Magic Superlatives
Moderators: ChosenSavior, UCF, Knightro, UCFJayBird, Def Swami, Howard Mass
Magic Superlatives
- eyriq
- Retired Mod
- Posts: 33,466
- And1: 9,455
- Joined: Mar 25, 2008
- Location: #TheLab
- Contact:
-
Magic Superlatives
#Magic superlatives for 2023-24:
Fill in the blanks
• Best Player:
• Most Overrated:
• Most Underrated:
• Could Surprise:
• Takes a Leap:
• Prove-it Year:
• Key Addition:
Fun thing somebody posted on discord
Fill in the blanks
• Best Player:
• Most Overrated:
• Most Underrated:
• Could Surprise:
• Takes a Leap:
• Prove-it Year:
• Key Addition:
Fun thing somebody posted on discord
Re: Magic Superlatives
-
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,047
- And1: 2,157
- Joined: Jul 08, 2019
-
Re: Magic Superlatives
eyriq wrote:#Magic superlatives for 2023-24:
Fill in the blanks
• Best Player:
• Most Overrated:
• Most Underrated:
• Could Surprise:
• Takes a Leap:
• Prove-it Year:
• Key Addition:
Fun thing somebody posted on discord
• Best Player: Franz
• Most Overrated: Isaac
• Most Underrated: Cole
• Could Surprise: Jalen
• Takes a Leap: Goga
• Prove-it Year: Markelle ( for the 5th consecutive)
• Key Addition: HaHaHa, as if (ok, Black)
Re: Magic Superlatives
- drsd
- RealGM
- Posts: 39,039
- And1: 8,895
- Joined: Mar 16, 2003
-
Re: Magic Superlatives
• Best Player: F-Wagner (he is two way and Banchero is just an offensive player)
• Most Overrated: G-Harris (his stats hide how bad he is)
• Most Underrated: Fultz (Fultz led to wins last year)
• Could Surprise: Suggs (maybe he develops to a SG)
• Takes a Leap: Banchero (could average 12 FTA per game this year)
• Prove-it Year: Fultz (must, must, must lead the team to the playoffs)
• Key Addition: Ingles (rookies are horrible and he will be a glue guy)
EDIT: "Key Addition" might not be know yet, as there really needs to be a trade.
• Most Overrated: G-Harris (his stats hide how bad he is)
• Most Underrated: Fultz (Fultz led to wins last year)
• Could Surprise: Suggs (maybe he develops to a SG)
• Takes a Leap: Banchero (could average 12 FTA per game this year)
• Prove-it Year: Fultz (must, must, must lead the team to the playoffs)
• Key Addition: Ingles (rookies are horrible and he will be a glue guy)
EDIT: "Key Addition" might not be know yet, as there really needs to be a trade.
Re: Magic Superlatives
- eyriq
- Retired Mod
- Posts: 33,466
- And1: 9,455
- Joined: Mar 25, 2008
- Location: #TheLab
- Contact:
-
Re: Magic Superlatives
• Best Player: Paolo
• Most Overrated: Fultz
• Most Underrated: Moritz
• Could Surprise: Suggs
• Takes a Leap: Paolo
• Prove-it Year: JI
• Key Addition: Black
• Most Overrated: Fultz
• Most Underrated: Moritz
• Could Surprise: Suggs
• Takes a Leap: Paolo
• Prove-it Year: JI
• Key Addition: Black
Re: Magic Superlatives
-
- Sixth Man
- Posts: 1,660
- And1: 1,997
- Joined: Apr 17, 2018
-
Re: Magic Superlatives
• Best Player: Franz
• Most Overrated: Fultz
• Most Underrated: WCJ
• Could Surprise: Suggs
• Takes a Leap: Paolo
• Prove-it Year: all non rookie PG
• Key Addition: next season Ingles / future Black
• Most Overrated: Fultz
• Most Underrated: WCJ
• Could Surprise: Suggs
• Takes a Leap: Paolo
• Prove-it Year: all non rookie PG
• Key Addition: next season Ingles / future Black
Re: Magic Superlatives
-
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,365
- And1: 1,348
- Joined: Mar 01, 2011
Re: Magic Superlatives
eyriq wrote:#Magic superlatives for 2023-24:
Fill in the blanks
• Best Player:
• Most Overrated:
• Most Underrated:
• Could Surprise:
• Takes a Leap:
• Prove-it Year:
• Key Addition:
Fun thing somebody posted on discord
• Best Player: Franz
• Most Overrated: Cash Considerations
• Most Underrated: WCJ
• Could Surprise: Fultz
• Takes a Leap: Suggs
• Prove-it Year: Cole
• Key Addition: Black
Re: Magic Superlatives
- SOUL
- Retired Mod
- Posts: 58,723
- And1: 40,757
- Joined: Dec 11, 2006
- Location: █████████████
-
Re: Magic Superlatives
• Best Player: Paolo (becomes a legit #1)
• Most Overrated: Moe W (I find his defense/outside shooting negates the good)
• Most Underrated: Suggs (will do all the little things people don't appreciate)
• Could Surprise: Isaac (if he stays healthy, that's a surprise)
• Takes a Leap: Paolo (if I think he becomes best player, it means he leaps Franz)
• Prove-it Year: Fultz (if he shoots threes off the dribble and at a higher rate, discussion on him changes)
• Key Addition: Black (but also voting for surprise trade at deadline)
• Most Overrated: Moe W (I find his defense/outside shooting negates the good)
• Most Underrated: Suggs (will do all the little things people don't appreciate)
• Could Surprise: Isaac (if he stays healthy, that's a surprise)
• Takes a Leap: Paolo (if I think he becomes best player, it means he leaps Franz)
• Prove-it Year: Fultz (if he shoots threes off the dribble and at a higher rate, discussion on him changes)
• Key Addition: Black (but also voting for surprise trade at deadline)
www.rareslums.com // please support my writing!
