Page 1 of 108
Official 2024-2024 Magic Trade Ideas Thread
Posted: Fri Oct 18, 2024 5:26 pm
by Knightro
ELIGIBLE TO BE TRADED IMMEDIATELY
Paolo Banchero
Franz Wagner - but has a Poison Pill restriction until JULY 1, 2025
Cole Anthony
Jalen Suggs
Anthony Black
Jett Howard
Tristan Da Silva
Caleb Houstan
ELIGIBLE TO BE TRADED DECEMBER 15, 2024
Kentavious Caldwell-Pope
Moritz Wagner
Goga Bitadze
Gary Harris
Cory Joseph
ELIGIBLE TO BE TRADED JANUARY 6, 2025
Jonathan Isaac
ELIGIBLE TO BE TRADED APRIL 6, 2025
Wendell Carter Jr.
FUTURE PICKS OWED
None
FUTURE PICKS INCOMING
2025 Denver 1st Round - Top 5 Protected
2025 Boston or Memphis 2nd Round - Least Favorable
2026 Phoenix or Washington 1st Round Pick Swap - Least Favorable
2026 Detroit and Milwaukee 2nd Round Pick Swap - Most Favorable 2 of 3 between Detroit/Orlando/Milwaukee
2027 Boston 2nd Round
2028 Washington or LA Lakers 2nd Round - Most Favorable
2030 Milwaukee 2nd Round
2030 New Orleans 2nd Round Pick Swap
2031 New Orleans 2nd Round Pick Swap
Have at it.
Re: Official 2024-2024 Magic Trade Ideas Thread
Posted: Fri Oct 18, 2024 7:41 pm
by GelbeWand09
I think we dont need that thread as long as Weltman is here.

Re: Official 2024-2024 Magic Trade Ideas Thread
Posted: Fri Oct 18, 2024 8:10 pm
by eyriq
The "ideal" rotation from my perspective is:
Point guard: AB
Combo guard: Cole
Shooting guard: Suggs
Swingman: KCP
Small forward: Franz
Combo forward: TDS
Power forward: Paolo
Combo big: WCJ
Quick center: JI
Power center: Goga
To improve here I'd upgrade the combo guard.
So the trade pieces are Cole, Harris, Moe, Jett, and Caleb. The target would be someone like Keyonte George but older and cheaper. A primary playmaker that can win 6th man of the year.
Re: Official 2024-2024 Magic Trade Ideas Thread
Posted: Fri Oct 18, 2024 8:18 pm
by RichCollab
eyriq wrote:The "ideal" rotation from my perspective is:
Point guard: AB
Combo guard: Cole
Shooting guard: Suggs
Combo forward: KCP
Small forward: Franz
Combo forward: TDS
Power forward: Paolo
Combo big: WCJ
Quick center: JI
Power center: Goga
To improve here I'd upgrade the combo guard.
So the trade pieces are Cole, Harris, Moe, Jett, and Caleb. The target would be someone like Keyonte George but older and cheaper. A primary playmaker that can win 6th man of the year.
Kenny is a combo forward?
Re: Official 2024-2024 Magic Trade Ideas Thread
Posted: Fri Oct 18, 2024 8:28 pm
by eyriq
I don't know, can he guard small forwards and wings?
Re: Official 2024-2024 Magic Trade Ideas Thread
Posted: Fri Oct 18, 2024 9:39 pm
by MasterGMer
Remember, who is our President of Operation

