mjkvol wrote:GoSixersBro wrote:mjkvol wrote:
Curry is a level of greatness that James could never dream of touching. With one team his entire career, never abandoned a franchise after winning there and wrecking it chasing his precious 'legacy', never met in hotel rooms plotting 'superteams', doesn't make it all about himself at the expense of his team, doesn't throw other players and management under the bus, etc., etc.
Maybe I see sports greatness a little differently, but to me it's as much about things like being an invaluable part of an organization and, elevating that organization to heights it never reached, loyalty to teammates, being a class act, and a touch of humility as it is about rings and stats. James might be the greatest physical specimen that ever played, but true greatness? Hardly.
Just my opinion, of course.
I respect your opinion and agree with a lot of your points. I think when it comes to LeBron's greatness, there are two categories that it consists of: raw basketball ability/skill/talent and then the achievement (awards, how he won them like you said "elevating the team", etc.).
Like you already know, I loathe LeBron the person, but am a massive fan of his basketball ability and talent. I share the same feelings you and Kobble do about how he went about his career (forming super teams, not always taking full responsibility, hypocrisies in pressers, etc.) but to me I think he solidified his greatness in winning in 2016. I think if we're going to knock his Miami rings or the LeMickey Bubble Title 2020, we also have to bring up Curry's 0 Finals MVP's (obviously if he takes down Boston in the same fashion he played Friday he gets a massive boost) and winning 2 with Durant, the ultimate mercenary. Also the 2015 title wasn't all that impressive considering it took them 6 to beat LeBron, Mozgov, Shump, and Delly.
You know I respect your opinion as well, but I disagree with a couple of points here. First, the ultimate mercenary will always be James - he wrote the book and created the template that Durant merely copied.
Second, 2016 was more about Silver stepping in once again and suspending Draymond, which at that point of a Finals was abhorrent and an obvious ploy to try to extend the series. And that Cavs team was also a James creation, with the recruitment of Love, and if not for Irving they never win anyway. 2020 is almost comical being considered a legit ring.
I respect the raw talent of James, but that's as far as it goes. No one has ever gotten away with traveling the way he does multiple times a game, and he is one of the all time whiners. It sickens me to see him placed by a sycophantic national media on the same level as true greats like Jordan, Kobe, Curry, and Bird, all of whom made their claim to greatness with one team, not hopping around the league as if they owned it.
Soon enough he will own it, when he just buys his next superteam in Vegas.
I think this is one of the weaker excuses I've read repeatedly online for the last 6 years trying to discredit the 2016 title. Draymond accumulated his fourth flagrant foul in the Playoffs, which is WILD to think a player is notching basically 1 per series. You gotta be at least borderline dirty to pick up that many. The rule was there and applied to all players. Green himself had earned his reputation since early in his career, which would never lend him any goodwill in the future. The instance itself where he got tangled under LeBron and threw his arm twice at and towards LeBron's groin in was just a confirmation of a pattern he himself had established for years. This wasn't some contested lay-up/dunk where a hard basketball foul is undeservingly labeled as a flagrant. The dude flat out earned that suspension and it's part of the game.
I'm always ready to listen to a theory of the league trying to fix games, because trust me, I know Donaghy was just a patsy in Stern's whole orchestra, but I'm not buying that the refs were just waiting for the perfect moment in the closing minutes to get Draymond out of the game. That Game 4 was very close until the last 5 minutes. You think the refs had a directive to pull this? The whole dust up between Green and LeBron was organic and Draymond being Draymond. He's got no one to blame but himself for that flagrant.
Now even if we can't agree on that point and you say this should have been nothing more than a technical and he should've played Game 5 then that's fine and I'm not doubting momentum shifted. But the Warriors still had 3 games to clinch, especially Game 7 at home in front of their own fans, which I believe lends itself to say if Draymond played Game 5 then we definitely cannot conclude GS wraps it up in 5. Especially considering Draymond flirted with a 32 point triple-double in Game 7 and they still lost.
I don't see us agreeing, but IMO LeBron was flat out Godly that series. In my book, that solidified him as one of the all-time greats and etched him into the Top 5 easily of all-time and a case for Top 3. To take down the 73-9 Warriors while down 1-3 with a pretty meh supporting case compared to the opponent was historical. I also don't really consider those Cavs anywhere close to a superteam because Kyrie was young and unproven (unlike Wade) and Love was a shell of his former self. Lue had to lean on Tristan Thompson, Iman Shumpert and a 36 year old Richard Jefferson. That team was very thin outside LeBron and Kyrie.