Re: Magic Superlatives
- fendilim
- RealGM
- Posts: 31,830
- And1: 5,470
- Joined: Jun 11, 2002
- Location: 孫悟空, 时间太?!
Re: Magic Superlatives
eyriq wrote:#Magic superlatives for 2023-24:
Fill in the blanks
• Best Player:
• Most Overrated:
• Most Underrated:
• Could Surprise:
• Takes a Leap:
• Prove-it Year:
• Key Addition:
Fun thing somebody posted on discord
Best player: paolo
Most overrated: caleb houstan
Got a promise to be drafted. But he is nothing special. Best skill is being standstill shooter. Not even elite at it.
Most underrated: suggs
Elite defender. Offensive improvement this year is overlooked
Could surprise: cole
Wildcard. Will surprise especially if he isn’t able to get extension.
Takes a leap: franz
Hoping he becomes more aggressive next year. He defers to his teammates. We need him to be more aggressive to show his is a apt to be a top offensive option. He is playing for the MAX extension next year too.
Prove it year: paolo
This year, he has to prove he can be THE man once team already have him on their scouting report.
Key addition: jett howard
Book it! Everyone expects him to be ****. Lol So underrated, can’t go anywhere but up.

Re: Magic Superlatives
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 18,355
- And1: 8,422
- Joined: Jan 21, 2017
-
Re: Magic Superlatives
• Best Player: Paolo…he’s got his feet under him now and pushes for All-Star status
• Most Overrated: Fultz…he’s out there, he’s not messing up, but he’s not really adding
• Most Underrated: Suggs…we focus on shortcomings, but when he’s in the game- you can feel the intensity. Effort on D is contagious.
• Could Surprise: Goga…he’s #2 now at C, if WCJ misses any time, we’ll get a real look. Big, physical, rim-protector?
• Takes a Leap: Suggs again…if his shooting ticks up again, the questions start to go away and he’s solid
• Prove-it Year: Cole…if his BBIQ & efficiency improve again, he could be QB1 and get paid to stay and start post-TD
• Key Addition: Ingles…he’s good for a 5% improvement (across the whole roster) in attitude, locker room, ball movement, BBIQ, humor
• Most Overrated: Fultz…he’s out there, he’s not messing up, but he’s not really adding
• Most Underrated: Suggs…we focus on shortcomings, but when he’s in the game- you can feel the intensity. Effort on D is contagious.
• Could Surprise: Goga…he’s #2 now at C, if WCJ misses any time, we’ll get a real look. Big, physical, rim-protector?