Re: Official 2024-2024 Magic Trade Ideas Thread
Posted: Fri Oct 18, 2024 9:47 pm
by Skybox
RichCollab wrote:eyriq wrote:The "ideal" rotation from my perspective is:
Point guard: AB
Combo guard: Cole
Shooting guard: Suggs
Combo forward: KCP
Small forward: Franz
Combo forward: TDS
Power forward: Paolo
Combo big: WCJ
Quick center: JI
Power center: Goga
To improve here I'd upgrade the combo guard.
So the trade pieces are Cole, Harris, Moe, Jett, and Caleb. The target would be someone like Keyonte George but older and cheaper. A primary playmaker that can win 6th man of the year.
Kenny is a combo forward?
No…I really don’t know where these imaginary categories came from but certain skills are required and redundant similar players (like Suggs and KCP and Harris at SG is a strong rotation - with the third guy playing sporadic minutes) make for a deep rotation. There’s nothing wrong with similar players coming off the bench to execute the same scheme. I like having “different looks” but it’s even better to come at them in waves and impose YOUR game on the opponents.
Re: Official 2024-2024 Magic Trade Ideas Thread
Posted: Fri Oct 18, 2024 9:53 pm
by eyriq
Skybox wrote:RichCollab wrote:eyriq wrote:The "ideal" rotation from my perspective is:
Point guard: AB
Combo guard: Cole
Shooting guard: Suggs
Combo forward: KCP
Small forward: Franz
Combo forward: TDS
Power forward: Paolo
Combo big: WCJ
Quick center: JI
Power center: Goga
To improve here I'd upgrade the combo guard.
So the trade pieces are Cole, Harris, Moe, Jett, and Caleb. The target would be someone like Keyonte George but older and cheaper. A primary playmaker that can win 6th man of the year.
Kenny is a combo forward?
No…I really don’t know where these imaginary categories came from but certain skills are required and redundant similar players (like Suggs and KCP and Harris at SG is a strong rotation - with the third guy playing sporadic minutes) make for a deep rotation. There’s nothing wrong with similar players coming off the bench to execute the same scheme. I like having “different looks” but it’s even better to come at them in waves and impose YOUR game on the opponents.
There was an article a long time ago about the perfect rotation. These are the categories from that article. Effectively the idea is to find multi-positional bench guys to allow for the most flexible lineup configurations around your starters.
Re: Official 2024-2024 Magic Trade Ideas Thread
Posted: Fri Oct 18, 2024 9:56 pm
by eyriq
I meant swingman not combo forward for KCP anyway
Re: Official 2024-2024 Magic Trade Ideas Thread
Posted: Fri Oct 18, 2024 10:05 pm
by MasterGMer
Should Magic monitor Giannis situation in Milwaukee?
Re: Official 2024-2024 Magic Trade Ideas Thread
Posted: Fri Oct 18, 2024 10:26 pm
by Knightro
MasterGMer wrote:Should Magic monitor Giannis situation in Milwaukee?
Of course. So should every other team in the league.
Re: Official 2024-2024 Magic Trade Ideas Thread
Posted: Fri Oct 18, 2024 10:29 pm
by VFX
eyriq wrote:The "ideal" rotation from my perspective is:
Point guard: AB
Combo guard: Cole
Shooting guard: Suggs
Combo forward: KCP
Small forward: Franz
Combo forward: TDS
Power forward: Paolo
Combo big: WCJ
Quick center: JI
Power center: Goga
To improve here I'd upgrade the combo guard.
So the trade pieces are Cole, Harris, Moe, Jett, and Caleb. The target would be someone like Keyonte George but older and cheaper. A primary playmaker that can win 6th man of the year.
I get that this is your perspective to compartmentalize the roster, but why? Front Offices don't think this way.
Not saying I disagree with your list other than Jett. Don't see them moving a 6-7 21 year old SG/SF for another wing of the same variety they simply didn't draft.
Re: Official 2024-2024 Magic Trade Ideas Thread
Posted: Fri Oct 18, 2024 10:32 pm
by MasterGMer
Knightro wrote:MasterGMer wrote:Should Magic monitor Giannis situation in Milwaukee?
Of course. So should every other team in the league.
What about De'Aaron Fox situation in Sacramento?
Re: Official 2024-2024 Magic Trade Ideas Thread
Posted: Fri Oct 18, 2024 10:34 pm
by eyriq
VFX wrote:eyriq wrote:The "ideal" rotation from my perspective is:
Point guard: AB
Combo guard: Cole
Shooting guard: Suggs
Combo forward: KCP
Small forward: Franz
Combo forward: TDS
Power forward: Paolo
Combo big: WCJ
Quick center: JI
Power center: Goga
To improve here I'd upgrade the combo guard.
So the trade pieces are Cole, Harris, Moe, Jett, and Caleb. The target would be someone like Keyonte George but older and cheaper. A primary playmaker that can win 6th man of the year.
I get that this is your perspective to compartmentalize the roster, but why? Front Offices don't think this way.
Not saying I disagree with your list other than Jett. Don't see them moving a 6-7 21 year old SG/SF for another wing of the same variety they simply didn't draft.
It's just my framework for thinking about the rotation and team needs.
Re: Official 2024-2024 Magic Trade Ideas Thread
Posted: Fri Oct 18, 2024 11:39 pm
by Skybox
VFX wrote:eyriq wrote:The "ideal" rotation from my perspective is:
Point guard: AB
Combo guard: Cole
Shooting guard: Suggs
Combo forward: KCP
Small forward: Franz
Combo forward: TDS
Power forward: Paolo
Combo big: WCJ
Quick center: JI
Power center: Goga
To improve here I'd upgrade the combo guard.
So the trade pieces are Cole, Harris, Moe, Jett, and Caleb. The target would be someone like Keyonte George but older and cheaper. A primary playmaker that can win 6th man of the year.
I get that this is your perspective to compartmentalize the roster, but why? Front Offices don't think this way.
Not saying I disagree with your list other than Jett. Don't see them moving a 6-7 21 year old SG/SF for another wing of the same variety they simply didn't draft.
Square peg
Re: Official 2024-2024 Magic Trade Ideas Thread
Posted: Sat Oct 19, 2024 11:10 am
by tiderulz
Knightro wrote:MasterGMer wrote:Should Magic monitor Giannis situation in Milwaukee?
Of course. So should every other team in the league.
he turns 30 in about 6 weeks. Yes, he is a physical freak, but his injuries are starting to add up. played 70+ games once in the last 5 years.
Re: Official 2024-2024 Magic Trade Ideas Thread
Posted: Sat Oct 19, 2024 11:22 am
by J-Mezzy
I just don’t know what we’d have to give up for the freak
Franz
Suggs
Bunch of firsts
Don’t think they’d take that
Re: Official 2024-2024 Magic Trade Ideas Thread
Posted: Sat Oct 19, 2024 12:04 pm
by T-Cat
We should go after Atlanta Hawks unprotected pick via Spurs and CP3

Re: Official 2024-2024 Magic Trade Ideas Thread
Posted: Sat Oct 19, 2024 3:23 pm
by JBSouthpaw
MasterGMer wrote:Remember, who is our President of Operation

The guy who’s almost every move has paid off since drafting Bamba?
Re: Official 2024-2024 Magic Trade Ideas Thread
Posted: Sat Oct 19, 2024 3:36 pm
by drsd
Cole Anthony for Caleb Martin (or any other decent MLE-type SF e.g. Naji Marshall, etc.)
Suggs/Black/Joseph
Caldwell-Pope/Harris/Howard
F-Wagner/Martin/Houston
Banchero/Isaac/da Silva
Carter/M-Wagner/Bitadze
See how much this one little trade balances the roster???
..