic ways where you can test them in lineups, without them being runned over by teams that actually have one thing they don't provide- spacing.
I can't imagine how trully horrific this team will be if "masterplan " for this season is to play Suggs & Fultz and bring Cole and Hampton off bench . Those will be the worst guard rotations NBA has seen since 76ers lost 72 out of 82 games. Isaiah Cannan & Ish Smith starting level bad.
How da *** will Suggs ( or Fultz) benefit from playing with each other? One will dribble, other will be spotting up for his 28% catch and shoot? Than next possession they will reverse roles?
How will Banchero benefit from drive & kick game if kick is to 2 guards who can't make jumpshots to save their lifes?
How will Wagner have any driving lines if he is surrounded by 4 sub 33% shooters?
And answer is simple. You won't. You won't develop 6 young players at once. They will step each other's toe and stunt each other's growth because their games overlap and don't compliment each other.
Young players show best development & maturity when they are given structure and defined role. Magic, just seems to repeat their Payton, Oladipo, Hezonja, Harris scenario with new faces, but with same incompetence at top.
Quick fix: trade Fultz , Cole, Hampton and even Isaac for guys who can play with Banchero, Wagner and Suggs and compliment their skillset.
Will it happen? No. Why? Because out front office is too busy plotting their 10- years of nothigness plan before retirment and any "higher risks" would undercut their best efforts to never commit to anything.