• Takes a Leap: Suggs again…if his shooting ticks up again, the questions start to go away and he’s solid
• Prove-it Year: Cole…if his BBIQ & efficiency improve again, he could be QB1 and get paid to stay and start post-TD
• Key Addition: Ingles…he’s good for a 5% improvement (across the whole roster) in attitude, locker room, ball movement, BBIQ, humor
Re: Magic Superlatives
- tiderulz
- RealGM
- Posts: 36,916
- And1: 14,847
- Joined: Jun 16, 2010
- Location: Atlanta
-
Re: Magic Superlatives
• Best Player: Franz, efficient 2 way player
• Most Overrated: Fultz
• Most Underrated: Cole (numbers show, he plays the PG spot pretty well right now)
• Could Surprise: Jett (i know i didnt like the pick, but he has a chance to show his shooting value)
• Takes a Leap: Paolo (if he can improve defense and 3 pt shooting could make him our #1)
• Prove-it Year: Suggs (has to show his offense can improve), close 2nd ISaac (though i dont believe he will ever be healthy again)
• Key Addition: Ingles (improve bench offense/shooting and be the adult voice in the locker room)
• Most Overrated: Fultz
• Most Underrated: Cole (numbers show, he plays the PG spot pretty well right now)
• Could Surprise: Jett (i know i didnt like the pick, but he has a chance to show his shooting value)
• Takes a Leap: Paolo (if he can improve defense and 3 pt shooting could make him our #1)
• Prove-it Year: Suggs (has to show his offense can improve), close 2nd ISaac (though i dont believe he will ever be healthy again)
• Key Addition: Ingles (improve bench offense/shooting and be the adult voice in the locker room)
Re: Magic Superlatives
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 22,960
- And1: 18,953
- Joined: Jan 10, 2016
-
Re: Magic Superlatives
Let's play this
• Best Player: Franz Wagner
• Most Overrated: Fultz
• Most Underrated: Cole Anthony
• Could Surprise: Black
• Takes a Leap: hopefully Suggs
• Prove-it Year: Suggs
• Key Addition: who? Ingles?
• Best Player: Franz Wagner
• Most Overrated: Fultz
• Most Underrated: Cole Anthony
• Could Surprise: Black
• Takes a Leap: hopefully Suggs
• Prove-it Year: Suggs
• Key Addition: who? Ingles?

Life is what happens when you're busy making other plans. -John Lennon
Re: Magic Superlatives
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 18,355
- And1: 8,422
- Joined: Jan 21, 2017
-
Re: Magic Superlatives
tiderulz wrote:• Best Player: Franz, efficient 2 way player
• Most Overrated: Fultz
• Most Underrated: Cole (numbers show, he plays the PG spot pretty well right now)
• Could Surprise: Jett (i know i didnt like the pick, but he has a chance to show his shooting value)
• Takes a Leap: Paolo (if he can improve defense and 3 pt shooting could make him our #1)
• Prove-it Year: Suggs (has to show his offense can improve), close 2nd ISaac (though i dont believe he will ever be healthy again)
• Key Addition: Ingles (improve bench offense/shooting and be the adult voice in the locker room)
This has got to be our last try with Isaac…and he deserves it, imo, he’s that impactful, even in a limited deployment. But…there comes a time to move on. Hopefully, he’s healthy, but Jan 10 is the fully-guaranteed date…I’d say that’s THE day for him & ORL
Re: Magic Superlatives
- tiderulz
- RealGM
- Posts: 36,916
- And1: 14,847
- Joined: Jun 16, 2010
- Location: Atlanta
-
Re: Magic Superlatives
Skybox wrote:tiderulz wrote:• Best Player: Franz, efficient 2 way player
• Most Overrated: Fultz
• Most Underrated: Cole (numbers show, he plays the PG spot pretty well right now)
• Could Surprise: Jett (i know i didnt like the pick, but he has a chance to show his shooting value)
• Takes a Leap: Paolo (if he can improve defense and 3 pt shooting could make him our #1)
• Prove-it Year: Suggs (has to show his offense can improve), close 2nd ISaac (though i dont believe he will ever be healthy again)
• Key Addition: Ingles (improve bench offense/shooting and be the adult voice in the locker room)
This has got to be our last try with Isaac…and he deserves it, imo, he’s that impactful, even in a limited deployment. But…there comes a time to move on. Hopefully, he’s healthy, but Jan 10 is the fully-guaranteed date…I’d say that’s THE day for him & ORL
i cant say "he deserves it". i just think its time to move on because he wont be healthy
Re: Magic Superlatives
-
- Head Coach
- Posts: 6,068
- And1: 3,405
- Joined: Jul 01, 2015
-
Re: Magic Superlatives
• Best Player: Franz Wagner- doesnt need any comment
• Most Overrated: Markelle Fultz- same
• Most Underrated: Wendell Carter- often doesnt mentioned as core while being arguably our best player last season
• Could Surprise: Bitadze- he played well with us, and this year we havent signed replacement yet
• Takes a Leap: Banchero- he needs to, wasnt that good last year
• Prove-it Year: Suggs- roster space getting tight, will have to fight for minutes
• Key Addition: Black- we drafted him despite his lack of shooting and despite having so many guards. Weltmans saw something special
• Most Overrated: Markelle Fultz- same
• Most Underrated: Wendell Carter- often doesnt mentioned as core while being arguably our best player last season
• Could Surprise: Bitadze- he played well with us, and this year we havent signed replacement yet
• Takes a Leap: Banchero- he needs to, wasnt that good last year
• Prove-it Year: Suggs- roster space getting tight, will have to fight for minutes
• Key Addition: Black- we drafted him despite his lack of shooting and despite having so many guards. Weltmans saw something special
My money is on Banchero going number 1 !
