SelfishPlayer wrote:Pau Gasol 7'0" 250 sometimes a PF, sometimes a center depending on what the team needed entering the season or what they want in game from moment to moment. NBA champion...
Tim Duncan 7'00" 250 champion...
LaMarcus Aldridge 6'11" 260...
Zach Randolph 6'9" 260 PF that has experienced deep playoff runs on a perennial playoff team.
Empirical data says that big power forwards can be used successfully in the NBA...
You're attacking a strawman argument. The reason that he can't play PF is not because he's too big. It's because he can't defend the position, can't space, can't set screens, and doesn't look to be a good passer.
Okafor doesn't play anything like those guys.
Duncan is one of the best defensive bigs of our generation. He was also great within the Spurs offense of doing the things that create space and separation for others.
Pau was a great defender, a great passer for a big, and a much better shooter than Okafor is.
Aldridge and Randolph are significantly better shooters than Okafor is. They're also significantly better defenders and probably both better passers. Neither of them has won anything yet though. Aldridge has never made it past the second round and Randolph has been on treadmill teams his whole career, making the conference finals once where they got swept and were never really championship contenders.
Again I'll state - the argument against him succeeding at a smaller position is not because he's too big, but because he's already been horrible at defending his natural position (he was literally last in DRPM for Centers last season). He was too slow to defend bigger guys - how is he going to defend faster guys in a role he's even less familiar with? He was 58th of 61 in ORPM for Centers as well, so it's not like you can even point to his offensive game and say it will make up for his defensive shortcomings. At least Enes Kanter (who was unplayable vs Golden State in the WCF) made up for being 60th out 61 for Centers in DRPM by being 3rd of 61 for Centers in ORPM.















