Arsenal wrote:Well you got one thing right. Kon will top out as a fourth starter, but probably not on a title team.
And Ace may bust, but the chance to hit on a star is worth far more than the chance to grab a nice role player. That’s the point of such a high draft pick.
I feel like the "star potential" cop out, is just that. An empty and unsubstantiated excuse to grant artificial points to an undeserving player. Every player has degrees of upside that go beyond their current forms regardless of their shapes and/or sizes and this isn't an excuse that exists only for forwards. We're actually seeing that feel, IQ and basketball skill reign supreme in today's day and age. Some of the most impactful and winning players have been unconventional builds . These playoffs alone we've seen Nembhard (wingspan / athleticism), Brunson (age, height), McConnell (complexion) turn near losses into wins and wins into blow outs.
I'm heavily discounting scouting an evaluation process that reverts back to RCSI and/or combine measurements as a crutch.
There's a trend that I posted a while back of how only
one player within The Ringer's T25 had a sub 6.0 box plus minus in college, Ace was at 4.5. This isn't star upside, this is banking on a historical outlier to beat the odds.
There are numerous studies about the correlation between assist to turnover as a predictor of NBA success, just like ft% with deciphering shooting mechanics.
I think some Ace supporters feel like they're taking a brave position in declaring they're interested in "star potential". Who isn't? That doesn't mean the fastest track sprinter automatically rises to the top of the draft board, you have to evaluate and contextualize basketball traits. Again, Ace's profile is littered with red flags of players that are the antithesis of winners, or even NBA caliber players, let alone stars.
The reason why algorithms have been outperforming NBA GMs for years now is because the emotional bias is stripped.
The funny thing is, I remember you and I fighting on the same side for Trey Murphy in 2021. A lot of our fans also discredited him for "star upside" and he's developed into a fantastic NBA player. We weren't spamming buzz words as much back then, we just saw a high level basketball player with translatable skills.