blargh wrote:stormi wrote:
Tobias in five separate post season runs has yet to match what Poole did in his first (scoring/creating/passing) or what Wiggins did in that championship run absolutely tilting the floor against the Celtics which his phenomenal defense against Jayson Tatum and rebounding. He was the second best player in the finals.
Gordon is an elite rebounder/defender/finisher at the rim. MPJ is maybe the best shooter / movement shooter / contested shot maker in basketball and on high volume.
Tobias is a jack of all trades guy, but elite tools win out when it matters most.
Wow, that is a pretty charitable assessment of MPJ
For the record, last year Tobi and MPJ had identical 31% EFG when shooting highly contested (defender closer than 2 feet) jumpers (> 10 ft).
MPJ shot over 50% from the corner last season and an absurd 62.1% on contested catch & shoot jumpers in the playoffs on volume. Last season he also ranked 1st percentile in shot quality shooting 41.4% on 7.3 attempts per game.
Tobias Harris is not in the conversation with the elite jumbo marksmen in this league, Lauri is another one. Tobias is gunshy. Puts the ball on the floor and dribbles himself into chaos if you make him uncomfortable. He also can't slash or finish at the rim like MPJ.
He's the off-brand version in most categorical metrics. He's probably better at bringing "good vibes" and statpadding in regular season trivial clashes against teams like the Wizards and Hornets though, if that's what we care about the most.
Tobias against the Sixers 4 hardest opponents (2019 TOR, 2020 and 2023 BOS, 2022 MIA):
37.2 mpg (24 games)
14.3 ppg
26.8% 3P%50.6% TS%
Tobias when he was asked simply to stand in the corner, get out of better players' way and be valve release with our best roster of the century and a streamlined path to the finals:
And that's while Embiid had to mark SIakam defensively because he fed Tobias a swift 30 in game 1. I feel like a ball of negativity here, but it just blows my mind that every single year fans watch Tobias put up the same cute regular season act and then jump back on the train of overwhelming hope and belief. He is his traits, and your traits never lie. Is he an elite athlete? No. Can he shut down opposing stars? No. The best case scenario in achieving anything with him performing a significant role would be on the off chance that he, not only goes unconscious from 3, but he's not afraid to pull them when it matters most.
I will say however he is vital to picking up wins in the regular season / round 1. He's a valuable foot soldier, relatively consistent and his health record is impeccable.