Re: Magic Superlatives
- MagicHolland
- General Manager
- Posts: 7,620
- And1: 312
- Joined: Apr 15, 2004
-
Re: Magic Superlatives
Lol @ most overrated being 90% Fultz
how can you be called most overrated by pretty much everyone
guess he’s not that overrated after all.
Look I’m not going to sit here and try to convince everyone how Fultz is the second coming of Jesus, he definitely has his shortcomings. But I’m going to feel good if Fultz shows out upcoming season. For one because we as a team would benefit greatly from that but also because I’d feel vindicated in my thrust in Fultz as a player and a teammate.
That being said, I might be very wrong and this might come back to haunt me. I don’t care
Carry on with the list, I don’t want to make this one about Fultz too..!


Look I’m not going to sit here and try to convince everyone how Fultz is the second coming of Jesus, he definitely has his shortcomings. But I’m going to feel good if Fultz shows out upcoming season. For one because we as a team would benefit greatly from that but also because I’d feel vindicated in my thrust in Fultz as a player and a teammate.
That being said, I might be very wrong and this might come back to haunt me. I don’t care

Carry on with the list, I don’t want to make this one about Fultz too..!
Re: Magic Superlatives
- MagicHolland
- General Manager
- Posts: 7,620
- And1: 312
- Joined: Apr 15, 2004
-
Re: Magic Superlatives
• Best Player: Franz Wagner
• Most Overrated: hardest one.. Bol? Also I expect Goga to disappear
• Most Underrated: Cole Anthony, guilty myself. The problem is that I expect him to want a role that we won’t give him. As a 6th man he’s Great!
• Could Surprise: Jett, as shooting is a big need. If he provides that he could get a bigger role than you’d expect.
• Takes a Leap: Suggs, time to push Harris out of the starting lineup.
• Prove-it Year: Fultz, so many doubters. He has to be the one to prove he can carry this team as a leader.
• Key Addition: does JI count?
• Most Overrated: hardest one.. Bol? Also I expect Goga to disappear
• Most Underrated: Cole Anthony, guilty myself. The problem is that I expect him to want a role that we won’t give him. As a 6th man he’s Great!
• Could Surprise: Jett, as shooting is a big need. If he provides that he could get a bigger role than you’d expect.
• Takes a Leap: Suggs, time to push Harris out of the starting lineup.
• Prove-it Year: Fultz, so many doubters. He has to be the one to prove he can carry this team as a leader.
• Key Addition: does JI count?
Re: Magic Superlatives
-
- Sixth Man
- Posts: 1,707
- And1: 508
- Joined: Feb 15, 2006
- Location: Fort Myers, FL
-
Re: Magic Superlatives
. Best Player: Franz
• Most Overrated: wcj
• Most Underrated: okeke
• Could Surprise: black
• Takes a Leap: fultz
• Prove-it Year: isaac
• Key Addition: black
• Most Overrated: wcj
• Most Underrated: okeke
• Could Surprise: black
• Takes a Leap: fultz
• Prove-it Year: isaac
• Key Addition: black
Re: Magic Superlatives
- VFX
- RealGM
- Posts: 18,313
- And1: 16,189
- Joined: May 30, 2016
Re: Magic Superlatives
BP: Franz. Obviously.
OR: Faultz bc of Twitter and Magic media
UR: Cole
Surprise: BlackMagic
Leap: Year 2 Paolo
Prove-it-Year: Suggs offense
Key Addition: Jingles so we don’t have to play Okeke
OR: Faultz bc of Twitter and Magic media
UR: Cole
Surprise: BlackMagic
Leap: Year 2 Paolo
Prove-it-Year: Suggs offense
Key Addition: Jingles so we don’t have to play Okeke
Re: Magic Superlatives
- YosemiteSam
- Starter
- Posts: 2,078
- And1: 873
- Joined: Dec 17, 2003
Re: Magic Superlatives
• Best Player: Paolo
• Most Overrated: Fultz
• Most Underrated: WCJ
• Could Surprise: Suggs
• Takes a Leap: Suggs
• Prove-it Year: Suggs
• Key Addition: Black
• Most Overrated: Fultz
• Most Underrated: WCJ
• Could Surprise: Suggs
• Takes a Leap: Suggs
• Prove-it Year: Suggs
• Key Addition: Black
Re: Magic Superlatives
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 12,141
- And1: 7,307
- Joined: Apr 02, 2017
Re: Magic Superlatives
I'm shocked at how many people are saying that Franz is going to be the best player. I would think Paolo would be the foregone conclusion with all the hype he is getting not only from Orlando fans but the national media.